Confluence of structural and cyclical change clouds
outlook for 2008 and beyond.
by Gnuschke, John E.^Alvarado, B. Lewis
A third main concern would have to be inflation. The November 2007
Consumer Price Index (CPI) showed a year-over-year spike of 4.1 percent.
While the CPI for 2007 came in at 2.8 percent, prospects for continued
commodity and energy price increases will put further upward pressure on
domestic inflation.
Finally, perhaps of most concern would have to be the pace of job
creation. Slower job growth will further erode consumer confidence and
place a drag on spending.
Q2. Looks like housing will be a drag on the economy for most of
2008. Can anything be done to stem the hemorrhaging in the housing
sector?
There are currently proposals for loan modification programs and
counseling service items on Congress' agenda, and the Bush
administration has brokered a voluntary-driven agreement that would
freeze about 1 in 5 subprime mortgage rates for a number of years.
Another change would allow Fannie Mae to increase its loan threshold to
$729,750. The Federal Reserve is also getting into the act by proposing
new rules on mortgage lending, one of which would require lenders to
verify applicants' incomes. Even the FBI has entered the fray,
seeking to determine fraudulent activities associated with mortgage
lending practices. Such initiatives are addressing only the fringe
elements of the housing crisis and are unlikely to solve the core issue
of just plain bad mortgage loans. Already, numerous financial
institutions are estimated to have writedowns totaling $100 billion.
Critics of such programs complain that government intrusions into the
mortgage market would only be rewarding those who took out risky loans
and would ultimately disrupt the mortgage lending market for years to
come. The best prospect for housing rests with lower mortgage rates
(restoring affordability) and a return to a more rational process of
assessing suitability for granting or refinancing a mortgage. Mortgage
rates have fallen below 6.0 percent and could stay there for most of
2008. The key factor will be the size and pace of foreclosures. While
estimates range as high as one million foreclosures in 2008, focusing
attention and resources in this area would go a long way in keeping the
housing market from imploding.
Q3. Consumers have weathered numerous storms in the past, such as
the dot.com bust and historically high gasoline prices. Now comes the
subprime debacle. Will 2008 be the year we see a significant downshift
in consumer spending?
Consumer spending was particularly dismal during the fourth quarter
of 2007, raising concerns that consumers were going into hibernation.
While consumers remained marginally positive during the last
recessionary period, prospects for an actual decline fundamentally
depend upon two factors: the pace of job creation and rising incomes.
Another factor analysts point to is known as the wealth effect. Over the
past few years home equity lending was touted as propelling consumer
spending forward to lofty heights. With the drying up in home equity
lending, the stock market was expected to take over the role of
providing a wealth cushion under the consumer. But, after reaching
record levels in mid 2007, the stock market has experienced a
precipitous downturn due to higher oil prices and the spreading credit
squeeze. Only one thing could trump the growing consumer pessimism
caused by feeling less wealthy and believing that a recession is on the
horizon--that's job growth. While the unemployment rate stood at
4.8 percent for February 2008, consumer confidence has plunged to its
lowest level in five years. Taken as a whole, consumer spending will be
painfully slow for the first half of 2008, with tax rebates adding a
boost to consumer spending for the second half of the year. The key
component to gauging the health and attitude of consumers will be their
spending on durable goods. Spending on autos, appliances, and
electronics, albeit subpar, will determine if the economy can stay on a
positive growth trajectory.
Q4. U.S. businesses appear reasonably sound financially and are
anticipated to take up some of the slack due to softening consumer
spending. What can we look forward to from the business sector?
Businesses have already taken up some slack, with solid
nonresidential construction investments absorbing some of the housing
construction job losses. Equipment and software spending gained a little
momentum during the second and third quarters of 2007, but expectations
are that this spending sector might be the first to show signs of
weakness during the first half of 2008. The Institute of Supply Managers
Index has fallen below the 50.0 mark, and industrial production has been
trending downward. Recent surveys have shown that CEOs' confidence
levels have slipped to their lowest level since 2000, and 2008 opened
with negative job growth. The main problem is that businesses are likely
to take a "wait and see" attitude. Since business spending is
correlated to hiring, any delay will most likely contribute to the
malaise in the job market. Even with expanded tax incentives from the
stimulus package, business spending can be expected to be subdued for
the first half of 2008 as the slowdown unwinds. However, with better
prospects for consumer spending later in the year, businesses will
respond and resume spending and hiring plans for the second half of
2008. The key component to gauging business attitudes will be hiring in
the business services, information, and financial activities sectors.
Q5. The Federal Reserve is in an aggressive mode to cut the federal
funds rate to keep the soft landing from becoming a hard landing. Will
the prospect of more interest rate cuts ahead be enough of a cushion to
steer the economy clear of a recession?
The roller coaster ride of the federal funds rate over the last few
years seems to have created as many problems as it has resolved. Since
there is a lag between an interest rate move and its ultimate effect on
economic activity (generally considered a year), recent cuts will have
no immediate impact on spending. However, there is an immediate effect
that is more related to confidence by convincing financial markets that
the Fed is steering the ship in the right direction. Since a 100 basis
points cut in September 2007, two dramatic cuts of 125 basis points in
January and 75 basis points in March, the federal funds rate stands at
2.25 percent. Such a dramatic swing is unprecedented and opens the door
to a potential loss of credibility if the moves don't work. While
the interest rate cuts will make money cheaper, there remain questions
as to their impact on spending, since debtors gain, but savers lose.
Right now, the Fed is more worried about the slumping economy and
pumping up liquidity to negate the effects of the credit crunch than it
is about inflation. In the past, particularly during the inflationary
period of the early 1970s, the Fed was criticized for lowering interest
rates in the face of rising inflation. A key inflection point will be
the next Fed meeting on April 30th where it will decide once again
between recession (further cuts) and inflation.
Q6. There was a mad stampede to get some kind of government
stimulus package passed to stave off a recession. The mantra was that it
must be timely, targeted, and temporary. Will such a stimulus package
resuscitate the economy?
A check in the mail should make those who receive it feel a little
better about their situation. At an estimated $160 billion, the stimulus
plan was hammered out in record time, with checks to be written and
delivered starting in May. Some higher income groups are excluded from
the plan, while individuals who don't usually pay any income taxes
will get a check if they file a return. However, many analysts are
concerned that the stimulus plan will increase the federal deficit,
causing lasting economic consequences beyond 2008. There are still
lingering questions concerning the impact of a previous stimulus package
in 2001. Most analysts agree that the rebates boosted spending, but
there is considerable debate over just how much. Some of the 2001
rebates were used to pay off debts rather than to make purchases. In the
best case scenario, the new stimulus package will kick in during the
second half of 2008, just as economic growth is anticipated to be
improving.
Q7. Now it is time to pull out the proverbial crystal ball and make
a forecast for 2008. Will there be a recession in 2008?
COPYRIGHT 2008 University of
Memphis Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.