Thwarting anti-Americanism: eight steps for CEOs
coping with the villainization of America.
by Kuhn, Robert Lawrence
Anti-Americanism is a potent phenomenon in the world, and business
executives as much as political leaders need to appreciate its
significance and deal with its consequences. First, I discuss the
etiology of anti-Americanism, its genesis and sources; then I prescribe
antidotes to its poison.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
There is nothing so strange about anti-Americanism. On the one
hand, its cause is the clash between American idealism, infused with
naivety and arrogance, and on the other, the natural nature of all
peoples to seek honor for themselves, to have pride in their countries
and to assert their national independence. All peoples are rightly proud
of their own nations and cultures and can come quite naturally to resent
other nations and cultures that may seem in some way superior (whether
economically or militarily). Such resentment is amplified when America
is seen exerting its military forces in a presumptive or preemptive
manner. These images cast America as "Big Bully," even if what
the "Bully" is doing is for the benefit, not the detriment, of
foreigners. The intimate and ubiquitous media, television and the
Internet, make personal and specific what in past generations were
generic and abstract.
Nationalism is pivotal here. In general, people do not resist
foreign intervention when it rescues them from other foreigners but can
come to begrudge such help when it rescues them from equally evil
domestic tyranny. Thus the French people universally appreciated the
American liberation of France from Germany's Adolf Hitler, while
the American liberation of Iraq from Saddam Hussein, who brutalized his
own country, was not appreciated. Although Iraq is laden with complexity
and subtlety, notably the interminable Shia-Sunni conflict, nonetheless
a majority of the Iraqi people, though they loathed Saddam, want the
Americans out.
An anti-American demonstration organized by university students in
an Asian country is illustrative. One student leader was particularly
virulent in his criticism of America, holding high placards criticizing
the U.S. for its military interventions and shouting slogans that the
U.S. is arrogant and bellicose and must be stopped. When asked by a
reporter how long he would continue his protest, the student leader
stated, rather matter-of-factly, that he could not remain much longer
since he had to return home to study for his GRE (Graduate Record
Examination), which is the test required for admission to American
graduate schools. The student saw no contradiction in his fervent
denunciation of American policy and his fervent desire to attend
American schools.
This true story, one of my all-time favorites, personifies
America's opportunities as well as its problems. For as much as
American policy is disparaged, its way of life, its grand vision and its
standards of excellence are all admired. Business leaders must learn how
to delimit the antagonism and leverage the appreciation.
Following are eight principles that executives can consider in
dealing with anti-Americanism:
1. Take Anti-Americanism Seriously. Understand the roots of the
problem and recognize it's not going away. Whether or not you think
anti-Americanism is justified is not the point. Expect it and adapt to
it.
2. Discern Proper Public Posture. Each company has its own market
position, its distinct image and style, and it is the articulation
between these company-specific characteristics, and the nature and
degree of anti-Americanism in each country, that drives proper strategy.
Consumer product companies and industrials have systematic differences,
yet since anti-American public pressure can affect a government's
capacity to buy American, even non-consumer goods, these differences may
not be significant.
3. Reflect Local Tastes and Sensitivities. It seems a cliche to
advise American companies to adapt their products and services to local
interests, but there is no better way to begin. Consider something as
simple as different body dimensions for clothes and divergent appetites
for foods. There are, however, no simple formulas. Customers can be
conflicted; they may like an American lifestyle but at the same time
they may feel uncomfortable, unpatriotic, liking it too much. In
advertisements, mix international and local faces.
4. Localize Structure and People. A company cannot counter
anti-Americanism if all of its leadership is American. More important,
it makes good business sense to develop local managers. Diversity of
people provides diversity of thinking, which makes the company more
robust in dealing with unexpected contingencies. A key question: What is
the process and the locus of decision-making in the foreign country? If
most decisions must go back to America, progress will be slowed.
5. Stress True Partnership. First, take your company's best
international practices and adapt them to local conditions. Then,
reverse direction and discern how local experiences can enhance the
international company. That's the essence of true partnership.
6. Craft a Consistent Public Image. In its ads, Toyota states that
it creates American jobs. This claim does not fool us into believing
that Toyota is not a Japanese company, but it does show us that Toyota
cares about its relationship with Americans beyond simply selling cars
to them, and we appreciate the effort. Sony, on the other hand, has
truly become an international organization; it is the first major
Japanese company to appoint a non-Japanese as CEO. After acquiring
IBM's personal computer and ThinkPad divisions, Lenovo also is
becoming a new kind of company, with executive leadership split between
China and America.
7. Warning: Do Not Condescend or Patronize. People smell
insincerity. If you put on a show to sell a public image, it won't
work. Only if you genuinely feel the partnership with your foreign
customers and employees will your tone reflect it. It is more how a
company thinks than what a company does that determines its true
internationalism.
8. Inoculate Your Company. The medical analogy is a good one. By
injecting into the body something like the real disease, the body will
develop immunological defenses to protect it against the real disease.
The analogy works by arguing that American companies operating
internationally should take anti-Americanism as a serious threat before
it arises, preparing its corporate body to withstand the attack.
Anti-Americanism is a wild card that can suddenly overturn a long
history of patient success. Only those companies that see
anti-Americanism for the threat that it is can survive such onslaught.
There is a tectonic shift among nations, and Americans must
recognize that every nation has every right to provide a good standard
of living for its people, and that if these nations feel restricted from
attaining this worthy goal, our world will see no end of trouble. The
consequences are clear: America cannot retain as large a disproportion
of world GDP as we have today, which will mean more disruptions in our
economy and more dislocations in our workforce--though we can adapt and
continue to improve our absolute standard of living. (American
percentage of world GDP peaked at just over 30 percent, coincidentally
about the same percentage that China enjoyed for hundreds of years until
the 19th century.) Thus, Americans should welcome the countries of Asia,
China and India in particular, into the widening circle of developed
nations whose peoples enjoy comfortable lives. We should hasten the day
when African nations--when all nations--can be so elevated.
As for Americans who feel threatened by the rise of other nations,
I can only say "we had better get used to it." The impact is
not avoidable and it is not uniform. Some people will prosper; others
will suffer. American jobs will be lost, but rather than retreating into
self-defeating protectionism and isolationism, we should adapt by
developing new kinds of jobs and by caring for those who, through no
fault of their own, find themselves displaced.
As for foreigners who rejoice when they see America falter and who
watch with glee as America's reputation declines, I can only say,
"Be careful for what you wish." The world without an engaged
America would be a more dangerous place, and you may rue the day that
you had sought it so. With all its misguided policies and naive
perceptions, America, perhaps more than any other nation in history, has
been international protector and benefactor. That this cannot continue
makes one fear for the future.
Robert Lawrence Kuhn, an international investment banker and
corporate strategist, is senior adviser at Citigroup. He is
co-editor-in-chief of China's Banking and Financial Markets: The
Internal Report of the Chinese Government. His articles describing and
explaining investment banking, which advise business executives how to
optimize investment banking products and services, are posted at
www.chiefexecutive.net/investment.
COPYRIGHT 2007 Chief Executive
Publishing Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.