An opportunistic ally: China's increasing
involvement in Africa.
by Shinn, David H.
Chinese officials, think tank researchers, and representatives of
state-owned companies frequently refer to a "win-win" outcome
when discussing Chinese-African relations. Most of my interlocutors
during visits to Beijing and Shanghai this year sincerely seemed to
believe that China and Africa have had, and will continue to have, a
mutually beneficial relationship. China and Africa have been trading
partners for many centuries. The Chinese Communist Party formed close
ties with African liberation movements in the late 1950s. However, its
engagements with the continent over the past 10 years have greatly
exceeded earlier contact. As the quantity and intensity of these
relationships have increased, China has been subjected to the realities
of dealing with Africa and has come under criticism for some of its
government policies and business practices. So far, China has shown an
unusual ability to react constructively and mitigate problems caused by
its policies. Indeed, if China continues its deft foreign policy in
Africa, popular discontent among Africans will likely remain manageable.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
China's Strategy in Africa
In general China has sought to portray itself as the world's
largest and most powerful developing country, while it describes Africa
as the continent with the largest number of developing countries. It
considers Chinese and African economies as highly complementary with
strong prospects for cooperation. China's January 2006 African
Policy statement proposed a decades-long comprehensive agenda that has
been well received by African leaders. This statement emphasized
non-interference in internal affairs, equality, mutual benefit and
support, and, most critical to Beijing, an acceptance of the one-China
principle.
This principle assigned a premium to high-level exchanges in all
spheres of activity. It called for a new international political and
economic order that would safeguard the legitimate rights and interests
of developing countries. China promised to facilitate the entrance of
African products into the Chinese market, increase investment in Africa,
and intensify agricultural cooperation. It began to encourage Chinese
enterprises in order to help build infrastructure in African countries,
something the West has been reluctant to do in recent years. And it
promised to help Africa raise the level of tourism, reduce its debt, and
increase economic assistance. The policy statement called for
comprehensive cooperation in the fields of education, science and
technology, culture, medicine and health, media, the environment, and
disaster relief. It offered training assistance to African military
personnel as well as support to internal defense building and African
peacekeeping operations. Finally, the statement noted that China would
promote cooperation with African judicial, law enforcement, and
immigration departments while addressing non-traditional security
threats such as terrorism.
The Forum on China-Africa Cooperation (FOCAC), launched in 2000, is
the vehicle through which China manages this relationship. The Third
Ministerial Conference of FOCAC took place in Beijing in November 2006.
All 48 African countries that have diplomatic relations with China sent
senior delegations, most of them led by their respective heads of state.
Only five countries--the Gambia, Malawi, Swaziland, Burkina Faso, and
Sao Tome and Principe, all of which have formal relations with
Taiwan--did not participate.
The Beijing Action Plan resulting from the last FOCAC conference
was ambitious in both its depth and breadth. Specific decisions included
a Chinese pledge to increase from 190 to 440 the number of items from
Africa's least developed countries that are permitted to enter
China duty-free. China said it would establish a China-Africa
Development Fund capitalized at US$5 billion to support investments in
Africa by Chinese companies. It also promised to double the value of its
2006 development assistance program by 2009 and cancel some states'
government interest-free loans that were due at the end of 2000.
In addition to these economic initiatives, China agreed to train
15,000 African professionals over the next three years and to increase
the number of Chinese government scholarships for African students from
the current 2,000 to 4,000 by 2009. It will help establish 100 rural
schools, send 100 agricultural experts to Africa, and set up 10
agricultural technology demonstration centers. It pledged to build 30
hospitals and 30 demonstration centers for the prevention and treatment
of malaria and will continue to send medical teams and supplies to
Africa.
This February, President Hu Jintao made his third visit to Africa
since coming to power in 2003. His twelve-day, eight-country tour
focused on trade, aid, and investment. Hu canceled debt during stops in
Cameroon, Liberia, Sudan, Zambia, and Mozambique, and he pledged soft
loans and grants to Cameroon (totaling US$100 million), Sudan (US$117
million), Namibia (US$139 million), and Seychelles (US$35 million). He
also inaugurated a major mining partnership in Zambia's copper belt
and pledged a new "strategic partnership" with South Africa.
The visit illustrated China's way of using high-level personal
contact to reach out to virtually every country on the continent with
which it has diplomatic relations. The Chinese Communist Party also
maintains regular contact with ruling African political parties and even
some opposition parties.
Forces behind China-Africa Ties
While China's strategy in Africa plays down the importance of
its quest for African natural resources to fuel its fast-growing
economy, most observers believe that its desire for African energy,
minerals, and timber is the single most important factor driving the
relationship. One-third of China's oil imports come from Africa,
and this proportion is growing. But the relationship also provides
benefits for Africa, including Chinese aid and direct investment,
reasonably good quality manufactured goods at low costs, and some
technology transfer. Granted, China will not cure poverty in Africa, but
it is certainly making a positive contribution.
China's foreign aid, loans, technical and military assistance,
export credits, high-level exchanges, Confucius Institutes, and debt
cancellation policies all support its efforts to increase its influence
in Africa. China is working hard to develop meaningful relationships
with all 48 African countries that recognize Beijing and has a resident
embassy in every African country with which it has diplomatic relations
except for Somalia, where the security situation precludes one. Indeed,
even the United States does not have resident diplomatic presence in
small island nations like the Seychelles, Comoros, and Sao Tome and
Principe.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Beijing's ties are especially intense with those countries
that are current or potential suppliers of raw materials for the Chinese
economy. Angola, Sudan, Congo-Brazzaville, Equatorial Guinea, Gabon,
Nigeria, Algeria, and Chad all sell significant amounts of oil to China.
South Africa, Zimbabwe, Zambia, Ghana, Congo-Brazzaville, Namibia, and
the Democratic Republic of the Congo provide minerals, while Gabon,
Congo-Brazzaville, Equatorial Guinea, Cameroon, and Liberia are
suppliers of timber.
It would, nevertheless, be a mistake to conclude that China
considers Africa only as a source of raw materials. China also views
Africa, which contains 14 percent of the world's population, as a
potentially important market for its exports and a destination for
Chinese investment. Trade between China and Africa reached US$50.5
billion in 2006, up 30 percent over 2005, and it is expected to reach
US$100 billion by 2010. China is now Africa's third largest trading
partner after the United States and France, and by the beginning of
2007, Chinese investment in Africa reached US$12 billion. Although
increasing rapidly, this amount is modest compared to Western investment
and has been concentrated in oil and extractive industries.
African countries constitute well over a quarter of the United
Nations' 192 members and are thus an essential component of
China's efforts to play a more important global role. China and
Africa tend to support each other in international forums on human
rights issues and those of special concern to the developing world.
China has been most appreciative of Africa's strong advocacy for
its one-China policy and looks for future backing on other contentious
political and economic issues. China is developing broad-based strategic
partnerships with key African countries such as Egypt and South Africa,
and it has been looking to develop a similar relationship with Nigeria.
COPYRIGHT 2007 Harvard International Relations
Council, Inc. Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.