Practice and research in career counseling and
development--2006.
by Tien, Hsiu-Lan Shelley
The author presents professional literature published in 2006
related to career counseling and development. The literature is
organized into 3 sections: (a) professional issues related to career
development throughout the life span, culture, ethnicity, gender, and
other specific topics; (b) research related to theoretical and
conceptual advances; and (c) career interventions and practice,
including issues related to career assessment and technology. Cohesive
themes throughout this review are the concepts of social context
embedded in career development, multicultural perspectives, and global
and international perspectives of career development. Research is
encouraged regarding career interventions that are based on career
theories specific to certain cultures and in general for global needs.
**********
The annual review organizes the professional career literature
published in 2006. This review of the literature was challenging, and I
did not realize how overwhelming this task would be until I became
immersed in the process. Despite my being overwhelmed, constant learning
occurred and made my teaching and supervision work abundant. To make the
literature review meaningful for career researchers and practitioners
alike, I tried to be succinct in searching for and including articles to
be reviewed. The search, therefore, was not exhaustive. Each article
published in The Career Development Quarterly, Journal of Career
Development, Journal of Career Assessment, Journal of Vocational
Behavior, and Journal of Employment Counseling was read. Next, a keyword
search was conducted on all journals published by the American
Counseling Association and on certain journals published by the American
Psychological Association. Career-related articles from the Journal of
Counseling & Development, Professional School Counseling,
Measurement and Evaluation in Counseling and Development, Journal of
Multicultural Counseling and Development, Journal of Counseling
Psychology, The Counseling Psychologist, Journal of Occupational Health
Psychology, Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research,
Journal of College Counseling, Journal of College Student Development,
Journal of Applied Psychology, Journal of Applied Developmental
Psychology, and Psychological Reports have also been included in this
review. During the literature search process, I noticed that there was
an increase in the number of studies concerning career counseling in
organizational settings and in career coaching. Thus, some relevant
career-related articles from Human Resource Management Review, the
Journal of Organizational Behavior, Human Relations, and Organizational
Dynamics have also been included. Finally, a search was conducted of
PsycINFO using a set of selected career development terms that
identified a few additional articles of interest from the Journal of
Business and Psychology, the Journal of Social Service Research,
Sociology, The Policy Studies Journal, the Journal of Labor Research,
the Counseling Psychology Quarterly, the Australian Journal of
Psychology, the Journal of Addictions and Offender Counseling, and the
Journal of Aging Studies. No books, book chapters, monographs, or
electronic media are included in this review. Ultimately, this annual
review covers 134 articles that were published in 2006 in refereed
professional journals.
The 2006 career counseling and development review is organized into
three broad areas: (a) professional issues; (b) career theory and
concepts; and (c) career interventions and practice, including career
assessment and technology. This review differs from the previous reviews
in that career assessment and technology were considered types of
interventions because there was a limited number of new assessment
instruments developed in the past year. The literature this year seemed
to focus more on examination of career intervention programs than in
previous years. In addition, in organizing this review, I chose to
discuss each article in only one of the three areas, although it was
clear that many articles could have been presented in more than one
area.
Professional Issues
Life Span Development
Youth and adolescents. Jacobs, Chhin, and Bleeker examined the
relationship between parents' expectations and their young adult
children's gender-typed occupational choices. The results indicated
that parents' gender-typed occupational expectations were
significantly related to their children's own expectations and to
the children's actual career choices. In addition, job satisfaction
was significantly related to having a gender-typed career. These
findings suggest that parents' early gender-typed expectations for
their children's occupational achievements are highly related to
the actual occupational decisions made by their adult children.
Kenny, Blustein, Haase, Jackson, and Perry conducted a longitudinal
study assessing the relationship between indices of career development
(career planfulness and career expectations) and school engagement
(belonging and valuing). The data were examined through structural
equation modeling for a multiethnic sample of urban ninth-grade
students. Higher levels of career planfulness and expectations at the
beginning of the academic year were associated with increases in school
engagement over the course of the year. The observed relationship
between career planfulness and expectations and school engagement is
consistent with emerging models of career development (e.g., Lapan,
2004) that seek to explicate the value of career development programming
as a component of educational reform.
Career development for students at the junior high level has drawn
more attention in recent years. According to Super's theory, high
school students span two of the life stages: growth and exploration. For
these students, a comprehensive career program that included
self-concept construction was important for career development. Bardick,
Bernes, Magnusson, and Witko assessed the career plans of junior high
school students in South Alberta in Canada. They found that junior high
students intended to combine full-time or part-time postsecondary
education with part-time work. The students were also confident about
achieving their future career goals. Bardick et al. concluded that
students as young as 11 years old would be ready to seriously consider
their future career plans. Therefore, this study suggested that career
planning programs need to begin at the junior high school level.
Taga, Markey, and Friedman examined boys' pubertal timing and
subsequent interpersonal success in midadulthood. Data from 460 boys
from another longitudinal study (the Terman Life-Cycle Study) were
examined over a 39-year period to relate age of pubertal onset to later
marital success, career success, and adult health behaviors. The results
indicated that boys who reached puberty earlier than their peers tended
to achieve greater success in their careers and experienced more
satisfaction in their marriages.
Diemer and Blustein explored the role of critical consciousness as
a key factor in predicting progress in career development among urban
high school students. Critical consciousness was operationally defined
as the capacity to recognize and overcome sociopolitical barriers
through sociopolitical analysis and sociopolitical control. Canonical
correlation analysis indicated a statistically significant relationship
between critical consciousness and progress in career development.
Participants with greater levels of critical consciousness had greater
clarity regarding their vocational identity, were more committed to
their future careers, and viewed work as a larger part of their future
lives. These results suggest that urban adolescents may best engage in
the career development process by maintaining a critical awareness of
sociopolitical inequity and situating their individual agency within
this critical "reading" of the opportunity structure.
Osborn and Reardon administered the Self-Directed Search (SDS) to
98 high-risk middle school students, who attended one of the 14
structured career groups based on the Cognitive Information Process
career theory (Peterson, Sampson, Lenz, & Reardon, 2002). The
results indicated that the SDS was a psychometrically sound instrument
for middle school students, especially those who were identified as
being at risk of dropping out of school. For those students, it seemed
to be particularly important to make the connection between school and
the world of work to develop interpersonal relationship and to increase
occupational knowledge.
Shapka, Domene, and Keating applied growth curve modeling to trace
the trajectory of the prestige dimension of career aspirations from
Grade 9 through 3 years post-high school as a function of gender and
early high school mathematics achievement. The sample consisted of 218
university-bound adolescents (129 female, 89 male). The findings support
the notion that mathematics achievement functions as a "critical
filter" to subsequent career aspirations, with youth who performed
poorly in Grade 9 mathematics aspiring to careers that were of lower
prestige.
COPYRIGHT 2007 National Career Development
Association Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.