Rejected by 25 publishers before finally making it into print,
former Naval officer Jeff Garigliano's debut novel is being billed
as adult fiction despite its young protagonists and adolescent themes.
"I looked at 'young adult' books and I didn't like
them and it didn't belong there,' states Garigliano. Most
critics agreed with him, citing the novel's black humor, violence,
and sex scenes. (Only the Cleveland Plain Dealer felt these elements
were "gratuitous, like a sex scene added to a movie to avoid the
dreaded 'PG' rating.") Despite the debate over the
novel's proper market and a few slow spots, the critics were
pleased with Garigliano's strong characters, authentic dialogue,
and obvious gift for humor that had reviewers laughing out loud.
****
How the Dead Dream
By Lydia Millet
Disappearing lives in a dying world.
T., a smooth and successful Los Angeles real estate developer
obsessed with money since childhood, is driving home after viewing a
potential construction site when he hits and fatally wounds a coyote. As
he stops and sits with the animal until it dies, his carefully
constructed, impassive facade starts to fracture, and he experiences his
first-ever spasms of compassion. When his girlfriend dies tragically,
his father disappears, and his latest project decimates a colony of
kangaroo rats in the Mojave Desert, T. copes with his grief and guilt by
breaking into zoos and sleeping near endangered species, seeking solace
in his newly discovered connection to the Earth as his life unravels.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Counterpoint. 256 pages. $24. ISBN: 1593761848
Chicago Sun-Times ****
"For the reader, T.'s adventures with animals carry more
emotional impact than any of the human encounters. They prompt the
serious, sometimes convoluted but always moving meditations that are the
spine of this strange, lovely novel." KIT REED
Kansas City Star ****
"With a master's in environmental policy from duke,
Millet sees the natural world with clear-eyed urgency and the social
landscape with wisecracking, dark humor. How the Dead Dream is an edgy
telegram on behalf of nature and its singular beasts." JEFFREY ANN
GOUDIE
Los Angeles Times ****
"T.'s evolution from capitalist to caretaker functions
both as allegory and character study, and works if the reader lends t.
his sympathies. ... He's rendered in such complex, fine detail--as
carefully etched as one of the engravings he studies on the backs of
dollar bills--that he comes alive, irresistibly sympathetic, both
deadpan and deep." CAROLYN KELLOGG
San Diego Union-Tribune ****
"T. comes off as less than three-dimensional, perhaps because
of the twin burdens of parable and parody on his character. ... [Millet]
writes marvelously, with a sense of hilarity, but also with a deep
passion, especially apparent in her acknowledgments in which she
dedicates the book [to extinct and rare species]." WENDY L. SMITH
San Francisco Chronicle ***
"The brevity and opacity of [the character of T.'s
girlfriend] don't support the histrionic period of mourning that
follows, which, along with T.'s strained relationship with his
out-of-the-closet father and his mother's descent into dementia,
slow down the middle section of the novel considerably. ... By
presenting the facts of biological extinction in a bizarre and
compelling fiction, the novel behaves more like the zoo animals T.
visits: You may be interested in them, but they're not necessarily
interested in you." ANDREW LELAND
Seattle Times ***
"But for all of the acuity that impregnates this novel (the
first in a projected trilogy), and for all of the ambition, one big
problem remains. T. is as emotionally skeletal a character as his
initial is a name." BARBARA LLOYD MCMICHAEL
Washington Post **
"Unfortunately, Millet clogs her moving story with a variety
of distracting dead ends: T.'s father 'goes' gay; T. has
an affair with a crippled woman; T.'s mother slips into dementia;
T.'s only friend is a wealthy jerk of cartoon-like crassness. ...
