IN THE GLOBAL MEDICAL COMMUNITY, THE DISPARITIES in the quality of
supplies and equipment are too obvious to overlook. Routine tools,
blades, and protective clothing used in surgical or emergency procedures
in medical centers are plentiful among richer countries such as the
United States, Canada, or Great Britain. Ironically, some of the very
countries where such materials are manufactured are missing them.
What's as common as bread and butter to some is a rare treasure to
others--particularly in the Third World, where that treasure is so
critical to survival.
Just ask Dr. Jaime Altamirano, a medical epidemiologist with the
U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. His home country of
Ecuador faced torrential rains and flooding caused by storms born out of
La Nina weather patterns earlier this year. Hospitals and clinics are
also being flooded--with patients who can't be guaranteed quality
care because of a limited space and, more significantly, scarce
supplies.
"The government is facing the needs of the community,"
Altamirano says. "[The flooding] started in January and is
predicted to last through the end of April. As of now, five provinces
are affected, and all those hospitals and health care facilities are
overcrowded, ill-equipped, and without supplies. Poverty is a difficult
word for the people, but when you talk of poverty in institutions,
you're talking about less-than-needed staff, poorly paid staff, and
no supplies."
The case for improving a country's health care system
isn't always a matter of revolution. In many cases, it's
simply a drive to heal and care for as many people as possible.
Unfortunately degraded hospitals and clinics often lead to failure
despite the noblest efforts because they lack the necessary tools. Such
a scenario is a familiar environment in dozens of countries,
particularly in Latin America, Africa, and along southern Asia.
Through its personnel-fueled supply chain and distribution
operations, MedShare International--a nonprofit organization based in
Decatur, Ga., near Atlanta--aims to be a remedy for global health care
shortfalls. Founded in 1998, the group collects, recycles, and
distributes surplus medical supplies and equipment from health care
systems nationwide, with nearly one-third given by hospitals and clinics
in the metropolitan Atlanta area.
Wills Moore, MedShare's director of operations, says that
routine donation pickups and deliveries by U.S. health systems bring
thousands of pounds of materials and equipment that would otherwise be
thrown away. The bestowed items are collected, sorted, and stored within
MedShare's inventory warehouse and held until the items are
requested by global recipients in need. Since its inception,
MedShare's inventory flow has been almost nonstop.
Moore also says that MedShare's operation combats a negative
tag sometimes placed on humanitarian aid organizations--such groups are
only giving what they have. But the group essentially maintains a
medical surplus treasure chest for Third World health care requests,
fulfilling as much of any wish list made by those who are asking for
aid.
"The big rap against humanitarian aid, in general, is that
'we're not sending what they need, but what we have.' A
lot of organizations will take a big bag of unsorted supplies and just
send that. What we're doing is creating boxes of the same item,
putting that into our inventory system, and when an [international]
hospital receives approval to receive a shipment, then they can go
online and order item-by-item."
Think of it as Amazon.com for medical surplus, Moore adds. A sample
list of requested items given by MedShare to Industrial Engineer
essentially resembles a how-to guide on building your own medical care
operation (minus pharmaceuticals, which MedShare does not collect or
include in its donations). Almost every letter in the English alphabet
has at least three items attached to it--drains, drapes, and dressings
(with gauze and tape); plastic ware, procedural trays, and pulse
oximeters; stethoscopes, sutures, and syringes. Almost any American
hospital can corral such a list without worry.
Don't expect Altamirano's Ecuador to relate. "When I
came to MedShare, I found they were a good resource of medical supplies
and equipment that could be used to assist in a larger way to our
needs," he says.
Med sharing
The medical items donated to MedShare are often sent to the garbage
among most hospitals, Moore says. Some tools and in-between knick-knacks
are part of whole kits that hospitals can't use following a
surgical or medical procedure or don't have time to place back into
its own stock. Other products can't be used due to government
regulations, production overages, damage to the cosmetic package, or new
tools that make the older models obsolete.
