Medical liability matters.
by Beers, Lee Savio
Medical liability insurance and litigation linger in the back of
many young physicians' minds. Once they leave the relative legal
security of a residency program, many physicians are unclear how to best
protect themselves and their practices. Simple answers are hard to
find--largely because they don't exist!
The area of medical liability is complex and has many stakeholders.
A quick Google search reveals a vast array of resources, most of them
prepared by insurance companies or law firms that offer medical
liability coverage or representation. Although they may offer good
information, it is hard to know when and where bias may be present.
As someone who is certainly no expert in this area, I set out to
find clear, helpful, and unbiased information that could serve as a good
starting point for learning more about the topic.
First, I turned to the sources I use most regularly for practice
management issues, the American Academy of Pediatrics (www.aap.org) and
the American Medical Association (www.ama-assn.org). Both sites offer
detailed information to nonmembers and members alike (although the more
robust resources are offered to members only). In particular, the
AAP's Young Physicians Section (www.aap.org/sections/ypn/
yp/practice_management) and Practice Management Online
(http://practice.aap.org) offer additional resources and links.
I also discovered that a number of state medical associations
present detailed, state-specific information regarding medical liability
insurance and regulations. Pediatricians and other physicians who have
been practicing in your area for many years also are an important source
of real-world information and feedback regarding specific insurance
carriers.
Finally, it is very important to mention that everything I read
emphasized the importance of legal and/or professional consultation when
deciding on a malpractice insurance carrier or if faced with potential
litigation. As I mentioned earlier, this is a very complex topic with
many nuances, and unless you are an MD/JD (or even if you are), you
could probably benefit from outside help.
If you are trying to select a professional liability insurance
company (or are looking for much more detailed and industry-specific
information), there are a few other additional online resources to help
you: the Physician Insurers Association of America (www.piaa.us) and the
National Association of Insurance Commissioners
(www.naic.org/state_web_map.htm).
No discussion of professional liability insurance would be complete
without mentioning ways to avoid ever needing to use it. More than half
of all suits against physicians never go to court or are settled without
requiring payment on the part of the physician.
Avoiding the circumstances that require a trial is the best
possible outcome for both the patient and the physician.
Following are several quick (but by no means comprehensive) rips
for minimizing risk in your practice:
* Document, document, document. Many concerns arise months or years
after the contact with the patient. Be sure you clearly document all
components of your encounters, including any telephone calls. If you
anticipate that a concern may arise in the future, it probably is
worthwhile to spend extra time documenting the details of that visit.
Never alter a medical record. If you need to make changes, cross out
your error with a single line (so that your error is readable) and note
why the change was made. If you realize at a later date that something
hasn't been documented, date your entry on the day it was made and
annotate it as a late entry.
* Ensure adequate follow-up. Be sure you discuss (and document)
with your patients when, why, and where to come back. Be sure to include
continued or increased parental concern as a reason to return.
* Stay up to date on current medical practice. Don't hesitate
to consult with colleagues and specialists.
* Spend time listening to, talking to, and educating your patients.
Many lawsuits could have been avoided if the practitioner had spent a
few extra moments to address a family's or patient's concerns.
Obviously, this is a big topic that is (and should be) important
for physicians of all ages. Consider this column as a starting point for
continued learning and research to ensure comprehensive risk management
and liability protection for yourself and your medical practice.
BY LEE SAVIO BEERS, M.D.
DR. BEERS is an assistant professor of pediatrics at
Children's National Medical Center in Washington. She also is a
member of the PEDIATRIC NEWS editorial advisory board and the American
Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Residency Scholarships. Write to Dr.
Beers at our editorial offices, pdnews@elsevier.com.
COPYRIGHT 2008 International Medical News
Group Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.