Rhodes, V. James, Jan L. Dauve, and Joseph L. Parcell. The
Agricultural Marketing System--Sixth Edition, Holcomb Hathaway
Publishers: Scottsdale, Arizona, 2007, 372 pp., $53.95.
One of the major strengths of agricultural economics and
agribusiness management programs is the requirement of a solid grounding
in microeconomics. Students who understand basic economic principles
such as supply and demand, marginal analysis, how markets operate, and
the benefits of specialization and trade have a distinct advantage in
grasping the fundamental business skills such as finance, production,
and marketing. The new sixth edition of this book by Rhodes, Dauve, and
Parcell is an excellent way to ensure that this critical connection
between economics and marketing is formed.
This text has endured for six editions because of its unwavering
focus on that objective. As they state in the preface: "The focus
of this text has always been, and remains, on training future managers,
decision makers, and opinion leaders as to the economic drivers of the
agricultural value chain" (p. xi). As generic business programs
give way to "domain based programs" such as agribusiness,
others are learning the importance of fully understanding the industry
in which they operate. We have known for years that our strength comes
from our appreciation of the biological and perishable nature of the
agricultural commodities and food products that we sell. Agricultural
economics and agribusiness were global before global was more than an
afterthought in most other business curriculums. Many of our special
institutions such as futures and options markets are gaining greater
acceptance in business school curriculums. All of these issues are
addressed in this text.
The material is offered using a behavioral systems approach
"that focuses on the interdependence and coordination of all the
participants and all the functions in the entire system. It focuses on
the flow of products as it is facilitated by a flow of market
intelligence and on those firms and institutions where major decisions
are made and where market leadership is exercised. Such an approach
examines market power in the system and the leadership roles exercised
by large or innovative firms. It shows how differing market structures
require different types of production and marketing decisions.... In the
1990s the behavioral systems approach spawned contract production and
marketing to enhance control of value, risk, and decision rights
(functional and institutional elements). For example, a hog processor
might offer a marketing contract to a would-be supplier in order to
control quality (functional) to meet a special retailer need
(institutional)" (p. 10).
These topics are presented from the perspective of an agribusiness
manager and shows "marketing problems as problems facing managers,
whether he or she is a farmer, an assembler, a processor, or a
retailer" (pp. 10-11).
The book is organized in two parts. Part I (Marketing, Market
Competition, and Consumer Markets) deals with applying microeconomic
analysis to marketing issues. These include a discussion of how the
different market situations--perfect competition, oligopoly, and
monopolistic competition--affect how firms operate and market their
products. A chapter is devoted to price determination, how markets
clear, and how to use price as feedback to guide future production
decisions. Separate chapters deal with an economic analysis of consumer
purchasing decisions, and agricultural trade.
Part II (The Marketing System) takes a broader perspective on
marketing by examining subjects that transcend a single firm. These
topics include different pricing and exchange systems with emphasis on
price discovery and price setting systems, contractual exchange
arrangements, and the impact of vertical integration on the whole
process. A chapter covers contractual arrangements that include trading
by description and quality and how grading affects this process. Details
of the grading of selected commodities such as grains, cattle, beef,
fruit/vegetables and milk/dairy are provided. Storage and transportation
marketing activities are covered in a single chapter.
The final six chapters concentrate on the changing marketing
environment faced by agribusiness firms. An extensive chapter is devoted
to the increasingly important subject of market price risk. The authors
show how hedging using futures and options provide an effective way to
avoid much of this is variance. Three chapters are devoted to the
development and use of market power in marketing channels. The final two
chapters in this section are devoted to the role of the processors,
wholesalers, and retailers who deal with differentiated products and
national brands. Each topic in this section is presented from a systems
perspective so that it "offers readers an understanding of how
decisions at one level in the value chain impact all other levels and
explores if, how, and when the system changes and evolves as a result of
cumulating individual decisions" (p. xii).
Rhodes, Dauve, and Parcell bring a comprehensive look at the
subject of agricultural marketing that includes discussion of
contemporary issues in marketing from a mainly agricultural commodity
perspective. All the topics are presented in a straightforward manner
with many examples.
To assist student learning, each chapter begins with a preview of
the important ideas and terms so that students will know what to look
for while they are reading. A summary of the key points is also given at
the end of the chapter plus a number of students questions. A small
group exercise is also given so students can apply what was learned. The
chapter organization leads itself to the use of active learning so there
can be less reliance on straight lecture presentation. It is unclear
whether the book comes with instructor support in the form of visuals
and teaching manuals.
The behavioral systems approach is an effective way to address this
topic. It is important for students to understand how economics can
enhance a manager's ability to understand what is happening within
their business and how to navigate its external business environment
effectively. The authors of this text do both very well.
James G. Beierlein
Pennsylvania State University
COPYRIGHT 2008 American Agricultural Economics
Association Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.