Finances and affordability of
caregiving.
by Davenport, Tracy^Eidelman, Steven M.
More than 51 million Americans have a disability. This represents
nearly 20 percent of the U.S. population. Of Americans 65 and older,
more than half have a disability. From a family perspective, nearly 29
percent of all American families (approximately 20.9 million) have at
least one member with a disability. These numbers will only increase as
people with life-long disabilities of all kinds continue to live longer,
with the simultaneous increase in the number of people with age-related
disabilities. This trend has significant public policy implications for
state human service agencies.
Most people with a disability live at home and are cared for by
their families. Some of these individuals will require significant
supports their entire lives. The cost of family caregiving can be beyond
the reach of millions of American families. Researchers have estimated
that the overall daily living expenses for families with a child with a
disability are 8 percent to 20 percent higher than their counterparts
without a family member with a disability. Others have attempted to put
a dollar figure on the increase and have estimated the out-of-pocket
family costs for an individual with disabilities to be an extra $6,300
to $16,000 per year. However, few family caregivers are afforded a
complete picture ahead of time of what the actual costs of care will be,
and are unable to plan for the future as they would for other major life
expenses, such as the purchase of a house or higher education.
Some of the supports and services states provide include direct
payments to service providers that help families care for their
relatives at home, pay for educational expenses and for specialized
equipment. However, the levels of funding lag behind what is needed for
the poorest families and families at the bottom half of annual earnings.
Leading-edge support models allow people with disabilities and their
families to control how funds allocated on their behalf are expended.
This program design produces better outcomes.
The research supports what many families in a caregiving situation
already know. In every state, families with members with disabilities
are more likely than other families to have their economic prospects
diminished. According to the U.S. Census, 29.2 percent of children with
disabilities live in households with incomes below the federal poverty
level, compared with only 17.3 percent of children who do not have
disabilities. Only a fraction of public long-term spending has been
directed towards family care. In 2004, 6 percent of community
disabilities funding was allocated to family support services across the
nation. This same year, only 22 states financed cash subsidy programs,
with an average annual subsidy payment to a family equal to $2,853, well
below the lowest estimate of the average cost of family care.
The financial strain of caring for a family member with a
disability is not limited to low-income families. Middle-income families
can also be challenged by the cost of disability and chronic illness and
caregiving to the point of financial catastrophe.
In 2005, medical problem care costs contributed to at least half of
all bankruptcies in the United States, and the average bankruptcy filer
was a 41-year-old woman with children and at least some college
education. Most of these debtors owned homes and were primarily
classified as middle class by education and occupation. Medicaid and
Supplemental Security Income were not originally designed for
middle-income families, which places these caregivers in a precarious
position. Not only do these families not qualify for medical assistance,
but they are also a population not ordinarily in the system of support,
Therefore, public outreach may be nonexistent at worst and awkward at
best.
Providing public support and benefits to families that care for an
individual with a disability is a policy-and-practice issue that affects
a broad population across the income spectrum. Policy-makers must
address the need of family caregivers across earning levels as well as
be prepared to respond to the increasing demand for assistance as our
nation's population ages.
The financial burden of caring for a family member with a
disability is only one of the obstacles many family caregivers face on a
daily basis. As program directors reach out and get to know these
families better, many families will share the uncertainties of their
lives--about whether their family member will ever get better or whether
their caregiver responsibilities will prevent them from maintaining
full-time employment. If asked why they have not reached out for public
support, many will confide that they are just trying to get through each
day, one at a time. Many of these families will express the fact that
they do not need a stack of paperwork to fill out, or criticism for not
knowing about the programs that have been available all along to provide
assistance. They need real help and understanding. Our public policy
must address these needs to strengthen American families.
Steven M. Eidelman is the Robert Edelsohn chair of Developmental
Disabilities, co-director of the National Leadership Consortium on
Developmental Disabilities, and professor in the College of Human
Services, Education and Public Policy, University of Delaware. Tracy
Davenport is a PhD student and research assistant at the University of
Delaware focusing on the psycho-social aspects of illness and
disability.
COPYRIGHT 2007 American Public Welfare
Association Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.