When you send one of your top employees to an executive education
program at any of the many fine postgraduate business schools in Mexico,
what do you expect in return?
If you're typical, you expect at the very least a more capable
and up-to-date executive who'll put new knowledge and leadership
skills to work for the benefit of the company. That's what
you're paying for, after all.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
But are you also expecting a more well-rounded human being who has
undergone a radical personal transformation and come out with new
attitudes about family relationships, co-worker interaction and his or
her own role in the company?
You should be, says Heriberto Rodriguez, director general of a
relatively small (about 550 students) but influential graduate business
school in Puebla. Rodriguez is a vocal advocate for emphasizing personal
development as a key component in executive education.
While this concept is hardly unknown in prestigious executive
education programs across the country, it's intimately woven into
the fabric of the curriculum at IESDE (Instituto de Estudios Superiores
en Direccion de Empresas de Mexico), the school Rodriguez runs. And he
expects to see more programs follow IESDE's lead in the future.
"Value creation is an important reason a business exists, and
generating wealth is business' principal role in society,"
Rodriguez says. "But businesses have other roles as well. And,
especially in Latin America, they involve a community of people who want
to be happy."
By no means does this mean that pure business skills need to be
sacrificed in executive training programs to make room for personal
development.
Quite the contrary. Rodriguez's point is that the whole
panoply of factors that go into training better executives--the
practical, the personal, the interpersonal and the societal--need to be
integrated for the benefit of everybody concerned, including the
company's bottom line.
To take an obvious and simple example, treating subordinates with
respect is known to help them do a better job. But being the kind of
person who treats subordinates with respect also helps you to do a
better job.
But there's even more. Fostering a business environment of
personal respect for one and all helps the nation as a whole do a better
job. That's not trivial or secondary, Rodriguez insists.
In fact, IESDE's stated mission might serve as a good
introduction to the big picture for anyone considering executive
business education for employees or themselves: "To train business
and organization managers integrally, deeply and systematically to
procure their managerial improvement and entrepreneurial development,
and in this way to influence the economic and social development of the
region."
Rewarding Experience
Executive MBA programs may fill the glamour spot for experienced
professionals seeking advanced business education, but the large
selection of shorter and more specific courses may offer the most direct
benefits to companies, as well as the executives themselves.
And anyone who may wonder if combining the personal with the
professional tends toward the touchy-feely need only hear
Rodriguez's down-to-earth reasons for choosing non-MBA programs to
assuage their fears.
"A masters program deals with a lot of theoretical
knowledge," he says. "The more specific programs that we and
others offer reward experienced people who have previous knowledge with
more capability to put their knowledge to work."
This is not to say that MBAs aren't the best option for many
executives who climbed the ladder without one and would benefit from
getting one at a certain stage of their careers. For many, an MBA is a
statement about their overall preparation, their range of knowledge and
their understanding of business as an area of human endeavor.
With a globalizing economy and a shifting business environment,
that statement, and the knowledge that goes with it, can make as much
sense for an executive at age 55 as it does for an up-and-comer at age
30.
But for many others, availing themselves of the more narrowly
focused, shorter duration (less than a year, usually a matter of months)
courses and diplomados offered by the better business schools offers the
immediate benefits they're looking for.
"The business world is a practical world," Rodriguez
points out. "The entire emphasis is on the practical, on getting
things done. That's not to say that knowledge, per se, is of minor
importance. But it does mean that the abilities and practical know-how
these programs offer count for more than abstract science."
For instance, Monterrey Tech's business school (EGADE-ITESM)
offers several prestigious MBA programs, but also attracts executive
students with its shorter programs in "World Class Marketing
Skills," "Macroeconomy for Decision-Making,"
"Strategic Management and Leadership," and many others.
Mexico, in fact, is blessed with a wealth of well-regarded schools
offering such programs, including the Panamerican University (UP), the
Autonomous University of Guadalajara (UAG), and the Ibero-Americana
University, to name just a few.
The programs can be quite creative in their focus. For example,
IPADE, perhaps the best-known postgraduate business education school
with facilities in several major Mexican cities, offers a special
program called ADIT focusing on innovation and technology.
It's aimed at businesspeople and executives who have found
themselves suddenly facing a brave new world of competing markets, short
product lifestyles, and ever changing business models--all resulting
from the dizzying pace of technological advancement.
Learning to ride with technology's pace instead of struggling
to keep up with it is as useful a reason for executive education as
anything.
Focus On Growth
Like many others, IESDE's most important programs are aimed at
veterans with at least five years of top executive experience. The
principal goal is the development of managerial skills for growth in the
business field.
But unlike many others, IESDE gives equal billing to "growth
as a human being."
The reason for this is not altruistic, but practical. Just as
better gasoline won't make much of a difference in a poorly tuned
car, better skills alone aren't always enough to achieve leadership
improvement. A better person will put the new skills to better use.
There's nothing new-age about the kind of growth Rodriguez
means. In fact, one of the major applications of the personal
improvement he advocates is in the concept of leadership as it relates
to the individual. The word he coined for it is duenez, which you might
translate as owner-ness.
It's not exactly ownership, since an executive usually
doesn't own in any literal sense what he or she is in charge of.
Rather, it's applying the consciousness of an owner to your
responsibilities--"owning up" to them, as it were, rather than
simply carrying them out.
"Doing your job," even if you do it well, is not what
it's all about.
"Today's companies put a lot of emphasis on
managing," Rodriguez says. "But managing, per se, is not
enough. What companies need are more 'owners.'"
Duenez is achieved, Rodriguez says, when executives function more
as politicians than managers. The notion of "politicians" in
the business place certainly sounds undesirable at first, to say the
least. But we're not talking here about manipulators or
power-seekers. Rather, the true masters of duenez know how to set policy
as well as carry it out.
As IESDE emphasizes, it's a different matter for an executive
to act like an owner than it is for a manager. The latter might perform
well, but the former identifies opportunities, takes risks and, most
importantly, unites wills to reach common objectives.
This duenez is as much a personality change to be made as a skill
to be learned, according to Rodriguez.
"The most important thing we teach is essentially
political," he says. "It consists of the knowledge and ability
to lead an organization to a better place."
Making Sound Decisions
The means IESDE uses to impart duenez and other traits and skills
are based on the Case Study method.
Again, this is used across the country, but Rodriguez--always a
visionary when it comes to business education--thinks it's
underused nationally. One reason may be the need for professors skilled
at using it.
"The emphasis has to be on the kinds of teachers who know how
to put it to its best use for everybody," Rodriguez says.
"With the case method, a teacher is as much a facilitator and
monitor as an instructor."
The case method is basically what it sounds like--using real
situations as a portal to learning.
The idea is that learning comes from discovering, not from
listening. What it's all about is not being told the
"right" way to do things, but getting a feel for how to decide
between different possible solutions.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
In a sense, Rodriguez maintains, the case method creates the
conditions for the executive student to discover what he or she already
knows.
Helping Mexico Win
Perhaps where advanced business education can help the most is in
the family business area.
This is a huge sector in Mexico. It's also a sector that
Rodriguez feels is mostly lacking in the skills and knowledge that these
programs impart.
"Very few family businesses make it to the third
generation," Rodriguez says. "And it's for the same
reason. They've never learned to be good owners."
COPYRIGHT 2005 American Chamber of Commerce of
Mexico A.C. Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2005, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.