Rebuilding brand USA: can U.S. companies restore
America's good name?
by Martin, Dick
A single South African bill-board tells us everything we need to
know about America's standing in the world. Daimler Chrysler's
Smart Car, it boasts, features "German engineering, Swiss
innovation and American nothing."
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Forget that the company paying for the ad--DaimlerChrysler--is
nominally German-American and the billboard belongs to Texas-based Clear
Channel Communications. The campaign targets people fed up with America
and all things American. That billboard could just as easily have been
planted along the highways of Australia, where to say something is
"so American" translates to "really stupid." Or in
South Korea, where some restaurants post hand-lettered signs warning,
"Americans not welcome." Or in Mexico, where the U.S. entrant
in the Miss Universe pageant was booed for making it to the finals. Or
in Europe, where two-thirds of people told the BBC that America
"stands primarily for money and sex."
For those who prefer hard data, there's plenty. According to
Zogby International, three out of four likely voters are concerned about
America's global reputation. And nearly half say U.S. multinational
corporations should play a "major role" in doing something
about it.
The CEOs of most U.S. multinationals, however, demur.
"We're not an American company," they proclaim.
"We're global." Unfortunately, their American roots show
and carry enough publicity value to make them a target for
protesters--or worse.
The Cost of Anti-Americanism
Anti-Americanism matters to our economy, health and safety. The
impact on U.S. companies' foreign sales may be masked by the
declining dollar for now. According to Richard Edelman, CEO of the
eponymous public relations firm, other costs include "the ability
of U.S. companies to recruit and retain local talent, engage with
regional governments, secure regulatory approval and establish goodwill
that they can draw on in a crisis." Meanwhile, the U.S.'s
share of the international tourism market, which should benefit from a
weak dollar, has fallen by a third from 1992 to 2006. These figures are
striking--and expensive. By one estimate, that market share drop
represents $93 billion in lost spending, $16 billion in lost taxes and
194,000 lost jobs.
More worrisome, anti-Americanism also costs the U.S. the
cooperation of other nations in dealing with such global problems as
terrorism, climate change, HIV/AIDS, avian flu or the next security
crisis. A world shaken by conflict makes for a lousy market.
What Can Business Do?
U.S. companies cannot single-handedly make their country of origin
more lovable and trustworthy. But the U.S. government won't get
very far on its own either.
Despite recent accounting scandals, American companies have more
credibility than the U.S. government in most corners of the world. They
also have more feet on the street--feet that aren't clad in combat
boots. More than six million people work for U.S. companies abroad.
They're all potential ambassadors for American values of individual
freedom, equal opportunity and fair play.
U.S. companies need to become as obsessed about America's
reputation around the world as they are about free trade. The Bush
administration's 2008 State Department budget request includes
increases for proven programs such as language training,
people-to-people exchanges and targeted economic development. But it
will be a long time before the State Department catches up with the
massive spending cuts that followed the end of the Cold War. U.S.
business groups need to push those budget increases through a skeptical
Congress, as if they were curbs on trial lawyers.
U.S. companies operating abroad can also help more directly as
living exemplars of American ideals in the way they treat their
employees and their customers. Many people around the world have the
impression that, if they are not buying something we sell, we don't
care about them. When we have acted to the contrary, attitudes have
changed quickly. America's response to the Asian tsunami of 2004
dramatically increased favorable attitudes toward the U.S. worldwide.
Significantly, it also decreased support for Osama Bin Laden in the
world's most populous Muslim country, Indonesia. And more than two
years later, it's still the biggest factor underlying favorable
opinion towards America there.
American global companies should demonstrate that they share their
customers' cares through employee volunteerism, by engaging
constructively with responsible nongovernmental organizations and by
investing in strategic philanthropy. This isn't
"dogoodism," knee-jerk political correctness or buying favors.
Successful corporations have learned that philanthropy has business
benefits when it operates at the intersection of both the donors'
and the recipients' interests.
Coca-Cola responded to criticism that it contributes to water
shortages in developing countries by announcing plans to boost water
recycling so it ultimately uses no more water than it bottles. While
that could save money, Coke's CEO says the primary goal is to win
"the social license to continue to operate."
Cisco established network-training academies in technical schools,
colleges and community-based organizations across more than 150
countries. To date, Cisco has prepared more than 1.5 million students
for careers in the information technology industries, including several
thousand women in Middle Eastern countries such as Saudi Arabia and the
United Arab Emirates.
Successful global companies make themselves part of the local
community wherever they do business, sharing their customers' cares
and dreams. They don't just open branches overseas; they sink
roots. In fact, one of China's vice-premiers recently told a State
Department official that his government loves it when an American
company opens local facilities "because one of the first things
they do is put up a basketball court for the local kids."
Basketball backboards, and the like, may be the most telling billboards
of all for American values.
Dick Martin is the author of Rebuilding Brand America. He retired
from AT & T as executive vice president of public relations and
brand management in 2003.
RELATED ARTICLE: Five Things You Can Do Right Now
1. Educate employees in working across cultures. For example,
Business for Diplomatic Action's World Citizens Guide pinpoints
American mannerisms, such as a loud voice and hurried gestures, that can
be perceived as boastful or arrogant. See
www.worldcitizensguide.org/index2.html.
2. Encourage your employees to get involved with organizations that
promote international understanding, such as a local World Affairs
Council (www.worldaffairscouncils.org) or a Rotary International club
(www.rotary.org).
3. Support organizations that facilitate cultural and educational
exchanges, such as Meridian (www.meridian.org) and AYUSA
(www.ayusa.org).
4. Charge the heads of your foreign operations to become active
members of local chambers of commerce and to build stronger
relationships with local journalists and business leaders. See
www.foreigntrade.com/chambers.htm.
5. Offer English-language training and local internships in your
overseas locations. The State Department can help. See
exchanges.state.gov/education/engteaching/.
World View of U.S. Influence
(all figures in percentages)
Mainly Positive Mainly Negative
2005 40 45
2006 36 47
2007 29 52
Source: Globescan Poll of 18,000 adults in 18 countries. Released
Jan. 23, 2007
Note: Table made from line graph.
U.S. Share of International Travel Market
1992 9.4
1993 8.9
1994 8.4
1995 7.9
1996 8.0
1997 8.0
1998 7.5
1999 7.5
2000 7.4
2001 6.8
2002 6.2
2003 5.9
2004 6.0
2005 6.1
2006 6.1
Source: Office of Travel and Tourism Industries. October 2006
Note: Table made from line graph.
COPYRIGHT 2007 Chief Executive
Publishing Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.