Becoming subjects.
by Ciezadlo, Janina
Afterimage • March-April, 2008 • Girls on the Verge
The works in this exhibit are at once notable photographs and
important documentation of the shift in representation that has taken
place during our time. "Girls on the Verge" offers the viewer
an important opportunity to survey the work of women photographers who
have been able to represent and redefine themselves. The inclusion of
the work of a male photographer, Steinmetz, is significant in that the
curator is thus able to balance her inquiry and keep the field open. The
questions that the photographs pose in images parallel the inquiries of
sociologists, philosophers, writers, and others who have studied gender
during the last thirty years. Is adolescence the transition during which
girls' bodies become useful to men as objects of desire and
exchange in a patriarchal context or is this process important in a
woman's life? Do women and girls present themselves to the world or
are they offered up to the male gaze? Are women's photographs
different than men's photographs or does the camera itself trip
some balance? Some of the photos seem to point to answers regarding the
contested categories of girlhood, childhood, and the tricky
relationships between subject and object. Others suggest that after all
we have learned about femininity, women's bodies, gender, and
culture, many of the girls in these photos remain as elusive and
enigmatic as ever.
JANINA CIEZADLO is a writer and artist who has taken many
photographs of her own daughter.
NOTE 1. Sandra Bartky wrote an important essay, "Foucault,
Femininity and the Modernization of Patriarchal Power," widely read
in the 1990s, arguing that Foucault's concept of discipline applies
only to men. She then applied his concepts of social control to women
contending that patriarchal cultural messages (discourse) constructs
women's bodies as deficient. Hence dieting, clothing, and other
time-consuming attempts at becoming acceptable are a form of social
control of women's bodies that result in keeping them
"docile."
COPYRIGHT 2008 Visual Studies
Workshop Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.