Tween Beat
Here's marketing to you, kids; why increasing numbers of entrepreneurs are selling their sights on preteen consumers.
URL:
http://www.entrepreneur.com/magazine/entrepreneur/1999/september/18154.html
Cargo pants are over. The Backstreet Boys are cool--and way
cute. 7th Heaven is the must-see TV show on the new must-see
network, the WB. And, yes, computer literacy is as fundamental as
learning your ABC's.
Welcome to the wonderful world of preteen America. Oh sure, much
fuss is made over the awesome spending power of these kids'
elder siblings--a.k.a., teens. Rest assured, however, that the
legions of 9- to 12-year-olds whimsically referred to as
"tweens" boast a shopping force all their own.
And they're not afraid to use it. "Finally, someone
woke up and smelled the statistics," observes Karen Bokram,
publisher and founding editor of Girls' Life magazine.
"Whichever group has the largest number of people drives the
culture. The only other [comparable group to today's
youngsters] is their parents--the baby boomers--and who the hell
wants to talk about them anymore?"
Who indeed? Although exact figures are hard to come by, we do
know tween purchasing dollars number in the billions--and
that's before tacking on the additional billions worth of
influence these kids exercise over household expenditures.
"More and more parents are ceding power to their kids,"
agrees Dan Acuff, author of What Kids Buy & Why: The
Psychology of Marketing to Kids (Free Press). "Take fast
food--which [restaurants] do we go to? We go to the ones they want.
That's a tremendous influence."
Debra Phillips is a former senior editor for
Entrepreneur.
No one needs to tell Nancy Dennis about this influence. As the
43-year-old founder of the Toronto-based Ch!ckaboom girls'
retail clothing chain, Dennis, along with partners Glenn
Stonehouse, 49, and Arif Noor, 36, courts preteen consumers on a
full-time basis. Convinced there existed an underserved market--and
inspired by the success of Limited Too--Dennis opened the first of
two Ch!ckaboom stores in 1997.
"I saw Ch!ckaboom as going one step further than Limited
Too," Dennis explains. "We really make this a store for
[preteen girls]. We market to them, we talk to them, we serve them.
[We view the shopping experience] through their eyes."
To that end, Dennis and her young sales staff regularly sponsor
in-store events and contests geared toward the tween girl. Perhaps
Ch!ckaboom's most effective marketing tool, however, is the
company's birthday club--on their birthdays, each of the
3,000-plus names in Ch!ckaboom's database receives a card and a
$5 gift certificate. "These little girls aren't getting
mail," Dennis points out, "so when they get something
from Ch!ckaboom, they're thrilled."
For her part, Bokram is struck by the strength of mail-order
catalogs such as the much ballyhooed Delia's--an upstart teen
clothier looking to take its winning formula to tweens. "For
most people, trying to reach this girl is like trying to market to
someone on Mars," Bokram says. "Delia's does a
wonderful job. It managed to build a business where there had been
nothing. No one was marketing to these girls on a catalog basis;
nobody thought it would work."
So much for conventional wisdom.
OK, so maybe you had already figured out the bit about tweens
not being from Mars--or Venus either, for that matter. But that
doesn't mean those boys and girls poised on the threshold of
teendom today don't remain something of a mystery. Exactly who
are these youngsters who seem so much more mature than previous
generations of tweens gone by--yet barely old enough to watch the
teen-ridden angst of TV's hugely popular Dawson's
Creek?
"They live in a technological world," says author
Acuff, who is also president of Youth Market System Consulting and
The Character Lab in Sherman Oaks, California. "Today's
preteens are living in a more complex world."
"There's a real sophistication going on with this
generation," echoes Dennis. "My daughter moved from
Disney to Buffy the Vampire Slayer by age 7."
"There are so many of them--and they're so
bright," adds Bokram. "They've grown up in a world of
information and knowledge that's unmatched. They have access to
more types of information from more sources than we could have ever
imagined."
So it's all the more difficult to grab their attention,
right? Well, yes--and no. Although contemporary tweens enjoy
entertainment options galore--to say nothing of time-consuming
extracurricular pursuits like after-school sports--their minds are
still arguably more focused than many adults.
