Donors with access: things shouldn't be quiet at
this library.
by Clolery, Paul
There was always one kid in class who ruined things for everyone
else. That was true starting with kindergarten and running through
college. In kindergarten, it was the kid who blew bubbles when gum was
grudgingly permitted by the teacher with the caveat that there be no
bubbles or snapping. During college, students in a literature class were
given the choice of either a final paper or an exam. The decision had to
be unanimous. One person opted for the exam, for which she didn't
show up.
Bill and Hillary Clinton were probably those kids in their
respective classes, always pushing the envelope to the eventual
detriment of their classmates. Whether it's an Arkansas land deal,
a questionable investment in the futures markets or now donations to a
presidential library, the Clintons have always found a way to contort
the rules to their advantage. What's going on with donations to the
William J. Clinton Presidential Library, while his wife is in the U.S.
Senate and is running for president, endangers the overall charitable
sector. Large donations from mysterious sources will at least start the
discussion of regulation changes with regard to large gifts to political
organizations tied to an individual elected official.
The current rules are pretty clear when it comes to politics,
donors and the nonprofit sector. Donors of $5,000 or more must be listed
on Schedule B of the federal Form 990. That part of the form is not a
public document. But, flip through the annual report of almost any
organizations and the names of donors are there for the world to see. Of
course, there are always a few "anonymous" donors in the
annual reports.
Politicians have always had civic organizations to which
"friends" could contribute. That money generally is in the
less than $5,000 category and thus excluded from being listed. It is
amazing though, how little it can take to get someone's attention.
When the mayor of Bridgeport, Conn., was indicted for corruption, one of
the counts was the acceptance of just $4,450 in kitchen appliances.
Surely the Clintons don't need that handy little Magic Bullet
for the kitchen in their Chappaqua, N.Y. home. But you have to wonder
why huge donors to Bill Clinton's presidential library don't
want to be identified. Bill and Hill also reported more than $100
million in income since he left office and she went to the U.S. Senate.
Presidents make a fortune on the speaking tour after they leave office
but nobody has raked it in like Bill Clinton, the guy with a wife in the
Senate. There was shock when former President Ronald Reagan accepted $1
million to speak in Asia. That's chump change for Bill. And,
President Reagan wasn't peddling influence with a nudge and a wink.
Long gone are the days of Billy Beer, when a presidential family
member, in that case Billy Carter, has to back away from nickel and dime
endorsements.
To suggest that Bill has no influence with his wife is ridiculous,
given she is running nearly conjoined to him. It's safe to say
Billy (Carter not Clinton) had little say in Jimmy's
administration. Though, history does repeat. It only took 20 years for a
presidential candidate to have to get some distance from a
self-promoting family member named Billy.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Peddling influence happens all the time under the cloak of
tax-exempt organizations. An outside observer can easily see the
conflicts of interest. No politician--former presidents nor former dog
catchers--should be able to market their access to elected officials
under the cloak of a tax-exempt organization. The Internal Revenue
Service needs to promulgate new rules, expanding on the prohibition
regarding electioneering. The nonprofit sector doesn't need another
round of beers.
COPYRIGHT 2008 NPT Publishing Group,
Inc. Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.