From dot bomb implosion to the printing industry: my
personal and professional journey.
by Lockwood, Diane L.^Frayne, Colette A.^Callahan, Robert
E.
EXECUTIVE OVERVIEW
Since its founding in 1974, Printing Control Graphics (PCG), a
recent acquisition of Houston-based Consolidated Graphics (NYSE: CGX),
has been known as a high-end, boutique, commercial printer, producing
annual reports, presentation folders, catalogs, brochures, and direct
mail. Before 2000, PCG was a successful medium-sized printing company
with nearly $13 million in annual revenues. However, after the dot.com
bubble burst in 2000-01, the slide in earnings began with back-to-back
years of successive losses. But that was before Richard Lancaster joined
the ranks of this rapidly sinking ship in June 2003 as Vice President of
Business Development.
When Mr. Lancaster joined the company, revenues had fallen to $7.5
million and the company had an operating loss of more than -10%. At that
time PCG was owned by a failed consolidator called Kelmscott
Corporation, which in turn was owned by J. P. Morgan Chase and GE
Capital, and managed through the JPM workout banking group. The goal on
joining the company for Lancaster was to affect a turnaround and
transition as quickly as possible and to help the Kelmscott group's
effort to earn its way out from bank ownership.
Lancaster, at the age of 43, has lead PCG on a steady march back to
profitability. Revenues in 2004 jumped to $10 million from $7.5 million
in 2003 when he came onboard. However, the company's bottom line
still showed some red, with losses of $716,000 in 2003 and $100,000 in
2004. Then in April 2005, after the closing of the merger with CGX,
Lancaster was promoted to President of the company, and ever since the
company has been profitable each month. July 2005 operating income came
in at 18.5%, while the industry standard is around 5%. While the
turnaround and transition is not complete, Lancaster feels the company
is well on its way to becoming an industry leader in terms of operating
income. The organization-wide restructuring resulted in a:
* 20% reduction in the workforce.
* 19% replacement in the remaining workforce.
* Crossed-training 60% of the staff.
* Increased sales revenues due to new customers.
* 10% increase in cross-selling additional value-added services to
existing customers.
* Investment in new, state-of-the-art digital printing technology.
* Reduction in operating costs through various process efficiency
improvements.
Lancaster noted in a presentation to executives at his new parent
holding company that he set out six core ideas in leading PCG's
transition, but pointed out that these principles were not all that
different from using persistent, consistent, good management principles
anywhere:
* Sales Focus--"nothing happens until somebody sells
something!"
* Program Selling--sell value-added programs, not tactical printing
jobs.
* Cost Consciousness--embed this in everyone for everything we do
and make results clearly visible.
* Quality-Centric--customers know us as a high-end boutique
printer, thus we must deliver a quality product to differentiate
ourselves in the marketplace.
* People Focus--respect employee's longevity and knowledge. If
people truly feel valued, this is infectious in their interactions with
customers and with each other. Have fun (e.g., BBQ's for the staff
and horse races for customers).
* Insist upon integrity in all that we do--always take the high
ground on any issue where "circumstantial ethics" can creep
into decision making.
What is particularly amazing about Lancaster is that he had no
prior experience whatsoever in the printing industry I a traditionally
"good-oldboys" industry.
Born in England into a British military family, Lancaster spent his
youth traveling the world with his parents and attending Britain's
equivalent of The Citadel military boarding school, followed by a small
liberal arts college in Nottingham, England. Prior to joining PCG, he
held a number of sales and marketing executive positions in various
companies such as Dun & Bradstreet in Australia and England, Digital
Systems/Avaya in Seattle (a computer/telephony mainframe manufacturer),
and Nextel Communications, where he was the Director of Marketing. In
addition, in 1994 Lancaster started up CobWeb, Inc., one of the first
Internet companies in the Seattle area and a pioneer in the emerging
field of online technology.
