Total body photography helps reduce unnecessary
biopsies.
by Worcester, Sharon
SAN ANTONIO -- The use of total body photography as a surveillance
tool for melanoma has great potential to reduce the number of
unnecessary biopsies, Dr. Allan C. Halpern said at the annual meeting of
the American Academy of Dermatology.
When used appropriately in conjunction with self-examination and
regular follow-up, total body photography (TBP) can also increase the
likelihood of detecting thinner melanomas, said Dr. Halpern, chief of
dermatology at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York.
Although it does have some disadvantages--namely the possibility of
raising the threshold for removal of lesions in favor of follow-up in
patients who may not return for follow-up--it also has a number of
possible advantages for both patients and physicians, he said.
The key is to use TBP cautiously. The first visit is not the time
to raise the threshold for removing a suspicious lesion in anticipation
of using TBP for surveillance. Instead, build a relationship before
relying on the patient to perform self-evaluations and come in for
routine follow-up visits. Once a relationship is established and the
patient is compliant, TBP can be a great tool for engaging patients in
their own care and increasing patient satisfaction, he noted.
The sensitivity and specificity of TBP for melanoma are increased
in those who do come back. Studies have shown that patients who are
engaged in their care because they receive copies of the photos and are
asked to do monthly serf-examinations by comparing lesions with the
photos are more likely to do self-examinations and are more likely to be
effective when performing self-examinations than are patients who do not
receive photos, Dr. Halpern said.
As a result, the use of TBP is increasing. A survey of AAD members
showed 63% of 105 residency programs use TBP and 49% of AAD members use
it at least some of the time in patients with dysplastic nevi.
Furthermore, 83% of programs with specialized pigmented lesions clinics
and 49% of those without such a clinic are using TBP.
Those who don't use TBP cite perceived logistical
difficulties, financial constraints, and doubt about its benefits as
reasons for not using it, he said.
The use of TBP requires only a digital camera of at least 6-12
megapixels (although he uses one with 40 megapixels), a computer, and a
space with good lighting and the availability of a blue or black
backdrop, Dr. Halpern explained, also noting that a CPT code for TBP
exists.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
As for benefits, one small study showed no difference in detection
of melanoma for those who used and didn't use TBP. It did show an
increase in sensitivity and specificity for detection of nonmelanomas,
and another showed that twice as many patients who received photos were
compliant with recommended care, including self-examination, than those
who were not.
The actual taking of the photographs can be uncomfortable for the
patient, so it is a good idea to perform a physical examination first.
Dr. Halpern always starts with the patient facing away from him to allow
the patient time to acclimate to the discomfort of the situation and to
allow himself time to regain composure before facing the patient should
he encounter an alarming lesion.
Photos can be taken by the physician, a specially trained nurse, or
a medical photographer. Some practices have a photographer on staff, and
hospitals may employ photographers and be accommodating when it comes to
TBP services. "You can achieve very high-quality pictures if you
nail down a system and use it in a sufficiently standardized
fashion," Dr. Halpern said, noting that there are papers in the
literature to provide guidance for using TBP.
Basically, as much of the body surface as possible should be
photographed, and positioning should be chosen to allow this.
Side-by-side (photos and patient) examinations can then be
conducted at follow-up visits. He recommended examining patients while
they are standing, which makes it easier to compare lesions against
those in the photos.
Patient privacy needs to be carefully protected, so photos kept on
office computers should be encrypted, he said.
Patients should be provided with hard copies and a compact disk
along with a photo-marking pen that they can use to mark the photographs
if they find something of concern on their monthly self-examination.
It is important to inform patients that their role in performing
self-examinations is not meant to be anxiety provoking; rather it should
be an exercise in becoming familiar with the big picture so they can
recognize obvious changes and fast-growing lesions that might be of
concern.
Dr. Halpern used a night-sky analogy to describe how patients
should view their photos. If they become familiar with their own
"constellations," they will notice when something new appears
in the field, or if something other than the North Star is shining
brightest. The patient's job is to notice the obvious changes; the
physician's job is to find the subtle changes, he said.
As for which patients are the best candidates for TBP, he suggested
using it for those with dysplastic nevi who have undergone many
excisions and those with a familial or personal history of melanoma. No
prospective data exist to guide how often patients should be seen, but
every 6 months has been a good interval in Dr. Halpern's
experience. "We do find the vast majority of melanomas in
surveillance with these patients.... This is one of the major reasons
for doing total body photograph."
BY SHARON WORCESTER
Southeast Bureau
COPYRIGHT 2008 International Medical News
Group Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.