Susan Choi's American Woman (**** Nov/dec 2003), a Pulitzer
Prize finalist, fictionalized the abduction of Patty Hearst; here, she
successfully tackles terrorism in an alienated America. Praised by the
New York Times Book Review as "combining the unhurried pleasures of
certain classics with the jittery tensions of more recent fiction,"
A Person of Interest is more notable for its acute psychological insight
and focus on one man's discovery of himself than for its whodunit
elements. A few reviewers faulted the flashbacks and ending and thought
the novel too ambitious for its central character, but the majority
commended Choi's piercing exploration of how terrorism leads both
to alienation and self-knowledge.
****
The age of shiva
By Manil Suri
An Indian saga.
In 1955 Delhi, 17-year-old Meera, from a well-to-do Hindu family,
falls for Dev, a handsome, aspiring singer. After being discovered in a
compromising position, they marry, despite opposition from Meera's
progressive and manipulative father, Paji. When Meera enters Dev's
household, she starts to accept his family's lower status and
religious orthodoxy--as well as her mistake in her choice of husband.
Meera and Dev accept Paji's offer to help them move to Bombay
(renamed Mumbai in 1995), but happiness remains elusive. Even after the
birth their son, the sole bright spot in her life, Meera realizes that
in order to obtain true happiness, she must navigate between the
traditional and the modern and wrest control of her life.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Norton. 448 pages. $24.95. ISBN: 0393065693
Ft. Worth Star-Telegram ****
"Amid the current wave of Indian novelists, Suri stands out
for his tendency to minimize the exotic aspects of South Asian life. ...
In the book's final chapters, Suri reveals that his broader
interest is in how family shapes one's obsessions." AMAN
BATHEJA
Milwaukee Jrnl Sentinel ****
"Meera's story is filled with examples of the way she and
other women are held down, and Suri manages to convey Meera's
frustration and anger in a voice that rarely falters. ... That he has
constructed another fascinating and frustrating portrait of Indian
society, however, is his novel's greater success." VIKAS
TURAKHIA
Oregonian ****
"Panoramic yet personal, epic yet intimate, The Age of Shiva
is a rich read, full of the sights and sounds of tumultuous political
years in India during the country's struggle for
independence." HOLLY JOHNSON
NY Times Book Review ****
"The Age of Shiva is painted in broad, colorful strokes that
sometimes evoke the melodramatic movies so beloved in India. ... The
novel would have been richer if Suri had infused it more deeply with the
world-shaping changes that surround his heroine." CARYN JAMES
Seattle Times ****
"Many of Suri's literary trademarks are in evidence here:
a wealth of detail, luminosity of prose, vivid portrayals of mundane
human interactions. ... At 455 pages, it is overly long and slow to
unfold." BHARTI KIRCHNER
Washington Post **
"Not only does the narrative move slowly, sometimes it grinds
to a halt. suri will linger far too long over a scene, describing with
guide-book precision a sports competition, a Hindu wedding ceremony or
religious ritual, an erotic encounter. His descriptions often go beyond
local color to dogged, anthropological exactitude." MICHAEL DIRDA
CRITICAL SUMMARY
Manil Suri's debut novel, The Death of Vishnu (PEN/Faulkner
Award nominee, 2002), satirized families in a single apartment building
in Bombay. The Age of Shiva, about women's subjugation,
postindependence Indian politics, and Hindu-Muslim conflicts, offers a
more panoramic view of Indian society. A few critics compared it to
Salman Rushdie's Midnight's Children, but The Age of Shiva is
a smaller, tighter work, ambitious in scope if not as wholly successful.
Written as a letter from Meera to her son, the novel shines with
luminous prose, Hindu myths, and mother-child bonds, but bogs down as it
chronicles the decades. Most critics agreed, however, that Suri
effectively portrays Meera as the embodiment of an India caught between
tradition and modernization.
****
Detective Story
By Imre Kertesz, translated from the Hungarian by Tim Wilkinson
The system is the mystery.
