After being hyped for more than a decade, extensible business
reporting language (XBRL) has gained legitimate legs, bringing improved
reporting conventions and easier translation between accounting
programs.
Imagine having access to real-time financial data for any public
company. Imagine transferring data from one accounting program to
another without the added cost of custom programming, sifting, sorting
or rekeying. Such is the promise of XBRL.
That promise is becoming a reality thanks to influential support
from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The XBRL initiative
is being positioned as a way to not only streamline the delivery of
financial information, but make it easier to use the information as
well. The hope is that the increased transparency of financial
information will boost investor confidence and dovetail with
international convergence.
What is XBRL
"XBRL is one of the most significant business reporting
developments in the last 10 years," said Ohio Society member
Michael R. Dickson, CPA, CITP, CISA with Plante and Moran. "While
many business executives don't yet understand or appreciate XBRL,
some of the largest financial institutions in the world, and the SEC,
are well aware of the capabilities and benefits of XBRL"
"Simply stated, XBRL is a standardized tagging system that
defines financial and nonfinancial data used in business reporting
processes. The gist of XBRL is to facilitate the generation and
dissemination of different types of financial and nonfinancial reports
from a single database of tagged elements. For example, a single tag set
of data could generate reports for filing financial statements in
several different languages, or under different languages, or under
different accounting standards. Thanks to XBRL, reporting to the Chinese
government, the banker around the corner or the SEC is no longer a
month-long process," Dickson said.
Why you should care
XBRL will offer many benefits to those involved with financial
statements. For many CPAs, the biggest benefit is the ability to easily
move information from one program to another without rekeying.
"Before the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC)
adopted XBRL, the data collection and validation process was cumbersome
and time-consuming," said FDIC Vice Chair Martin J. Gruenberg.
"Multiple file formats and inefficient legacy systems required
substantial manual effort and resulted in significant delays. FDIC
analysts had to spend up to three weeks manually checking data quality
following submission."
XBRL also makes financial data more comparable across industries.
"One hidden value is that using an XBRL taxonomy, an investor or
business stakeholder could download tagged data from five different
companies and generate side by side, comparable reports using any of the
recommended or approved taxonomies," Dickson explained.
Fellow Ohio Society member J. David Ryan, CPA, CITP, vice president
of information services with Artromick International agrees. "One
of the biggest strengths of XBRL is the way it allows users to quickly
compare financial data across industries. Its "lingua franca"
is certainly one of its strengths--that you are using the same taxonomy.
That can also be one of its biggest weaknesses though. If you look at
it, you have a little latitude over what you aggregate with certain
things. Maybe current assets are current assets. But you can't make
certain assumptions within any given account. You still have to dig into
how companies treat certain accounting transactions."
Electronic audit trail
XBRL's ability to offer real-time, comparable data across
companies and industries keys into the market's growing hunger for
transparency. It also has the added boon of strengthening the audit
process through greater data integration and accessibility.
"From our vantage point at the SEC, it's clear that
interactive data will significantly improve audit quality," said
Christopher Cox, SEC chair during the 14th Annual XBRL conference in
Philadelphia last December. "Not only can XBRL help reduce errors
in the first place, but it can also help detect them after they
occur."
XBRL offers several benefits to the international audit community.
Ian Ball, chief executive of the International Federation of Accountants
(IFAC) noted several of these benefits in a recent article from
AccountingWeb. These benefits include:
* Enhanced credibility
* Improved transparency
* Streamlined supply chain
* More accessible data mining
All of these benefits can work together to strengthen the
public's faith in the audit process.
"The goal [is] a seamless audit trail for financial reporting,
tax reporting, statutory and statistical reporting, and management
reporting. It's not just about accounting and tax, but also about
operational and business information," explained Eric Cohen, XBRL
global technical leader with PricewaterhouseCoopers.
The driving force of the SEC
In 2005, former SEC chair William Donaldson announced the launch of
the SEC's pilot program to accept financial reports from companies
reporting in XBRL. Program participants were no feather weights. Two
dozen companies, including 3M, Dow Chemical, Ford, General Electric,
Microsoft, Pepsi, Pfizer and Xerox, representing more than $1 trillion
of market value, signed on to implement the program.
Taking another step forward last September, the SEC awarded three
separate contracts totaling $54 million to transform the agency's
1980s-vintage public company disclosure system from a form-based
electronic filing cabinet to a real-time search tool with interactive
capabilities.
The contracts pave the way to the SEC's widespread adoption of
XBRL by addressing the three major stumbling blocks:
1. Incomplete taxonomies
Taxonomies for many industries are already completed, but a
decisive move from static to interactive data requires that the job of
writing computer codes to "tag" financial report information
be completed for all U.S. GAAP-based filers. When this work is finished,
every item in a company's financial statement, such as net income
or gross sales, will be assigned a unique computer-readable label.
With these labels in place, the data that companies file with the
SEC can then be immediately used to analyze and compare any aspect of a
company's financial performance. At the same time, the task of
preparing the reports can be automated for the companies that file them.
Once the work is complete, every public company in America can make
its required disclosures to the Commission more accurately and
quickly--and as software applications are developed, company investors
will find it easier to understand that information.
The SEC is contracting with XBRL US, Inc., which is responsible for
developing the computer standard in America. It is anticipated that the
work will be completed in less than a year.
2. No requirement
To date, the SEC has not required companies to file their
information in interactive format, largely because the SEC's own
database--nicknamed EDGAR--can't yet use the extra capabilities of
XBRL.
The largest contract--$48 million--was earmarked to update EDGAR,
which paves the way for the SEC to require companies to file their
information in XBRL format.
The new system will use XBRL and be completely interactive. It will
allow Investors and analysts to search not only forms, but the
information within them. In addition, the information can be immediately
downloaded into applications software. Finally, anyone can get
real-time, streaming data using RSS feeds, ATOM, and other automated Web
tools, which could automatically search for newly filed SEC disclosures
and deliver the desired data directly to the desktop.
3. Readability
The third contract focuses on providing a new generation of
"interactive" investor tools on the SEC's Web site. The
new features will allow investors to not only view but analyze
companies' financials for free directly within the SEC Web site.
This will liberate investors from tedious hunt-and-guess searches,
and they can download not just SEC forms but specific data with in those
forms. Users will also be relieved of having to re-key data to make it
useful in software applications, or having to pay others to translate
the data to more usable formats.
Rush to market
While XBRL tags similar data, a viewer is needed to translate the
data into a readable format. Fortunately, XBRL is pledged to always be
an open source standard, which means the coding can be changed and
adapted to meet programming needs.
"The SEC is committed to doing everything in our power to
ensure that XBRL remains a truly international, stateless and open
source standard," Cox stated.
As with any technology need, several solutions have been developed
and will continue to develop as XBRL adoption broadens. "Vendors
will put together tools to meet the needs of the marketplace and then
leverage those tools with other audiences. By pushing the products down
the channel even more people will benefit," Ryan said.
Current contenders include:
* The SEC's Financial Report Viewer, available at
http://www.sec.gov/spotlight/xbrl/xbrlwebapp.htm. It includes financial
information for companies in the XBRL pilot program. Rivet Software has
developed an Excel add-in that will help tag spreadsheet data so
companies don't have to purchase high-end accounting systems to
take advantage of the bene fits of XBRL.
COPYRIGHT 2007 Ohio Society of Certified Public
Accountants Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.