The Great Moderation and the relationship between
output growth and its volatility.
by Fang, Wen-Shwo^Miller, Stephen M.
[not equal to] post-1982
t test 0.7024
Structural stability test for [H.sub.0]: pre-1982 = post-1982
unconditional variance [H.sub.1]: pre-1982 > post-1982
F test 3.7772 [0.0000]
Standard errors appear in parentheses; p values appear in brackets.
The measures of skewness and kurtosis are normally distributed as
N(0,6/T) and N(0,24/T), respectively, where T equals the number of
observations. LB Q(k) equals a Ljung-Box statistic testing for
autocorrelations in growth up to k lags. LM (k) is the Lagrange
multiplier test for conditional heteroscedasticity, distributed
asymptotically as [chi square](k). ADF(n) equals the augmented
Dickey-Fuller unit-root test with n lags selected by the Schwarz
Criterion. The t statistic tests for structural change in the mean
between samples i and j. The F statistic equals the variance-ratio
test between samples i and j, asymptotically distributed as
F([df.sub.i],[df.sub.j]), where df denotes degrees of freedom.
* 5% significance level.
** 10% significance level.
Table 2. GARCH-M Results without Structural Break
[y.sub.t] = [a.sub.0] + [a.sub.1][y.sub.t-1] +
[a.sub.2][y.sub.t-2] + [lambda][[sigma].sub.t] +
[[epsilon].sub.t]; and [[sigma].sup.2.sub.t] =
[[alpha].sub.0] + [[alpha].sub.1][[epsilon].sup.2.sub.t-1] +
[[beta].sub.1][[alpha.sup.2.sub.t-1]
[a.sub.0] [a.sub.1] [a.sub.2] [lambda]
0.4267 * 0.2371 * 0.2002 * 0.0911
(0.1648) (0.0692) (0.0725) (0.1960)
LB Q (3) LB Q (6) LB [Q.sup.2] (3) LB [Q.sup.2] (6)
1.6828 4.2863 0.7517 6.7173
[0.6407] [0.6379] [0.8609] [0.3477]
[[alpha].sub.0] [[alpha].sub.1] [[beta].sub.1]
0.0106 0.1606 * 0.8355 *
(0.0123) (0.0492) (0.0434)
Skewness Kurtosis Jarque-Bera LR
0.1388 0.8898 * 8.5442 * 0.0213
[0.3870] [0.0059] [0.0139] [0.8839]
Maximum log-likelihood function value: -76.5102
ARCH-M Results without Structural Break
[y.sub.t] = [a.sub.0] + [a.sub.1][y.sub.t-1] +
[a.sub.2][y.sub.t-2] + [lambda][[sigma].sub.t] +
[[epsilon].sub.t]; and [[sigma].sup.2.sub.t] =
[[alpha].sub.0] + [[alpha].sub.1][[epsilon].sup.2.sub.t-1] +
[[beta].sub.1][[alpha.sup.2.sub.t-2]
[a.sub.0] [a.sub.1] [a.sub.2] [lambda]
0.3891 ** 0.3223 * 0.1611 * 0.1130
(0.2247) (0.0755) (0.0651) (0.2497)
LB Q (3) LB Q (6) LB [Q.sup.2] (3) LB [Q.sup.2] (6)
2.6000 5.8491 1.0033 8.7188
[0.4575] [0.4403] [0.8004] [0.1904]
[[alpha].sub.0] [[alpha].sub.1] [[beta].sub.1]
0.3661 * 0.3107 * 0.3730 *
(0.0564) (0.0883) (0.1190)
Skewness Kurtosis Jarque-Bera LR
-0.0293 1.2352 * 15.0378 * 2.6977
[0.8551] [0.0001] [0.0005] [0.1005]
Maximum log-likelihood function value: -85.6076
Standard errors appear in parentheses; p values appear in brackets;
LB Q(k) and LB Q2(k) equal Ljung-Box Q-statistics tests for
standardized residuals and squared standardized residuals for
autocorrelations up to k lags. LR equals the likelihood ratio
statistic following a [chi square] distribution with one degree of
freedom that tests for [[alpha].sub.1] + [[beta].sub.1] = 1
or [[alpha].sub.1] + [[alpha].sub.2] = 1.
* 5% significance level.
** 10% significance level.
Table 3. GARCH-M Results without Structural Break at 1982: I
[y.sub.t] = [a.sub.0] + [a.sub.1][y.sub.t-2] +
[a.sub.2][y.sub.t-2] + [lambda][[sigma].sub.t] +
[[epsilon].sub.t]; and [[sigma].sup.2.sub.t] =
[[alpha].sub.0] + [[alpha].sub.1][[epsilon].sup.2.sub.t-1] +
[[beta].sub.1][[alpha.sup.2.sub.t-1] + [gamma] Dummy, where
Dummy = 1 for t [greater than or equal to] 1982:I; 0 otherwise.
