Suggestions for training students in using the
internet for career counseling. (Effective
Techniques).
by McCarthy, Christopher J.^Moller, Naomi^Beard, L.
Michelle
The Internet is increasingly important for career counseling;
however, there are few suggestions for training graduate counseling
students how to use this technology. This project sought to address that
lack by having graduate counseling students use a structured interview
with undergraduate volunteer clients to assess which needs could be met
using the Internet. Graduate students then identified relevant Web sites
and explored these in a meeting with the volunteer clients. Results of
class surveys indicated that participants encountered few obstacles
using the Internet and perceived this intervention to be useful.
Implications for training graduate students in using the Internet for
career counseling are discussed.
**********
Although predicting the long-range impact of the Internet on the
counseling field is challenging, it is an important task for career
counseling practitioners to undertake (Harris-Bowlsbey, Dikel, &
Sampson, 1998; Stevens & Lundberg, 1998). First, the Internet
radically affects the accessibility of career-related information in
ways that are important for career counselors and their clients. Second,
the Internet can profoundly alter the process of career counseling by
allowing instant communication among counselors, clients, and even
employers through electronic mail, postings on Web sites, and
videoconferencing (Sampson, 1999). Although a number of resources exist
that document the explosive proliferation of career-related Web sites
currently available (Koonce, 1997), there has as yet been little
systematic exploration of their usefulness as it applies to career
counseling (Sampson, Kolodinsky, & Greeno, 1997). In addition,
despite the increasing body of literature pertaining to integrating the
Internet into the classroom (Kahn, 1997), there are few suggestions for
training career counselors in the use of the Internet.
Because the Internet vastly increases the accessibility of
information, some have wondered whether career counselors will find
themselves by-passed as clients increasingly conduct their own career
searches online (Noll & Graves, 1996). However, Noll and Graves
(1998) argued that career counselors who successfully integrated the
Internet into their interventions would not be left behind. Rather, the
services of career counselors may become ever more important as the
amount of information available online expands exponentially. Although
using the Internet as part of one-to-one, face-to-face counseling with
clients is more time intensive than using it in other modalities (for
example, as part of group interventions or as a homework assignment
completed outside of session), this approach may pay substantial
dividends in helping clients manage the potentially overwhelming amount
of information that is available online. Because career-related
information on the Internet is constantly changing and expanding,
trainin g in its use for one-on-one interventions may also provide a
unique opportunity for counselors-in-training to learn about these
resources and their relative utility for clients.
Harris-Bowlsbey et al. (1998) have identified four broad categories
of career resources on the Internet: assessment services, communication
Web sites, occupational information, and career-related databases.
However, as Stevens and Lundberg (1998) pointed out, seekers of
information on the Internet today are confronted with much the same task
as those using libraries before the advent of the Dewey decimal system:
Vast amounts of information are available, but not necessarily organized
in a coherent manner. In fact, the ease with which individuals who are
surfing the Web can become mired in the sheer volume of information
available has been cited as one of the main barriers to the
Internet's effective use (Presno, 1998). Career counselors can be
of great service to their clients by helping them overcome the possible
discouragement associated with not finding relevant information (Offer
& Watts, 1997). This, of course, means that the counselor must first
be familiar with the various types of information that exi st on the
Internet and the best ways to find it. The latter can be accomplished
with the various search engines now available to navigate the Internet
(Gilster, 1997).
Purpose of the Study
Because the Internet offers both considerable promise and numerous
challenges for career development activities, this study was designed as
an exploratory investigation of the possible benefits and obstacles in
its use for one-on-one career counseling. The intervention was designed
to serve two purposes: (a) to develop graduate counseling students'
Internet career counseling skills and (b) to facilitate the use of these
skills with volunteer undergraduate clients. To accomplish the first
goal, the graduate counseling students developed their facility with the
Internet by learning how to use various search engines to find career
information and then assisting in the design of a class Web page
containing links to relevant career resources. The second goal was
accomplished by having the counseling students use a structured
interview with undergraduate volunteers, assess which of their needs
could be met through the Internet, and then use Internet resources (with
the class Web page serving as a starting point) as part of face-to-face
meetings with their clients.
Two main research questions were therefore explored: (a) How
effective was this intervention perceived to be by both the graduate
counseling students delivering the intervention and the undergraduate
students they worked with? and (b) What barriers to using the Internet
were encountered by both groups? We adapted quantitative surveys to use
in finding the answers to both questions. Semistructured focus groups
were also conducted with the graduate counseling students after the
intervention to probe for information that might not have been conveyed
in the quantitative surveys. In the following sections, we provide a
description of the implementation of this project as part of a
graduate-level career counseling class. The results of the project are
then presented, along with a summary of the project's implications
for training graduate students in the use of the Internet for career
interventions and suggestions for future research.
Method
Participants
Participants in this study were 14 counselor education students
enrolled in a graduate-level career counseling course and 20
undergraduate students enrolled in an undergraduate Career Planning
course. Before participating in this project, both groups were surveyed
regarding the amount of time they spent using computers for school,
work, and educational purposes. Most reported using computers frequently
for at least two of the above three categories, but few had any
experience in constructing Web pages. Both groups are described in more
detail in the following sections.
Graduate students. Thirteen of the 14 counselors-in-training who
participated in this project were female, 7 were European American, 4
were Asian American, 2 were African American, and 2 were Latino/a. The
average age of these participants was 27.5 years, and all but 1 student
were in the 1st year of a 2-year graduate counselor education program at
a large southwestern university (the remaining student was in a doctoral
program in counseling psychology). Each of these students worked with 1
or 2 undergraduate students as part of this investigation.
Undergraduate students. These participants were enrolled in an
undergraduate Career Planning course, which is an upper division
elective designed for students seeking to learn more about their own
career development. Of the undergraduate participants, 76% were female
and 24% male, 48% were juniors and 52% were seniors, and the average age
was 22 years. Regarding ethnic background, the undergraduate
participants were 67% European American, 19% Latino/a, and 14% Asian
American.
We recruited the undergraduate participants from the Career
Planning classes, and as an incentive, they were allowed to substitute
this activity for another class assignment. The nature of the project
was described to the prospective participants, including the fact that
they would receive a two-session structured counseling experience. These
students were asked to volunteer only if they had specific career
concerns that fit within the scope of this project.
Procedure
Training graduate students in the Internet career intervention. The
career development class in which the graduate students were enrolled
was a 3-semester-hour, graduate-level course that is required for
students in counselor education. During the first half of the semester,
the focus of the course was primarily academic and the nature of
instruction was mainly lecture and small group activity. This section of
the class included a review of the main theoretical approaches to career
development.
COPYRIGHT 2003 National Career Development
Association Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2003, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.