Practice and research in career counseling and
development--2006.
by Tien, Hsiu-Lan Shelley
In Israel, Flum and Cinamon examined 338 teachers' attitudes
toward career education. They hypothesized that teachers' attitudes
toward career education plays a crucial role in the successful
implementation of relevant career-related programs in the school
curriculum. Results demonstrated similarity in the general pattern of
ranking of importance of career education goals for Arabic and Jewish
teachers, but significant differences emerged in relation to several
issues (e.g., self-knowledge, familiarity with range of occupation, and
experience with choice making). Differences are discussed as they
reflect diverse worldviews, the disparity between majority and minority
status, and differences in social structure.
In Southern Alberta, Canada, the Comprehensive Career Needs Survey
was used to assess the career plans of senior high school students in a
study conducted by Witko, Bernes, Magnusson, and Bardick. They examined
senior high school students' perceptions regarding (a) their future
plans, (b) confidence in attaining their career goals, (c) importance of
remaining in their community, and (d) where they anticipated working.
They found that a majority of respondents planned to combine full-time
education with part-time work. They were confident in executing their
career plans and anticipated finding work in their country. Results
indicated a need for programs that address career decision making and
the combining of education and work experiences.
In New Zealand, Higgins and Nairn investigated young people's
perspectives on transition during their last year of school. The
processes by which they made choices about postschool destinations were
also investigated. In particular, they examined the extent to which the
transitions the students negotiated were shaped by the institutional
infrastructure that guided the transition process. Although Higgins and
Nairn expected some degree of mismatch between the complexities of
participants' lives and the linear transition process implicit in
policy, they found instead a combination of traditional assumptions
(e.g., that transition would be a straightforward, linear process) and
late-modern assumptions (e.g., that elective biographies would be
constructed through active choice). These assumptions combined to
produce a particular perception of risk among participants.
Career Concerns in Specific Groups
Busacca and Wester examined career concerns of 152 counselor
trainees in seven master's-level programs accredited by the Council
for Accreditation of Counseling and Related Educational Programs.
Results indicated that near four fifths of the students reported a high
degree of interest for meeting the exploration and establishment stages
of career development. More specifically, the students were concerned
about the efforts required to gain more information about themselves and
about occupations. They were also concerned about how to express their
self-concept in an occupational role. In conclusion, counselor trainees
with high levels of concern for establishment-stage tasks reported
significantly higher levels of overall career concerns. Busacca and
Wester asserted that counselor educators must strive to be more aware of
the career development of graduate counselor trainees.
Gender Perspective
Lambert, Eby, and Reeves compared gender differences in
white-collar job-seekers' network system. They found that age
showed a curvilinear relationship with network diversity. A proactive
personality (e.g., one characterized by initiative and aggressiveness)
was found to be positively related to network intensity. However, no
effects were found for gender or race.
Schmidt and Nilsson agreed with the "bottleneck
hypothesis" proposed by Hetherington (1991). Schmidt and Nilsson
hypothesized that a bottleneck effect may interfere with the career
exploration of lesbian, gay, and bisexual (LGB) individuals because
their sexual identity development process might supersede development in
other areas (e.g., career development). This hypothesis was tested in
Schmidt and Nilsson's study with 102 LGB youth. The results
indicated that career maturity was predicted by inner sexual identity
conflict and social support, with a large effect size. Both inner sexual
identity conflict and social support were also found to predict career
indecision.
Career Uncertainty
Trevor-Roberts indicated that career uncertainty is a fundamental
experience that affects people's vocational behaviors, attitudes,
and emotions. He asserted that people experience uncertainty because of
the changed nature and structure of the world of work. He discussed
three approaches to interpret uncertainties experienced by individuals:
protean career, identity, and social constructionism. People feel
uncertain regarding their career for many reasons. They may be uncertain
about the meaning of "success" or uncertain about "who
they are" no matter how advanced they are in their career
development. People may also feel uncertain about themselves because of
their perceptions of the expectations society imposes on them. Because
of the many possible uncertainties, career counseling for uncertainty is
necessary. Positive uncertainty, planned happenstance, and complexity
theory are three approaches discussed in this article for career
counseling practice targeting both individuals and organizations.
Another perspective that attempts to explain career uncertainty is
the chaos theory, which Pryor and Bright examined in their article. They
also proposed a quadrant to help counseling practitioners understand the
relationship between different theoretical perspectives and practical
interventions. Practical techniques such as the signature exercise, the
sometimes magic exercise, and the parable of the ping pong ball were
also presented as examples of the concept of chaos theory in career
services.
Boundaryless Career and Social Context Embedded Career
R. Harrison used landlines and cell phones as metaphors for how
changes in technology and the world of work have affected the lives and
identities of workers today. In the postmodern world, changes in the
social context and global perspectives have changed the properties of
career to one that is described as mobile, self-determined, employer
independent, and free of hierarchy (DeFillippi & Arthur, 1994). How
an individual, as the center of meaning of career, creates narrative for
his or her career is an important issue for making sense of that
individual's career. The process of narrative construction is
grounded in cultural, political, religious, and social values. Thus, the
narrative approach to career counseling will become more prevalent in
creating a meaningful self and career through dialogue embedded in the
client's social context.
Career Competence and Ability
Career competence for the modern career was investigated by
Kuijpers and Scheerens. They asserted that the working environment is
now characterized by increased mobility, an increased level of support
from employers, and a variety of dynamics in the work environment. It is
argued that the following six competencies are needed to cope with the
modern career: career development ability, reflection on capacities,
reflection on motives, work exploration, career control, and networking.
The authors also asserted that having a mobility perspective is
important for career development and networking. In addition to personal
characteristics, networking and support from the dynamic work
environment are important to both internal and external career success.
To further investigate the relationships between career competencies and
career, Kuijpers, Schyns, and Scheerens invited 1,579 employees in 16
Dutch companies to complete a competence inventory that included the six
competencies discussed in the previous study (i.e., Kuijpers &
Scheerens). Personal and situation-linked variables were also measured.
Results indicated a negative relationship between motivation and
intrinsic as well as extrinsic career success. Employees who examined
whether their job corresponded with their personal values experienced
less career success than those who did not examine their job in this
way. It seems that individuals who are dissatisfied with their career
success might be more aware of the absence of these preferences in their
work. It might also be possible that there was lack of support from the
organization's staff. Overall, career control and networking
factors were strongly associated with career success. Kuijpers et al.
indicated that in addition to personal characteristics such as
motivation, reflection, and networking, career support from the work
situation and a dynamic work environment were found to be related to the
participants' career success.
COPYRIGHT 2007 National Career Development
Association Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.