"Kids' attention spans are better and stronger than
adults," maintains Acuff. "A lot of it is about learning
and meeting challenges. The reason a video game can occupy a
kid's time for three hours is because it has many levels of
challenge."
Of course, that doesn't make kids an easy sell. Warns Acuff,
"Don't underestimate their intelligence."
While you're at it, don't overestimate their
rebelliousness. Although teenagers are generally expected to go a
little James Dean on their parents--their younger counterparts
rarely opt for such adversity. "It's a conformative
time," says Acuff. "[Preteens] conform to peer pressure,
trends, apparel tastes and so forth because they're anxious to
be accepted. They're moving away from the need to be loved
solely by their parents to the need to be loved and accepted by
their peers. It puts a lot of pressure on them."
Without question, this gives businesses a tricky balance to
strike as well. On the one hand, tweens, especially of the
modern-day variety, are grown up enough to scoff at the likes of
Mickey Mouse and his cartoon pals. On the other hand, this is still
an age of innocence.
"There's a gray area," acknowledges Dennis, whose
Ch!ckaboom stores feature nail polish bars but refrain from selling
makeup. "I'm a parent, and I don't want [preteens] to
look like teenagers. This isn't about loss of innocence;
it's about having fun."
"When you think back to when you were 12 years old, that
was the last time in your life when you weren't really trying
to impress [the opposite sex] that much," agrees Bokram.
"You're just happily plodding along, thinking about what
you're going to do with your life. There's a feeling of
optimism and [the idea that] the world is laid out before
you."
Ironically, this generation of tweens may only be matched in
their optimism by their parents--the we-can-change-the-world baby
boomers. "They haven't really lived through bad
times," says Dennis of pre-millennium tweens. "That's
really molded them. There's an optimism and confidence [about
them] that I see."
So who says history never repeats itself?
Yet to suggest there isn't anything new in tween town would
be misleading. Most obviously, there's a greater ethnic
diversity among preteens in the United States now. Then, too,
there's the interactivity of technology. For instance, whereas
baby boomers absorbed product information through TV commercials
while growing up, their children are able to actively explore the
Internet in order to discover the latest in merchandise. And
today's kids aren't just connected via modem--they possess
cell phones and pagers to boot. Such strong communication ties are
welcome given the phenomenon of more two-working-parent
households.
"The increased percentage of working mothers has shifted
more responsibility to the preteen," Acuff says. "By
2001, [these kids will wield] something like $300 billion in
influence."
Which is a reality that checks the heartbeats of all but the
most jaded of entrepreneurs. Even corporate giants are eagerly
targeting young spenders. For starters, there's hip home
furnishings chain Pottery Barn's mail-order venture, Pottery
Barn Kids. Add to that DKNY Kids, Limited Too, Gap Kids and
Abercrombie & Fitch's well-publicized forays into kidswear,
and you get a picture of how influential tweens are becoming. There
are also kid-designated soaps, bottled water, radio and TV
networks, platform shoes and--seriously!--mutual funds.
"This group definitely deserves its own stores,"
insists Dennis, who predicts Ch!ckaboom's 1999 sales figures
will reach $2 million. "People say to me, `This is such a
narrow niche.' It's not. It's a fantastic niche, and
it's only getting better."
For her money, Dennis thinks preteen girls in particular make
for a better market niche than preteen boys--and the consensus
seems to be that she's right. "The only thing freakier to
marketers than young girls is young boys," Bokram wryly points
out. "As tough as girls are, girls also represent predictable
economic stuff--clothes, makeup, shoes, accessories. Guys just
generally aren't as conscious of fashion--they prefer something
simple like khakis."
Just like their teen counterparts, as a matter of fact. That
said, however, entrepreneurs are cautioned against linking tweens
too closely to teens. Popular perceptions to the contrary, tweens
aren't merely teenagers in miniaturized form. Funny as it may
sound, there's a big difference between being 10 years old and
being 14.
"There's this school of thought by less sophisticated
marketers that maintains if you're reaching 15-year-olds, then
you'll get the 12-year-olds, too," says Bokram.