"When you talk to nurses in areas we're [seeking
donations from], it's so devastating for them to see that stuff
going in the garbage," Moore says. "They're thrilled to
know that we've got solutions for that."
The solution operates almost entirely by a volunteer-driven system.
Students, area health workers, and even those with mental or physical
disabilities frequent the MedShare facility to filter thousands of
pounds worth of medical supplies. The volunteers are first introduced to
the system with brief instruction, explaining how tools need to be
sorted, how to find expiration dates, and how to make a box full of a
particular item for inventory.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Incoming supplies are divided among four or five tables, each
surrounded by volunteers seeking specific items and sorting them into
boxes that will later be marked and accounted for within MedShare's
electronic inventory tracking database. MedShare staff monitor the
volunteers, answer questions when necessary, help remove surplus that
absolutely cannot be useable, and enter inventory data into the system,
which managers of international hospitals and clinics access to pick
which items they most immediately need.
Quality management is a collective effort among the various members
of the operations team, says MedShare's national development
director Danielle Hegedus. A collaborative partnership manager focuses
on in-kind product and equipment donations; a biomedical engineer works
on procuring, assessing, and repairing biomedical equipment; a staff
inventory and logistics manager monitors fulfillment of container
shipment orders; and a distribution center manager focuses on order
fulfillment and scheduling donation pickups.
"We have defined certain standards regarding products and
equipment that we can and cannot accept," Hegedus says. "There
is a fairly high quotient of 'junk' that is offered to
organizations like ours, so we are continuously trying to improve our
processes for assessing potential donations and ensuring that we only
accept and ship items which our recipient hospitals really can
use."
The sorting room at MedShare has no assembly line or any other kind
of mechanics or robotics that common manufacturing or distribution
centers include. But volunteers--usually more than a dozen to as many as
30 in the room--are able to maintain a moderate pace in their sorting,
mostly thanks to the 25 or more examples of surplus tools and items
they're asked to look out for in the sorting process.
For example, if a volunteer is asked to collect syringes for
inventory, they are able to look at and touch different examples of
syringes that hang from one panel. In front of that panel is a 60-gallon
barrel with a large plastic bag, which is used to contain syringes found
by other volunteers who are tasked with finding other kinds of supplies.
The items in the bag are then emptied onto a sorting table at a later
time so that they can be included in the inventory. Neighboring rooms at
MedShare include bundles of utensils and electronic equipment, most of
which are contained in buckets, wall pockets, or shelves.
The key aspect of MedShare's operation is arguably the
48,500-square-foot inventory warehouse, which resembles a typical
Sam's Club grocery store--shelf after shelf of items boxed and
sitting on pallets waiting for loading and shipping. MedShare officials
say the average value of inventory in its warehouse at any time is
around $7.5 million. Supply orders are shipped to various countries in
40-feet-long containers that stand about 8 feet tall and 8 feet wide.
Each container can hold roughly 1,000 standard supply boxes or up to
12,000 pounds.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
And though there are no formally trained industrial engineers on
staff, MedShare officials keep an eye out for how their system can be
improved. They've already had help from several undergraduate IE
students from nearby Georgia Tech, many of whom have partnered with
MedShare staff on research and design for handling a supply of stainless
steel surgical instruments.
"This was a particularly amazing group as they worked beyond
graduation to finish the project," Hegedus says. "Stainless
steel instruments are tremendously valuable to clinics in developing
countries but so cheap to make that we treat them as disposable items
here in the U.S."
Other students performed an analysis of MedShare's sorting
process, looking at the aging process of the inventory through random
sampling. They also examined sorting barrels and made recommendations
for that process, most of which were implemented. The warehouse layout
was also examined, leading to a rearrangement of the inventory where
fast-moving items are placed closer to the loading dock.
COPYRIGHT 2008 Institute of Industrial Engineers,
Inc. (IIE) Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.