Toward a feminist "Coney Island of the
avant-garde": Janie Geiser recasts the cinema of
attractions.
by Barlow, Melinda
Afterimage • Jan-Feb, 2007 • Janie Geiser's "The Spider's
Wheels"
To borrow Morse's phrase, atmosphere is something "you
had to be there" to perceive. (20) But evocative description is
enriched by context, and corporeal sensations offer lessons in history.
Which brings us back to the shocking slam that boxes in our heroine and
echoes throughout the space-in-between the sculptural components
comprising "The Spider's Wheels." Here, in Geiser's
deconstructed chamber of cinema, the mood is one of serious
exhilaration, but the longer you linger the more your initial sensation
of delight is punctuated by pangs of dread. Every time that roof goes up
you anticipate its crash back down. Other visitors to the installation
seemed to feel the same: they gasped, or winced, or stopped in their
tracks, reacting each time the Spider was trapped. And while such
reactions are not gender-exclusive--I saw both men and women respond in
similar ways--they may be especially gender-poignant. The image of a
woman engaged in struggle is nothing less than archetypal, and seeing
this struggle repeatedly thwarted can be especially painful for female
visitors, if not traumatic. It is something that has happened
consistently throughout history (in the United States it took feminists
seventy years of activism to achieve the right to vote) and is an
experience women know all too well in the world.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
To have created a form of political commentary that possesses what
might be called somatic authority--that registers kinesthetically, in
our bodies--is one of the greatest achievements of "The
Spider's Wheels." An installation that is alternately riveting
and discomfiting, that encourages us to be analytic while filling us
with awe--these things make the work extraordinary. Finally, a feminist
Coney Island of the avant-garde whose spectacular attractions both
astonish and critique.
NOTES (1.) See Ben Singer, Melodrama and Modernity: Early
Sensational Cinema and Its Contexts (New York: Columbia University
Press, 2001). Chapter 8, "Power and Peril in the Serial-Queen
Melodrama," was an important resource for Geiser in thinking
through her ideas for "The Spider's Wheels." Interview
with the author, Los Angeles, May 2006. (2.) Doug Hall and Sally Jo
Fifer, eds., Illuminating Video: An Essential Guide to Video Art (New
York: Aperture in association with the Bay Area Video Coalition, 1991),
14. (3.) Chrisse Iles, "Video and Film Space," in Space Site
Intervention: Situating Installation Art, Erika Suderburg, ed.
(Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2000), 257. (4.) Janie
Geiser in Melinda Barlow, "Interview with Janie Geiser,"
Animac, No. 3 (2004) (Spain), 3. (5.) This is Geiser's phrase from
her program notes for the work, 1999. (6.) For more on Automata and
Geiser's role in the international revival of miniature theatre,
see Melinda Barlow, "Size Matters: In the Micro-Universe of Toy
Theatre, Startling Shifts in Perspective Require Audiences to Look
Closely" American Theatre, Vol. 22, No. 22 (February 2005), 60-64.
(7.) See Shelley Stamp, Movie-Struck Girls: Women and Motion Picture
Culture After the Nickelodeon (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University
Press, 2000), for a detailed discussion of female fans and the serial
film craze. (8.) Tom Gunning, "The Cinema of Attractions: Early
Film, Its Spectator, and the Avant-garde," in Thomas Elsaesser,
ed., Early Cinema: Space Frame Narrative (London: British Film
Institute, 1990), 61. (9.) Fernand Leger, "A critical essay on the
plastic qualities of Abel Gance's film The Wheel," in Edward
Fry, ed., Functions of Painting, trans. Alexandra Anderson (New York:
Viking Press, 1973), 21, cited in Tom Gunning, "The Cinema of
Attractions," 56. (10.) See Sergei Eisenstein; Maciej Sliwowski;
Jay Leyda, Annette Michelson, "Notes for a Film of Capital,"
October, Vol. 2 (Summer, 1976), 3-26. (11.) Gunning, 61. (12.) Ibid, 61.
(13.) Carolyn Walker Bynum, "Wonder," American Historical
Review (February 1997), 1. (14.) Ibid, 1. (15.) Gunning, 61 (16.)
Margaret Morse, "Video Installation Art: The Image, The Body, and
the Space-in-Between," in Doug Hall and Sally Jo Fifer, eds.,
Illuminating Video, 153-167. In the last fifteen years there have been
other books and essays that have also explored the phenomenology of
installation--but not moving image installation--and these do not
discuss what Morse isolated in 1991 and what most concerns me here: that
elusive thing called atmosphere. Significant, however, for their
examination of the "nomadic" aspect of installations are James
Meyer's "The Functional Site; or, The Transformation of Site
Specificity," and Miwon Kwon's "One Place After Another:
Notes on Site Specificity," both in Suderburg, 23-37 and 38-63,
respectively. Two other useful sources on kinesthetic insights in a
variety of media are Laura U. Marks, Touch: Sensuous Theory and
Multisensory Media (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2002)
and Caroline A. Jones, ed., Sensorium: Embodied Experience, Technology,
and Contemporary Art (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2006). (17.) Morse, 167.
(18.) Ibid, 153. (19.) Ibid, 166. (20.) Ibid, 165.
MELINDA BARLOW is associate professor of Film Studies at the
University of Colorado at Boulder. She is the editor of Mary Lucier: Art
& Performance (Johns Hopkins, 2000) and the author of Lost Objects
of Desire: Video Installation, Mary Lucier, and the Romance of History
(forthcoming from University of Minnesota Press). She is currently
working on a collection of essays on Janie Geiser titled Curiosa in
Motion.
COPYRIGHT 2007 Visual Studies
Workshop Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.