"That's simply not true."
It's a vital lesson for kid-targeting companies to
learn--and stick with. "I don't want the teens,"
Dennis says. "I think when you go into business, you have to
be very focused on who you're going after. I don't want to
be all things to all people."
And this condition of sharp focus extends to resisting the urge
to market to tweens' parents rather than to tweens themselves.
Admittedly, parents are most likely to provide kids with the
financial wherewithal to make purchases, but kids are still the
ultimate decision-makers. Again, it's a tricky balance to
strike.
In his widely hailed research on child-age consumers, author and
Texas A&M University marketing professor James McNeal points
out that there's not one but three different children's
markets. First and foremost, there's the market created by
kids' direct spending. Second, there's the market stemming
from kids' influence over their family's purchases.
Finally, there's the market of the future--that is, courting
kids to eventually become loyal adult consumers. With so much at
stake, it's easy to see why so many eyes are on the tween-age
kids of the baby boomers. They are the present; they are also the
future.
And they aren't an easy sell. But maybe it helps for
entrepreneurs to remain somewhat young at heart themselves.
"I'm probably the perfect person for this business,"
enthuses Ch!ckaboom's Dennis, a loyal viewer of the hip TV
shows Dawson's Creek and Felicity. "I'm
a perpetual [kid] myself."
What's it like to be a tween in 1999? It means reading
everything from Teen People to YM to Girls'
Life to a whole range of skateboarding and surfing magazines.
It means having your own e-mail address--or at least being on your
way to getting one. It means, ultimately, being who you are.
Like 11-year-old Taylor Carico, who listens to teenage singing
superstar Britney Spears and plays volleyball twice a week.
"I'm so busy," says the tween, citing a shopping
preference for department stores like Macy's and Nordstrom. How
much do friends influence her buying decisions? "I don't
usually copy what friends wear," Carico says. "I just
wear what I'm comfortable with."
"A lot of my friends buy stuff they see in magazines,"
offers Cassie Kreitner, 11, who frequently shops at Limited Too and
Old Navy. Describing her generation as "talkative,"
Kreitner says peer pressure goes only so far: "With clothing,
if I see someone [wearing something I like], I might get something
similar to it, but not exactly the same."
For 11-year-old Ricky Norris, watching Pokémon on TV is a
favorite way to spend time--as is occasionally acting in TV
commercials. Like a lot of tweens, Norris also enjoys auto-racing
(as a spectator, not a participant) and playing hockey. What's
cool to him? Vans, Billabong clothing--and Mom surprising him with
gifts of new threads.
"We [shop] together," says Amanda Limburg of herself
and her mother. "We look through the store, and I pick out
what I like, and she picks out what she likes, and we agree on what
to get." Although she still enjoys visiting Disneyland, this
11-year-old admits she's outgrown some Disney stuff and leans
towards such stores as Limited Too, Old Navy and the Gap. How does
she view today's tweens? Replies Limburg, "We're
weird, I think."
Feeling lost in preteen USA? Here's a handy road map to get
you tuned in to the latest and greatest according to today's
tweens.
HOT TV SHOWS:
Ones to watch for this season: New fall TV offerings from the
creators of Dawson's Creek (Wasteland), Party
of Five (Time Of Your Life), and 7th Heaven
(Safe Harbor)
HOT READS:
- Delia's mail-order catalog
HOT BRANDS:
HOT ACTIVITIES:
- Chatting with friends via e-mail
- Studying (Yep, it's cool to be smart.)
HOT MARKETING APPROACH:
Acknowledging the intelligence of today's tweens, à la
Arizona Jeans' recent TV advertising campaign featuring a group
of media-savvy kids mocking the lengths to which companies go to
appear hip. So nix any attempt to adopt the latest lingo or
over-zealous effort to reach tweens at their level. As the
youngsters advise: "Just show us the jeans."
Contact Sources
Ch!ckaboom, (416) 782-6162
Girls' Life,http://www.girlslife.com
Youth Market System, (818) 783-5551, dacuffq@aol.com
Copyright ©
2009 Entrepreneur.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy