Virtually no problems: by exploring the virtual
reality of a project with solid modeling, Dave, and the shop, can find
issues and resolve them before the chips start to
fly.
by Sterling, Dave
Every so often a project will come to the shop that is above and
beyond the standard job that normally rolls through. Such was the case
when a group of three similar parts came across my desk. The parts, at
first, looked intimidating. Large blocks made of forged steel, they had
two precision bores as well as many cross-drilled holes, SAE ports, and
on top of those, they were to be whittled into shape from solid blocks
of steel. This would be a challenge from all standpoints of
manufacturing engineering. With the help of many talented people, the
project came together. A constant aid in a project like this was my
solid modeling software.
At Ansco we use SolidWorks design software for many aspects of job
preparation. For this particular job, I first sat down with the prints
and created solid models of the parts.
This step may seem redundant, but it lets me understand the part.
But, the modeling process can be similar to the machining process: as I
remove stock from the model, I can visualize in my head how we would
remove the stock from the piece itself. Doing this part of the process
early in the manufacturing cycle also is a way to check our
understanding of the part before we've invested a lot of time and
energy into the part.
Discovery Phase
In this particular case, we discovered a few small errors on the
drawing that could have had major consequences if discovered during an
inspection process after the machining was done. This let us clean up
the problems, and let us raise machining questions to our
customer's engineer. This resulted in some feature changes that
didn't affect the performance of the part, but made it easier for
us to machine.
Once we had the parts modeled, and a keen understanding of them, my
father Mike, my brother Jon, and I locked ourselves in a room to
brainstorm and collect ideas. After much deliberation and many cups of
coffee, we had a whiteboard filled with sketches of each of the
part's operations. We had confidence in our methods, and after
getting the approval of our milling foreman. Tim, I set to work in
SolidWorks again.
After snapping a digital picture of the whiteboard, I started
modeling the fixtures, one by one. After the basics of the fixtures were
done, I began to knit them together to make an assembly of the pallet of
the machine.
Modeling in such a way provides early feedback as to whether or not
the idea will work in real life: Is there enough room for a clamp there?
Can we bolt the part to the table properly? Can we attach the fixture to
the machine's pallet?
All of these questions are answered as the assembly comes together.
Fixture Fixes
Once we saw that the fixtures would fit together, it was time to
separate them into individual parts again. This time we used SolidWorks
to create drawings of the individual fixture parts for manufacturing
them on the floor. We were not just using parts we were machining
ourselves, we also would be buying some fixture components. We can model
these parts of the fixture too, but sometimes there is no need.
Several retailers, such as Carr Lane, Reid Supply, and Jergens
offer solid model downloads of their products. This saves time modeling
the components, as well as ensures that what we're ordering will
fit together when it's time to make it happen on the machine.
With a few mouse clicks, I had my extra components modeled, and had
them ordered, too.
The fixture models are important in tool selection as well. Tool
reach becomes an issue when put in the middle of the pallet. By modeling
the spindle nose and the tools themselves, we made an early
determination whether a particular tool would reach its target.
The last aspect of project design using the solid model is
programming. Ansco owns a CAM system that is integrated into SolidWorks.
It has a fair integration into the whole process, and I can use the
models I create to generate the G-code for use on the floor.
Admittedly, it doesn't always work like it says on the side of
the box, but with some extra tweaking we can establish the groundwork
for a solid horizontal machining center program.
Solid modeling played an important role in the engineering portion
of this project. Most of the tasks could be performed without it, but I
certainly wouldn't want to do without it. When the next time a big
project comes into the shop, I'll be ready.
Dave is responsible for programming, tool selection, and fixture
design for Ansco Machine's 20 CNC machines in Peninsula, OH.
What do you think?
Let us know by e-mail from our website at
www.ModernApplicationsNews.com or e-mail the editor at
pnofel@nelsonpub.com.
Dave Sterling, Application Engineer Ansco Machine Co.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
COPYRIGHT 2008 Nelson
Publishing Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.