Patients on chronic opioids can be safe
drivers.
by Boschert, Sherry
SAN FRANCISCO -- On driving simulators, 51 patients on chronic
opioids performed just as well as 49 control subjects, preliminary data
from an ongoing study found.
The conventional recommendation that patients taking chronic
opioids should avoid driving may not be necessary, Dr. Asokumar
Buvanendran and associates stated in a poster presentation at the annual
meeting of the American Society of Anesthesiologists.
The randomly selected patients in the opioid group were taking
20-60 mg/day of opioids for chronic pain. They and the age-matched,
randomly selected control subjects spent 3 minutes practicing on a
driving simulator and then took a 12-minute test on the simulator in a
quiet room. The study excluded subjects with any medical condition or
other medication regimen that could affect driving skills.
There were no significant differences between groups in measures of
attention, reaction time, or number of crashes, reported Dr.
Buvanendran, an anesthesiologist at Rush University, Chicago.
Members of both groups veered a mean of 4 feet from the center line
during simulated driving (a measure of attention). Even the best drivers
had "accidents" because of the demanding structure of the
driving course, and each group averaged five crashes per driver.
Reaction times were 0.67 seconds in the opioid group and 0.69 seconds in
the control group, a difference that was not statistically significant.
Results for the two groups were statistically equivalent, separate
analyses showed.
Chronic opioid use has increased in the past decade as physicians
have become more attuned to the need to treat chronic pain,
coinvestigator Jeffrey S. Kroin, Ph.D., said in an interview at the
meeting. The doses used by the study patients are higher than starting
doses and are more typical of doses taken by patients on opioids for 6
months or longer for problems such as complex regional pain syndrome,
said Dr. Kroin, also of the university.
Package labels for opioids caution against driving and many other
activities while on the medication, but these restrictions may be
"ultraconservative" for patients on chronic therapy once they
have adjusted to the drug.
"There may not be any true impairment," Dr. Kroin said.
"Realistically, there are people who have been on chronic opioids
for 10-20 years and have been driving. What should physicians be telling
these people?"
Setting more reasonable restrictions on patients taking chronic
opioids could greatly improve their quality of life, coinvestigator
Mario Moric, Ph.D., added in an interview.
If they're not allowed to drive, patients have more difficulty
taking care of themselves, shopping for groceries, and getting to the
clinic if they need help with a problem. These patients tend to get
isolated.
"We want to take away a restriction that may not be that
critical to their or anybody else's safety," said Dr. Moric,
also of the university.
Driving is one of the more complicated tasks that people do on a
regular basis, as it requires many different sensory inputs, cognitive
skills, and timely reactions. That made it a good task for assessing the
functional effects of chronic opioids, he said.
The study is ongoing, with a goal of enrolling hundreds of
subjects.
The investigators also are starting a separate study of the effects
of anesthesia on driving after ambulatory surgery. Typically, patients
are told not to drive for at least 24 hours after ambulatory surgery,
even if they feel fine, Dr. Kroin noted.
That restriction is "vestigial, because of the kinds of
anesthetics that we used 40-50 years ago. It was true they had a long
half-life," but more modern anesthetic agents may not necessitate a
24-hour restriction on driving, he suggested.
BY SHERRY BOSCHERT
San Francisco Bureau
COPYRIGHT 2007 International Medical News
Group Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.