By 1996 he was running the company profitably as CEO and by 1999 he
was actively funding the company through "angels" (i.e.,
private venture capital and institutional investors across the country
as he pursued a product development strategy). Lancaster fashioned
CobWeb into an ecommerce service provider, developing an application on
emerging Microsoft technology, E-Storefront. CobWeb was then backed by a
global investment banking firm, Lazard, out of San Francisco. Lazard and
CobWeb embarked on a consolidation of six other Internet systems
integrator firms across the U.S. and Canada to create a major new player
in the Application Service Provider field, providing enterprise-wide
application services to medium and large firms.
However, timing is everything, and CobWeb's attempts to raise
$60 million to fund the closing of seven simultaneous mergers of the
companies involved in the consolidation fell right into the abyss of
private equity investing that marked the beginning of the dot.com crash.
With the consolidation in tatters, the 9/11 disaster then served to
finish off CobWeb as a going concern as the technology marketplace was
lobotomized almost overnight and new sales revenues dried up. Lancaster
voluntarily closed the company in June of 2002, having paid off the bank
and all but a few of the creditors, laying off over 40 people, and
transitioning the customers and technology to another firm to be
supported.
Personally devastated by his first major business failure, and the
cruel reality of "Thanksgiving Dinner Syndrome" ("when
you have to face relatives over the Thanksgiving dinner table for the
rest of your life knowing they lost their investment in your
company"), he dropped out of fulltime business for 12 months and
worked as a part-time consultant on an Open Source project out of
Singapore, as well as on the very successful launch of
"Scene-It?," a new DVD board game--now the fastest selling
board game in history. Lancaster licked his wounds and contemplated his
future.
What happened to Lancaster, like so many of his startup peers, is
both a personal and professional transition story--going from the highs
of running your own company and negotiating with investment banks and
venture capital firms, to the depths of despair, having lost it all, and
then career uncertainty. What lessons can be drawn from this experience
and applied to company turnarounds and transitions across different
industries?
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN DOT.COM AND PRINTING INDUSTRIES
It is conventional wisdom that different types of skill sets and
business foci are needed to successfully lead a high-tech start-up
versus a relatively stable, mature industry (see Figure 1). Therefore,
it is not surprising that the founders of startup companies are often
replaced by managers whose skill sets and experiences are more
consistent with a pattern of stable growth. It is equally plausible,
however, that a manager of an entrepreneurial venture may adapt his or
her behaviors to fit changing business demands and environments. In
other words, a manager can change his or her behaviors to a certain
extent, dependent upon his or her prior experiences and predisposition,
rather than it being assumed that they should be "replaced."
In PCG's case, sales skills were necessary to grow top-line
revenues, given historically slim industry operating margins and
increasing price competition as a result of consolidation. Sales skills
are often transferable from business to business--as the old adage goes,
"a good salesperson can sell nearly any product or service,
provided a market exists for it!" Lancaster's previous
background, primarily in executive sales and marketing positions, meant
he could bring his considerable sales acumen to bear on PCG's
turnaround.
THE INTERVIEW
Richard Lancaster was selected for this interview because of his
unique career path in which he transitioned from the high tech startup
industry to a very traditional printing industry where he has never held
a previous position. The general research questions were: (1) "What
made him want to undertake this career transition?, (2) Are certain
managerial skills and practices transferable across industries?, and (3)
If yes, what are these?" The initial and subsequent interviews took
place in Lancaster's office in Seattle, Washington. What follows
are the questions asked by interviewers, and a summary of his responses.
Question 1: Why and how did you make such a profound personal
career transition from a high-tech startup industry to a very
traditional printing industry where you have never held a previous
position? What kinds of insights helped you make this transition?
Response: At first, when I had to shut down CobWeb, I was
personally devastated and burned-out. I felt somewhat like a war
veteran--the experience was awful, but what was one to do upon returning
to civilian life where there were lots of unknowns? For years I had
written a high-tech column in the local business journal, lectured at
business schools on entrepreneurialism, and sat on the board of the MIT
Forum, as well as various startup company boards of directors. I even
helped startup five or six companies. I worked very hard and kind of sat
back and somewhat selfishly wondered what I had gotten out of all of the
effort.
COPYRIGHT 2007 Pittsburg State University -
Department of Economics Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.