[a.sub.0] [a.sub.1] [a.sub.2] [lambda]
0.4427 * 0.2634 * 0.1757 * 0.0519
(0.1361) (0.0694) (0.0726) (0.1633)
LB Q (3) LB Q (6) LB [Q.sup.2] (3) LB [Q.sup.2] (6)
2.4247 5.4342 0.8279 4.9614
[0.4890] [0.4894] [0.8427] [0.5487]
[[alpha].sub.0] [[alpha].sub.1] [[beta].sub.1] [gamma]
0.3948 * 0.0801 * 0.6271 * -0.3322 *
(0.1958) (0.0692) (0.1767) (0.1651)
Skewness Kurtosis Jarque-Bera LR
0.0944 0.1846 0.6862 17.5179 *
[0.5560] [0.5684] [0.7095] [0.0000]
Maximum log-likelihood function value: -64.1225
ARCH-M Results with Structural Break at 1982:I
[y.sub.t] = [a.sub.0] + [a.sub.1][y.sub.t-2] +
[a.sub.2][y.sub.t-2] + [lambda][[sigma].sub.t] +
[[epsilon].sub.t]; and [[sigma].sup.2.sub.t] =
[[alpha].sub.0] + [[alpha].sub.1][[epsilon].sup.2.sub.t-1] +
[[alpha].sub.2][[epsilon].sup.2.sub.t-2] + [gamma] Dummy, where
Dummy = 1 for t [greater than or equal to] 1982:I; 0 otherwise.
[a.sub.0] [a.sub.1] [a.sub.2] [lambda]
0.4644 * 0.2880 * 0.1559 * 0.0254
(0.1366) (0.0751) (0.0714) (0.1619)
LB Q (3) LB Q (6) LB [Q.sup.2] (3) LB [Q.sup.2] (6)
2.3699 5.3571 0.7853 4.2135
[0.4992] [0.4988] [0.8529] [0.6478]
[[alpha].sub.0] [[alpha].sub.1] [[alpha].sub.2] [gamma]
0.9886 * 0.1891 * 0.0959 * -0.8191 *
(0.1843) (0.0844) (0.1125) (0.1754)
Skewness Kurtosis Jarque-Bera LR
0.1307 0.1385 0.8607 18.1591 *
[0.6967] [0.4153] [0.6502] [0.0000]
Maximum log-likelihood function value: -64.7860
GARCH-M Results with Structural Break at 1984:I
[y.sub.t] = [a.sub.0] + [a.sub.1][y.sub.t-1] +
[a.sub.2][y.sub.t-2] + [lambda][[sigma].sub.t] +
[[epsilon].sub.t]; and [[sigma].sup.2.sub.t] =
[[alpha].sub.0] + [[alpha].sub.1][[epsilon].sup.2.sub.t-1] +
[[beta].sub.1][[alpha.sup.2.sub.t-1] + [gamma] Dummy,
where Dummy = 1 for t [greater than or equal to] 1984:I; 0 otherwise.
[a.sub.0] [a.sub.1] [a.sub.2] [lambda]
0.4396 * 0.2365 * 0.1888 * 0.0516
(0.1296) (0.0728) (0.0671) (0.1621)
LB Q (3) LB Q (6) LB [Q.sup.2] (3) LB [Q.sup.2] (6)
2.0877 4.0421 1.2643 6.3881
[0.5543] [0.6709] [0.7376] [0.3811]
[[alpha].sub.0] [[alpha].sub.1] [[beta].sub.1] [gamma]
1.0989 * 0.1025 * 0.0737 * -0.9326 *
(0.5406) (0.0893) (0.4186) (0.4615)
Skewness Kurtosis Jarque-Bera LR
0.0652 0.2646 0.8633 26.3497 *
[0.6830] [0.4115] [0.6494] [0.0000]
Maximum log-likelihood function value: -62.2568
ARCH-M Results with Structural Break at 1984:I
[y.sub.t] = [a.sub.0] + [a.sub.1][y.sub.t-1] +
[a.sub.2][y.sub.t-2] + [lambda][[sigma].sub.t] +
[[epsilon].sub.t]; and [[sigma].sup.2.sub.t] =
[[alpha].sub.0] + [[alpha].sub.1][[epsilon].sup.2.sub.t-1] +
[[alpha].sub.2][[epsilon].sup.2.sub.t-2] + [gamma] Dummy,
where Dummy = 1 for t [greater than or equal to] 1984:I; 0 otherwise.
[a.sub.0] [a.sub.1] [a.sub.2] [lambda]
0.4360 * 0.2592 * 0.1806 * 0.0533
(0.1369) (0.0706) (0.0746) (0.1618)
LB Q (3) LB Q (6) LB [Q.sup.2] (3) LB [Q.sup.2] (6)
2.6621 5.0311 0.4254 5.1444
[0.4467] [0.5398] [0.9349] 0.5254
[[alpha].sub.0] [[alpha].sub.1] [[alpha].sub.2] [gamma]
1.0628 * 0.0913 * 0.0823 -0.8914 *
(0.1946) (0.0821) (0.1073) (0.1828)
Skewness Kurtosis Jarque-Bera LR
0.0759 0.1963 0.6057 22.1019 *
[0.6360] [0.5441] [0.7386] [0.0000]
Maximum log-likelihood function value: -62.7772
Standard errors appear in parentheses; p values appear in
brackets; LB Q(k) and LB Q2(k) equal Ljung-Box Q-statistics tests
for standardized residuals and squared standardized residuals for
autocorrelations up to k lags. LR equals the likelihood ratio
statistic following a [chi square] distribution with one degree
of freedom that tests for [[alpha].sub.1] + [[beta].sub.1] = 1
or [[alpha].sub.1] + [[alpha].sub.2] = 1.
* 5% significance level.
Table 4. Subsample Results with Structural Break at 1982:I
AR(1): 1947:1-1981:IV
[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ACSII]
[a.sub.0] [a.sub.1] [lambda]
0.8160 * 0.3089 * -0.2937
(0.4157) (0.0900) (0.6735)
LB
COPYRIGHT 2008 Southern Economic
Association Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.