Help from man's best friend: psychiatric service
dogs are helping consumers deal with the symptoms of mental
illness.
by Esnayra, Joan
With greater frequency, mental health patients are presenting at
emergency rooms, hospitals, and clinics with a service dog in tow. These
are psychiatric service dogs, specially trained to partner 24/7 with
persons living with severe mental health disabilities.
A fundamental premise of the psychiatric service dog therapeutic
model, as promulgated by the Psychiatric Service Dog Society, is 24/7
human-canine partnership. The intensity of the partnership leverages a
dog's innately observant nature to the human partner's
benefit. As the dog becomes conditioned to the usual range of behaviors,
attitudes, and dispositions of its mentally ill partner, the dog
responds to the person's episodic manifestations of mental illness
by manifesting an unusual behavior. Each dog is unique in the signal or
alert it provides, such as nibbling a handler's fingers or toes,
bumping a handler's elbow, whining, barking, pensive or worried
looks, or apparent misbehavior (e.g., running around the handler in an
excited manner uncharacteristic or ill-suited to the circumstances).
Since the dog and handler are together 24/7, the human partner
takes note when her dog is behaving differently and uses this
information to deduce that she likely is entering an episode of mental
illness. This often silent exchange usually takes place before the human
partner even is aware of her own nascent symptoms, which may include
aggressive driving secondary to a hypomanic episode or hyperventilation
due to an incipient panic attack. In the words of three psychiatric
service dog handlers:
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
* "When a psychiatric service dog alerts, its handler acquires
new information about triggers that are affecting her brain and
precipitating symptoms."
* "I found that if I am not calm, [my dog] begins to act up.
This is my clue to do an internal check to see what is really going on
inside."
* "When my dog alerts, I am given an opportunity to act on the
information long before the development of symptoms that would otherwise
require inpatient care."
It is not yet understood what exact cues a dog may be picking up
on. They may be subtle behavioral cues, or they may be olfactory cues
such as a subtle change in the smell of one's breath or
uncharacteristic sweat gland secretions on one's skin. The
acquisition of insight in this context renders the human partner better
equipped to mitigate the episode through cognitive interventions,
risk-reduction behaviors, PRN medications, or calling one's
healthcare provider for assistance.
In fact, a vital therapeutic function of a psychiatric service dog
is to assist the human partner in cultivating insight into her unique
manifestations of mental illness. Since mental illness is known to
impair an individual's degree of insight, this therapeutic function
proves invaluable to savvy mental health patients. One psychiatric
service dog handler characterizes the interaction this way: "[My
dog] and I have a sort of feedback loop going on. I read her, reading
me, and this helps me to better modulate my reactions and
behaviors."
The Society promotes psychiatric service dogs as an adjunct to
ongoing standard-of-care mental health treatments. They are to be used
in addition to a consumer's existing mental health treatment plan
rather than as a substitution. To the best of our knowledge, no payers
reimburse the costs associated with training a psychiatric service dog,
which at a minimum costs $1,000, excluding the cost of purchasing the
dog. Such a serious training requirement represents a real financial
obstacle for many. Simply put, dogs cost money. Most mental health
consumers train their own psychiatric service dog. Some training
guidance is provided through the Society's Web site
(www.psychdog.org) and its handler Listserv, but individuals are
strongly encouraged to retain a professional dog trainer for one-on-one
training sessions to establish a solid training foundation.
In addition to providing a therapeutic function, psychiatric
service dogs may be trained to perform tasks that assist their human
partners. For example, many handlers have trained their dogs to remind
them to take medication at a specified time. The reliability of this
task derives from the natural clock in canine brains and a dog's
uncanny ability to associate a particular time of day with the reliable
provision of treats, which could be located next to the human
partner's mid-afternoon pill bottle.
Dogs have been trained to wake handlers experiencing night terrors,
as a result of post-traumatic stress disorder, and turn on the lights so
that they can regroup (the dog could activate a "touch lamp"
or pull a string attached to a light). A famous author with PTSD trained
her dogs to check a residence or hotel room for the presence of other
people so that she could feel safe to enter.
An individual with panic disorder trained his dog to lie on top of
him, providing warmth so that he can recover from the cold sweat and
chills that often accompany panic attacks. For many people with
psychiatric disorders, calling one's dog to sit quietly while
stroking its fur is enough of a therapeutic redirection of one's
attention to mitigate acute symptoms, such as the compulsion to bolt,
self-injure, or repeatedly check door locks.
Psychiatric service dogs can be distinguished from ordinary pets.
Service dogs are trained in three domains: basic obedience, public
access skills, and disability-related tasks or therapeutic functions. A
service dog will behave impeccably. It will not eliminate
inappropriately, bark incessantly, jump on people, or lunge at other
dogs. Much of the time, the dog will appear relaxed yet attentive to the
handler. Most service dogs wear a vest, backpack, or harness clearly
labeled "service dog," although such labeling is not required
by law.
A legitimate service dog handler should be able to describe how her
psychiatric service dog assists her, whether through the performance of
disability-related tasks or the provision of therapeutic functions.
Granted, it may be difficult for the handler to explain the precise
phenomenology of her dog's assistance, but it should not be
impossible. A corollary challenge would be to ask a patient to explain
how talk therapy works for her. You may not get the polished response
you would expect from a psychologist, but the response should make
sense.
The Society is studying the efficacy of psychiatric service dogs.
In addition to an arsenal of anecdotes, formal psychiatric service dog
handler survey data reflect refractory symptom reduction among 84.4% (n
= 54) of the respondents polled. Forty percent (n = 26) reported reduced
use of psychotropic medication subsequent to psychiatric service dog
partnership. In the past year, the Society submitted to the National
Institutes of Health three grant proposals for randomized clinical
trials utilizing psychiatric service dogs. Two proposals were not
funded, and the third is pending. A longitudinal outcomes study also is
in the planning stages.
No doubt the excavation of knowledge about psychiatric service dogs
still is under way. There is more to learn and, at least for now, the
key informants are mental health consumers. The Society will continue to
codify this developing body of knowledge, as it has for the past ten
years, and extract key findings for dissemination on its Web site.
Joan Esnayra, PhD, is President of the Board of Directors of the
Psychiatric Service Dog Society in Arlington, Virginia. She can be
reached at joan.esnayra@comcast.net.
The Psychiatric Service Dog Society offers informational brochures
for consumers and provides at www.psychdog.org.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
BY JOAN ESNAYRA, PHD
RELATED ARTICLE: Emmy-winning actress promotes dogs' role in
people's recovery from depression
As part of her commitment to helping people with depression, Emmy
Award-winning actress Linda Dano is leading Support Partners: Canine
Companions, a new program that offers practical tips on how to expand
support networks by incorporating dogs into the recovery process. The
program is sponsored by Eli Lilly and Company and the Psychiatric
Service Dog Society.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
"As someone who has always been a dog-owner, my Lhasa apsos,
Mo and Charlie, became more important to me than ever when I was
diagnosed with depression," says Dano, who won an Emmy for her role
on Another World. "I started getting help from my physician and
support from my friends, and soon realized that my dogs also gave me a
sense of comfort, purpose and companionship. Many days when all I wanted
was to stay in bed, alone, I knew I had to get up to take care of Mo and
Charlie and comfort them as they comforted me."
Support Partners: Canine Companions offers a brochure that provides
information about the benefits of dogs, the different levels of support
a dog can offer someone with depression, and easy, practical ways pet
owners can immediately work with their dogs to include them in their
support network. For details visit
http://supportpartnersprogram.com/canine/canine2.jsp.
COPYRIGHT 2007 Vendome Group
LLC Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.