Worse is Millet's tendency toward abstraction and pretentiousness,
which sometimes smothers her wit." RON CHARLES
CRITICAL SUMMARY
Lydia Millet, a social novelist with a master's degree in
environmental policy, has carved a reputation for herself by exploring
difficult topics in edgy, darkly humorous works of fiction. How the Dead
Dream--part philosophical meditation, part fable, and part comic
escapade--argues for the importance of environmental protection as it
portrays T.'s metamorphosis from coldhearted capitalist into
compassionate child of the Earth. Critics differed in their opinions of
T.'s character: is he a finely-wrought, sympathetic protagonist or
a one-dimensional cardboard cutout? A few critics also complained about
the many side plots that slow the novel's momentum and blur
Millet's message. However, T.'s internal struggles and quest
for redemption stress humankind's responsibilities and limitations
as stewards of the environment--a timely message indeed.
ALSO BY THE AUTHOR
OH PURE AND RADIANT HEART (2005): The creators of the atomic
bomb--Oppenheimer, Enrico Fermi, and Leo Szilard--are transported from
the 1940s to 2003, where they come face to face with the effects of
their invention. (**** Nov/dec 2005)
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
****
The Learners
By Chip Kidd
Experimentation, 1960s style.
Introduced in The Cheese Monkeys (2001), Happy, a recent art school
graduate in the 1960s, lands a job as a graphic designer at a small,
quirky New Haven ad agency. He happily navigates his new world of
eccentric colleagues and lunchtime cocktails as he learns the trade.
When he designs a small newspaper ad for a psychological study on
authority and obedience, he willingly embraces the era of
experimentation and answers it himself. He soon becomes involved in the
infamous Mil-gram experiments as a "teacher" who administers
dangerous electric shocks to "learners." Soon enough, Happy is
not so, well, happy--and starts to confront some long-held beliefs about
himself.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Scribner. 258 pages. $26. ISBN: 0743255240
Los Angeles Times ****
"As Happy tries to get his bearings after the experiment, the
imagery remains somewhat vivid but takes on a slightly more pedestrian
form. ... Snags are inevitable when it comes to form versus function,
but Kidd's quirky approach to life is endearingly recognizable in
its expression." EDWARD CHAMPION
Newsday ****
"For me, the resolution of the story sped by too fast, with
subthemes suggested rather than explored--though perhaps that will be
remedied if Kidd follows Happy to a new locale in his next novel?"
DEKKER DARE
Oregonian ****
"Reading the Cheese monkeys beforehand will add more depth to
the overall picture of Happy's life (like how he got his nickname).
Both novels are humorous and insightful and full of amusingly accurate
scenes from the early 1960s--right down to the threemartini lunches and
pillbox hats." NICOLE CHVATAL
USA Today ****
"Best known for his book-jacket designs, Kidd puts the story
on pause at times so he can discuss design, literary styles and the link
between form and content. the interludes may be self-conscious, but
they're also genuinely interesting and mercifully brief."
ROBERT BIANCO
Christian Science Monitor ***
"Although Happy's odd adventures are captivating, there
is an essential element missing from this sequel: the unique graphic
design assignments that Happy and his classmates at state U. received in
the Cheese monkeys. ... So design professors (and others) hoping to
score a sheaf of cool new design assignments will have to stick with
Kidd's first book." LAURA DISTEL
NY Times Book Review ***
"Where [it] fails, when it does, is in character development,
tone, affect--all those intangibles that are neither Form nor content,
but are conjured up by the interplay of the two." JAMES PONIEWOZIK
CRITICAL SUMMARY
Graphic designer and novelist Chip Kidd is best known for his smart
book-jacket designs for Donna Tartt, David Sedaris, and Michael
Crichton, among others. He used his innovative design elements to
explore the relationship between form and content in The Cheese Monkeys,
and he employs the same design virtuosity here, though critics diverged
in opinion about how much virtuosity, exactly, was enough. While most
reviewers praised Kidd's design talent, a few thought he courted
gimmickry with his page and font designs, and others thought he
didn't go far enough. With the exception of the New York Times Book
Review, however, reviewers agreed on Kidd's ample literary
talent--his dark, satirical wit, solid characterizations, and ability to
explore the dark abyss of the human soul. For pure originality,
there's little else like The Learners--except, of course, The
Cheese Monkeys, where readers may wish to start.
****
Mudbound
By Hillary Jordan
A Southern tragedy.
BELLWETHER PRIZE
COPYRIGHT 2008 Bookmarks Publishing
LLC Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.