Supporting sustainability through community and
collaborative processes at the landscape scale: an
introduction.
by Lumb, Ashok^Whitelaw, Graham
Environments • August, 2006 • Ecological Monitoring and Assessment
Network
Many of the partners of the Ecological Monitoring and Assessment
Network (EMAN) have embraced the concept of sustainability and are
actively working to ground the concept through their activities. The
EMAN is made up of linked organizations and individuals involved in
ecological monitoring in Canada to better detect, describe, and report
on ecosystem changes. The network is a cooperative partnership of
federal, provincial and municipal governments, academic institutions,
aboriginal communities and organizations, industry, environmental
non-government organizations, volunteer community groups, elementary and
secondary schools and other groups and individuals involved in
ecological monitoring. Environment Canada's EMAN-Coordinating
Office is mandated to work collaboratively with the EMAN partners in
improving the effectiveness of ecosystem monitoring and assessment to
encourage informed decision-making and to create environmental awareness
among Canadians.
Collaboration and landscape scale monitoring and assessment have
emerged as critical aspects associated with the work of the Network. The
network would cease to function without collaboration not only among
natural scientists but also among social scientists, non-government
organizations, the private sector and communities. It has become clear
through network activities that community-based activities and
collaboration at the landscape scale are essential elements of
sustainability. In recognition of these critical aspects of
sustainability and the work of the network, the theme selected for the
11th EMAN National Science meeting held in Penticton from November
20-26, 2005 was "Sustainability at the Landscape Scale: Supporting
the Process through Multi-party Stakeholder Participation."
This special issue of Environments is a collection of papers
selected from presentations made at the 2005 National Science Meeting.
The meeting was organized and sponsored by the EMAN Coordinating Office
and Forrex Science Outreach Organization. A stated purpose of the
meeting was to have partners use the meeting as "a forum to
consult, to connect and develop their programs." The event provided
a venue for a series of meetings to be held with a variety of partners
from all levels of government, non-governmental organizations, academics
and the private sector. The Meeting also included learning workshops on
monitoring framework development, monitoring study design,
communications and ecosystem monitoring protocols.
Throughout the meeting there were plenary and concurrent sessions
on the landscape sustainability theme. The collection of papers in this
special issue highlight the leading edge nature of the work being
carried out by EMAN scientists (defined broadly to also include social
scientists and citizen scientists) in efforts to move toward
sustainability.
The keynote presentation at the conference, by Don Gayton of
FORREX, titled Landscape and the condition of being, is the lead paper
for this issue. His paper explores the term landscape, the notion of
sense of place and its "difficult marriage between the hard science
of ecology and the soft, mushy concepts of psychology and
spirituality." Gayton concludes that it is time to start talking
about the "deficiencies in our current relationship to
nature." His reflections were well received at the conference and
offer reminders of the motivations that underly the efforts of those
involved in EMAN and similar work.
Papers by Milne et al., Conrad, and Kotak deal with community-based
monitoring, a subject that continues to receive much attention through
the activities of the Ecological Monitoring and Assessment Network.
Milne et al. explore the challenges of multi-party monitoring in Ontario
focusing on science, community and governance. Conrad explores the state
of community-based monitoring in Nova Scotia and extends the EMAN
Coordinating Office's community-based monitoring framework (EMAN-CO
2006) for application in Nova Scotia. Kotak, writing a shorter
commentary at the end of the volume, comments on the experience of
engaging the Black River First Nations in Manitoba in environmental
monitoring.
Two papers dealing with people and their role in science and
sustainability are included in the special issue. Jones et al. document
the role of the Ontario Benthos Biomonitoring Network (OBBN) in the
development of social capital, environmental action and problem solving
ability. White's paper presents results in the South
Okanagan-Similkameen community-based social marketing project and its
impact on local conservation.
Normand reflects on his involvement in sustainability-driven
conservation, including a study of the Toronto and Region Conservation
Authority. He discusses themes that were central to the Meeting and this
volume: sustainability, connection and collaboration.
The volume closes with two commentaries. The first, by Kotak is
mentioned above. The second, by McAfee et al., reports on one of the
most interesting sessions at the National Science Meeting hosted by
Natural Resources Canada-Canadian Forest Service on invasive alien
species.
The papers in this theme issue of Environments are written with a
variety of styles and from a variety of backgrounds and experience. As
such, this hints at the diversity of the Ecological Monitoring and
Assessment Network and the important socio-ecological science being
carried out by its members. The issue provides a window on the
inter-disciplinary work of the Network and its focus on community,
sustainability and collaboration, much of it at the landscape scale.
For more information on the network, the 2005 National Science
Meeting and the 2006 Meeting held in Winnipeg in November, 2006, please
visit: www.eman-rese.ca.
References
Ecological Monitoring and Assessment Network-Coordinating Office
(EMAN-CO). 2006. http://www.eman-rese.ca/english/results.html [Accessed
November 8, 2006].
Ashok Lumb, Ph.D, is Network Science Advisor with Environment
Canada's Ecological Monitoring and Assessment Network Coordinating
Office. He is involved in various aspects of water quality monitoring,
incorporating quality assurance/quality control in EMAN's
Monitoring Protocols. He has produced three special issues of
Environmental Monitoring & Assessment on various topics related to
monitoring ecological change in Canada. He can be reached at
ashok.lumb@ec.gc.ca
Graham Whitelaw is an adjunct lecturer and postdoctoral fellow with
the Department of Environment and Resource Studies, University of
Waterloo. His research focuses on the role of civil society in planning
and management processes. He can be reached at graham.whitelaw@gmail.com
COPYRIGHT 2006 Wilfrid Laurier
University Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.