On the shelves at Comercial Mexicana, the third-largest supermarket
chain in Mexico, there are signs that tell the buyer how much cheaper
the item is in comparison to the price of its most aggressive
competitor, retail giant Wal-Mart. The competition is that fierce.
Not only that, each store is strategically located, and each item
is carefully placed to give the client the feeling that she's doing
more than just the week's shopping. "Not only do I find what I
want, but everything is so attractive that I end up buying things I had
no intention of buying," says Sara Alvarado, a Mexican housewife
doing her shopping at one of the stores.
Following the tough price war after the 1999 introduction of
Wal-Mart's low-price system, today the struggle among retailers is
centered on getting the consumer to pay more attention. "In the
future, the most important thing won't be price but the service you
can give the client and how good her shopping experience is," says
Mauricio Brocado, director of research at investment firm Actinver.
Controladora Comercial Mexicana --which runs the supermarket chain
and a restaurant chain--this year will invest US$400 million to open 21
stores, remodel another 10 and open the doors at six restaurants.
"Last year was the best year in the history of Comercial Mexicana:
We had the best sales and profit margins. We are very optimistic; we
believe there's a great opportunity for growth," says
Francisco Martinez de la Vega, director of finance and administration
for Comercial Mexicana.
In 2006, the enterprise had sales of $4.22 billion and this year
it's expecting that figure to grow by 10%. But in order to get
there, it had to undergo a restructuring after the heavy hit it took
following the arrival of U.S. behemoth Wal-Mart. "In the past,
Comercial Mexicana was accustomed to average sales growth rates of 10%,
but from 2000 to 2003 we grew very little. In fact, we closed down
unproductive stores," Martinez says. It wasn't until 2004 that
the chain started growing again.
Price war. "Our promotion strategy was very worn out and
things started to go very badly. The consumer viewed us as expensive
compared to Wal-Mart and the company's numbers started to go
down," Martinez says. "The priority of not being expensive is
a central topic. Our managers compare prices against Wal-Mart in all
stores and, if they have a problem, we have to change prices."
To reduce costs and maintain low prices Comercial Mexicana had to
have a distribution infrastructure, and to improve and centralize its
logistics. This year it will complete a $17 million distribution center
just for frozen foods. "[This facility] give suppliers an exact
delivery of their merchandise to the group's operators, and it
gives Comercial Mexicana maximum advantage with its providers and
efficiency in the supply," says Fernando Gomez Da Costa, general
director of Comercializadora Tangamanga de la Metropolis, a dairy
producer that supplies the chain.
Over the next few years, Comercial Mexicana will also have two
important allies: increasing consumer purchasing power, and the push
toward more credit purchases. By 2020, the industry is expecting an
additional 14 million consumers due to a combination of economic
conditions and demographic growth. "All of these variables, and a
young population that is joining the labor force--young people who will
start marrying and requiring home appliances--generates a commercial
dynamic that could be very positive," says Rafil Arguelles, vice
president of corporate affairs for Wal-Mart Mexico.
The competition is on the lookout. This year, Wal-Mart will invest
$967 million in Mexico to open 125 self-service and department stores
and 35 restaurants, a 12% jump in store space. In 2006, the National
Association of Self-Service and Department Stores reported a total
investment of $1.40 billion among its member chains, which until May did
not include Wal-Mart. The figure underscores a feverish competition,
because it includes new establishments, remodeling and conversions in
the formats of stores.
MARISOL RUEDA * MEXICO CITY
COPYRIGHT 2007 Freedom Magazines,
Inc. Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.