The Black Stone
Linda Cargill
Cheops Books
8746 E Wallen Ridge Dr., Tucson, AZ 85710-6235
ISBN 9780979890406, $19.95
I am really struggling with the events that take place in "The
Black Stone." I have an opinion, which is totally mine, that may or
may not be the opinion of any other. "The Black Stone" was one
of those novels that brought you back and forth in time, I guess in
order to explain the story itself. We went all the way back to the
Cleopatra days along with Julius Caesar. The author was trying to bring
forth the point of origin of "The Black Stone," however; the
time it took to read about that part of the time in history, was too
lengthy. I think that part of the story could have been written with
less explanation, but still bring us to understand where the "The
Black Stone" really came from. Everyone in the world has their own
opinion on the happenings of 9/11. I am not sure that the author
realized how much she brings back the memories of 9/11 in her story.
Some people would probably welcome the story in the novel as a reminder
of the events of that day, but myself, I did not like reliving those
events. The author bringing Osama Bin Laden into the mix brought back
some very haunting memories and had me wondering what Osama has been up
to these days. It reminded me of how dangerous of a man he really is.
The storyline was a good one, but as I said the explanations were
very lengthy. I was disappointed in the outcome of the character
Madeline's family. I think that a different ending would have been
better. As you travel along with Madeline and her endeavors, it is a
very good and a very interesting part of the novel. What becomes of
Madeline is wonderful, very nice, I was pleased.
I believe that the author, Linda Cargill, had a vision of a novel
that she wanted to write, which included in her mind, terrorist times
and tribulations. Maybe she felt as though she needed to get her
thoughts on paper. I would only recommend this book to adults, as
children would only become frightened in reading about the reality of
what can happen in this world. Some of you may enjoy this novel, may
really get all the points and plots. You have to read it to find out. I,
however, have a problem with looking into the minds of terrorists and
Osama Bin Laden. I think the author's efforts in "The Black
Stone" are good and she should not take offense to any one
person's judgment. Maybe the novel was just not for me. In closing,
I actually did enjoy a large part of the story. I wish the author good
luck in future writings.
COPYRIGHT 2008 Midwest Book
Review Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.