In an unnamed Latin American country, a repressive military junta
has given way to a new regime. Antonio Rojas Martens, a member of the
secret police and torturer for the old government, will soon face trial
for multiple murders, but first he must confess his violent crimes and
the methodology that guided him. That confession forms this short novel,
which follows Martens's unrelenting pursuit--and arrest, torture,
and assassination--of a wealthy father and son, who find themselves
forced to cover up crimes they never committed. Though divorced from any
particular time or place, Martens's story reveals a
"logic" of totalitarianism that is relevant to readers
anywhere. Knopf. 128 pages. $21. ISBN: 03077266443
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Los Angeles Times ****
"The story is constructed with a delicate, scientific
objectivity, working like a trap. ... This short, spare book, a fable
about what governments do and the guilt a man tries to stop feeling, can
be read in a couple of hours; its bleak, despairing effect will haunt
for much longer." RICHARD RAYNER
Seattle Times ****
"Kertesz underlines the absurd tone by consistently finding
humor in the mundane. ... Critics have compared Kertesz to Kafka and
Beckett, as well as novelist-memoirist Primo Levi. Perhaps this novel
could have been written only by a survivor of Buchenwald." JOHN
HARTL
NY Times Book Review ***
"Martens's real subject of investigation is what he calls
'the logic,' a term used to describe the elusive forces that
govern an authoritarian state. ... Unfortunately, in order to get to
Kertesz's nuanced exploration of his theme one must overlook a
surprising array of tonal miscues and awkward formulations, for which
the translator, tim Wilkinson, surely does not deserve all the
blame." NATHANIEL RICH
CRITICAL SUMMARY
Imre Kertesz, who won the Nobel Prize in Literature in 2002, is
best known for his novels about the Holocaust and the attempt by
survivors to reconstruct a life in the aftermath. Since he lived both
through concentration camps in Poland (Auschwitz) and in Germany
(Buchenwald) and through Communist rule in Hungary, critics were eager
to read his further insights into totalitarianism. Though the book was
written three decades ago, critics found this new English translation to
be relevant not only because of its literary quality but for its bearing
on ongoing debates over torture and terrorism. At the same time, no
reviewer compared this short novel to Kertesz's better-known books,
including Fatelessness (1975), about a child deported to Auschwitz
(filmed in 2005 as Fateless). The New York Times Book Review, in
particular, cited stylistic distractions that undermined the
author's "difficult, haunting truth." Detective Story,
while compelling in its exploration of totalitarianism, might not be the
best starting place for readers wishing to explore this laureate's
oeuvre.
****
Dogface
By Jeff Garigliano
A not so Young adult novel.
When Loren, a 14-year-old boy obsessed with the military, tries to
burn a Navy SEAL symbol into the golf course where his mother's
latest boyfriend works, he is carted off to a rehabilitation
"camp" for delinquent teens. It's not long before he
realizes that Camp Ascend!--a polluted and abandoned music camp run by
the "Colonel," a scheming ex-con, his dim-witted wife, and her
sadistic brother--is a fraud, despite the slick promises printed in its
glossy brochure. Using his imagined martial skills, Loren pretends that
he is a POW behind enemy lines. He's soon recruiting his fellow
captives in a desperate bid for revenge and, ultimately, freedom.
MacAdam Cage. 325 pages. $23. ISBN: 1596922583
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Dallas Morning News ****
"With its bizarre characters, frank dialogue and violence, it
belongs somewhere between Louis sachar's Holes and a carl Hiaasen
comic thriller. ... despite the cliches, the novel never loses its
freshness." ANNE MORRIS
Denver Post ****
"Dogface is a kids vs. adults tale where the teens, despite
what they were up to before camp, have right on their side. ...
Garigliano shows a nice sense of black humor in his debut novel that
makes Dogface a book that will make the reader laugh and cringe at the
same time." JANNA FISCHER
Entertainment Weekly ****
"Finding an unexpected niche between Ya fiction, military
fantasy, and chick lit for dudes, Dogface succeeds via a combination of
snappy action and strong characterizations." WHITNEY PASTOREK
Cleveland Plain Dealer ***
"The book sags in the middle--too much time at camp--but the
author has an ear for the thoughts and speech of adolescents. ... Though
good, the novel lacks the manic edge and black cynicism of [carl]
Hiaasen's best stuff." JAMES F. SWEENEY
CRITICAL SUMMARY
COPYRIGHT 2008 Bookmarks Publishing
LLC Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.