Servicing HELOCs in a challenging
environment.
by FitzGerald, George
Mortgage defaults and foreclosures are on the rise nationwide,
while property values continue to slide in key geographical areas. As a
result, the uncertainty in the mortgage market continues, and there is
little consensus about when the market will finally hit bottom. Many
fear that home-equity line of credit (HELOC) defaults will be the next
shoe to drop, with significantly increased default volumes ahead.
In such a tumultuous environment, it is more important than ever
for lenders to service home-equity lines on a mortgage servicing
platform, rather than the consumer lending platforms that have
traditionally been used. When all else is stripped away, these products
are real estate-secured loans, a designation that carries very complex
demands when it comes to delinquency, default and foreclosure.
Additionally, reducing a servicer's exposure to risk requires
mortgage-specific data and analysis.
Consumer lending platforms are simply not designed for the rigors
of mortgage loan servicing. They lack the functionality that allows
access to mortgage-specific data, enables sophisticated analysis and
tracks mortgage-specific information such as lien position, property
values, escrows and more. With a heightened level of default potential
across the board, lenders and servicers need the robust capabilities of
mortgage servicing platforms to effectively manage the risks inherent in
their HELOC portfolios.
A new reality
In recent years, lenders experienced explosive growth in
home-equity lending, in terms of both volume and values. However, as
default increase and property values fall, many home-equity loans and
lines are either in default or at risk. To further complicate matters,
increased regulation of home-equity products is coming and can be
expected to create additional challenges for servicers.
At a time when it is more important than ever to employ aggressive
risk-management strategies, procedures and resources, servicers simply
can't afford to utilize less-than-optimal technology. In fact,
given the state of today's market, lenders holding second-lien
home-equity loans may have as much risk exposure as first-position
mortgage holders.
Here's why.
When facing financial trouble, borrowers with both a first mortgage
and a home-equity line of credit will do whatever they can to continue
paying the note on the first mortgage, even to the point of using the
line of credit to keep their mortgage current. This means that the level
of indebtedness on the home-equity line is increasing along with the
risk of default, though servicers may not realize it for some time.
Fortunately, servicers can deploy a comprehensive, end-to-end
servicing solution that handles all real estate-secured loan products.
By migrating their HELOC portfolios to a mortgage servicing platform
with embedded HELOC functionality, risk can be better managed and
ultimately reduced.
The right tools for the right job
Tracking the lien position of a HELOC is critically important for
lenders and servicers. When HELOCs are in a first-lien position, there
is certainly increased risk associated with escrow accounts and the
payment of taxes and insurance in addition to the default risk.
Servicers with HELOCs in their portfolios must be able to carefully
track these and other collateral issues.
Unfortunately most consumer lending platforms lack this most basic
functionality, though it is necessary for the effective servicing of
HELOCs and other real estate-backed loans. Unlike mortgage servicing
platforms, consumer platforms were not designed to track escrow payments
or default risk, keeping servicers in the dark about information that is
critical to their risk position.
Even if the HELOC is in second-lien position, servicers still need
to monitor the first mortgage to ensure that the note is being paid and
that tax and insurance payments are current as well. Traditionally,
HELOC servicers have relied upon the first-mortgage holder to make sure
insurance and tax disbursements are being made on time. However, given
the volatility of the current market and the second-lien holder's
increased exposure to risk, the heightened awareness afforded by a
mortgage servicing platform makes much more sense.
Mortgage servicing platforms also give servicers the added ability
to track HELOCs against fluctuating property values. Servicers can
directly order broker price opinions (BPOs) or appraisals for a
determination of value on the collateral backing the HELOCs in their
portfolio. With property values decreasing in many key markets, it is
imperative that servicers proactlvely adjust available lines of
credit--based not just on delinquency, but also on current property
values. However, this risk-management strategy is not readily supported
by today's consumer lending platforms.
Of course, if HELOCs ultimately move from delinquency into default,
servicers must be able to track these loans according to
default-specific requirements. The lack of this functionality is perhaps
the most critical flaw in using consumer lending systems to service
HELOCs. As HELOCs move into default, there are a multitude of federal
and state-specific processes--even county-specific in some cases--that
must be followed.
Facilitating intelligent loan modification
Another inherent capability of mortgage servicing platforms that is
not offered on consumer lending systems is functionality that enables
the institution to modify loans and institute loss-mitigation efforts,
such as establishing payments plans. Consumer lending systems, on the
other hand, may only support the ability to freeze credit lines when
borrowers become delinquent beyond a certain point.
Alternatively, prior to freezing the line, mortgage servicing
platforms make it easy to adjust the available line of credit based upon
property values or delinquency and begin loss-mitigation efforts. Once a
line has been frozen, collecting the money that is already owed can
certainly be problematic. That's where a mortgage servicing
platform's ability to accommodate payment plans or forbearance
agreements, as well as modified interest rates or loan terms, is
particularly helpful.
Some mortgage servicing platforms also include advanced analytics
to help servicers make better-informed modification decisions. Analyzing
borrower information against market data can deliver insight into
prepayment, modification and default propensities to determine whether
it makes sense to modify the terms of the loan.
The mortgage servicing platform effectively allows servicers to
produce a "re-underwriting" decision for the modification of a
HELOC product. Mortgage servicing systems are typically equipped with
the ability to access borrower financials, compare those against
borrower debt and determine what level of surplus or shortage the
consumer will have under proposed new terms. Without that knowledge,
loan modifications may only prolong the timing of an inevitable
foreclosure and increase its associated costs.
It just makes sense
While it may once have made some sense--back when times were good,
volumes were high and risk seemed low--to service a fluid credit product
such as a HELOC on a consumer lending platform. However, those days are
long gone. Today, given continued deterioration of the mortgage market
in general and HELOCs in particular, servicers need the functionality
available with a mortgage servicing platform.
The vast majority of servicers already have these systems in place;
it's just a matter of expanding their use to include HELOCs. Once
the shift has been made, servicers will find their HELOC operations
benefit tremendously.
From tracking defaults and escrows; monitoring tax and insurance
payments, and property values; to informing and enabling intelligent
loan modifications based on advanced analytical scoring, a mortgage
servicing platform delivers benefits and essential functionality.
Whether HELOCs are in a first- or second-lien position, HELOC
lenders have much greater exposure to risk today--risk that requires
mortgage-specific tools to properly mitigate. In an environment of
rising defaults, decreasing property values and overall economic
uncertainty, there is no time like the present to move the servicing of
HELOC portfolios to a mortgage servicing platform.
George FitzGerald is senior vice president, business strategy, for
Lender Processing Services (LPS). Jacksonville, Florida. He can be
reached at george.fitzgerald@\psvcs.com.
COPYRIGHT 2008 Mortgage Bankers Association of
America Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.