German vice chancellor Franz Muntefering, a Social Democrat,
recently labeled large investment companies "locusts," and
since then, the moniker has stuck. The nickname stems from the fact that
locusts descend upon a territory and leave everything destroyed.
Similarly--at least according to critical left-wing Germans--investors
buy into a company, squeeze every penny out of it and sell the useless
shell.
These days, the "locusts" have come in the form of Lavena
Holding 4, a conglomerate of U.K.-based Permira and U.S.-based Kohlberg
Kravis Roberts (KKR), which acquired the majority ownership of German
commercial TV group ProsiebenSat. 1 Media AG, which subsequently
bought--from its own investors--European Broadcasting conglomerate SBS
Broadcasting. Private equity funds KKR and Permira purchased SBS only
two years earlier before selling it to the ProSieben Group (for a hefty
profit), forging a strong new European TV player.
The deal stirred up recent memories of ProSieben's former
owner, the Kirch Group, which financed its expansion by going into a
debt that later killed the entire venture. To finance the SBS purchase
(costing approximately 3.3 billion euro), ProSieben--which was almost
debt-free until recently--has relied on bank loans and now finds itself
loaded with debt. Depending on the perspective, ProSieben is either
extremely lucky or unlucky to have finalized the deal just in the nick
of time, before the so-called "credit crunch" sent waves
through the U.S. and the rest of the world, making loan financing a lot
harder.
[ILLUSTRATIONS OMITTED]
ProSieben CEO Guillaume de Posch's aim is an ambiguous one. On
one hand, his goals are set on expansion--setting up a pan-European TV
player out of two individual players (SBS and ProSieben) that will be
able to compete with the still much larger RTL German group. On the
other hand, de Posch has announced plans to increase his group's
profit margins from 20 percent to some 25-to-30 percent, despite the
high cost of investment. Growth is expected to take place particularly
in Eastern Europe, where SBS is already quite strong and where the
company has expanded into radio ventures.
But some analysts predict that problems might arise from merging
the ProSieben and SBS ventures. ProSieben's core business so far
has been strictly TV--free TV, to be precise. Two small basic pay
channels were launched only recently in an effort to become less
dependent on classic advertising revenues. The company's main
ventures are still the two large German general interest channels
ProSieben and Sat. 1, along with Kabel 1--a general entertainment
channel generating about half the audience of each of the major
channels. There is also N24, a news channel, and 9Live, which features
interactive game shows. The entire group has brought in about double the
revenue of SBS, which in 2006, for the first time, crossed the one
billion euro benchmark.
SBS operates free-to-air TV and radio channels in Benelux,
Scandinavia and Eastern Europe. After acquiring the Nordic Canal+ pay
platforms, the company has also become a major payTV player in
Scandinavia. In the Netherlands, the company also runs the two major
printed TV guides.
Despite the skepticism running rampant in the industry, de Posch
plans to quickly integrate the SBS ventures into his group. By this
fall, the old SBS headquarters in Amsterdam may be shut down. De Posch
expects synergies to come primarily from joint program acquisitions,
where lower prices can be negotiated. SevenOne International, the
division of ProSieben that sells productions and formats
internationally, may profit from the larger group's activities as
well. But analysts say the profits are not enough to bring down the
group's mounting debt. So the channels will likely face increasing
pressure to cut costs, at least according to one senior analyst at a
large German bank (who said this shortly before the first severe job
cuts at the Sat. 1 network became public).
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
As per the announcement, approximately 200 jobs will be lost, 40 of
which are being attributed to administrative roles that will become
redundant once ProSieben and SBS are forged together. Another 180
employees of Sat. 1 will lose their jobs as a result of daily magazine
formats being taken out of program schedules. Sat.1 managing director
Mathias Alberti has vehemently denied that the changes in programming
are results of the TV group's new owners. Nevertheless, the
reaction from media regulators and the public in Germany has been harsh.
Local Rheinland-Pfalz regulator LMK, which granted Sat. 1 its license,
launched a rather short-lived investigation into whether or not the
channel still meets its licence terms since, in order to be eligible for
analog cable distribution in Germany, channels have to prove that they
cover all genres, including news and information.
Even though it was fleeting, the regulators' move illustrates
just how sensitive the German authorities and public are when faced with
so-called "locusts." Other local media regulators are starting
to investigate the influence investors have in the German media
industry. They've already suggested implementing a limit to the
number of shares investors can acquire in various industries, including
the media. It remains to be seen whether this will pan out. Bernhard
Heitzer, president of the German antitrust watchdog Bundeskartellamt,
has already voiced opposition to the idea.
In the meantime, analysts are eagerly anticipating Permira and
KKR's next step. ProSieben has said that in order to reduce debt,
the companies may consider selling production company ProsienbenSat. 1
Produktion, which has 1,000 employees. Permira is also the owner of the
England-based production conglomerate All3Media that only this May
acquired the major German independent production house MME. If all this
is merged into one big group, another major pan-European player would be
formed. For now, it's all mostly speculation. And while the idea
has charmed some Wall Street-types, for German critics, politicians and
regulators alike, it might be a whole different story.
COPYRIGHT 2007 TV Trade Media,
Inc. Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.