Worldwide, power grids are more fragile than ever. In many areas,
unexpected outages happen often enough that they are taken for granted,
and whole industries have sprung up to assure continuous power in
emergencies. It's not an enviable position: power as well as other
utilities such as gas and water, responsible to entire populations, must
remain operational.
Many such utilities utilize hydro and gas-powered turbines,
composed of hundreds of small parts. Often, the reliability of those
small parts can mean the difference between operational and
non-operational. So that these parts remain reliable, utility companies
plan periodic turbine shutdowns so that they can be disassembled and
inspected, and parts can either be thoroughly cleaned or, where needed,
replaced. Many utility companies are turning to Omegasonics ultrasonic
tanks to get those parts quickly and thoroughly cleaned.
Traditionally, parts cleaning has been laborious and costly.
"The last time we performed an outage on one of our gas turbines,
we rented a commercial parts cleaning agitation type machine," said
Kim Townsend, maintenance foreman for Farmington Electric, provider of
electrical power to Farmington, New Mexico and the surrounding county of
San Juan. "We would wash the parts for 12 to 14 hours, then take
them out, and then have to hand-clean them. I actually had 4 guys tied
up for probably a week of 8-hour days, with lots of little brushes,
sitting around this table and scrubbing and scrubbing and
scrubbing." The reason for the extra hand- cleaning was that the
rental machine had not done the job. The turbine contains a thousand
bolts and several hundred turbine blades, so it was a very involved
process.
Townsend points out that a cause of cleaning ineffectiveness is
weak solvents. "Going back a ways, there were solutions that worked
a little better, but they were extremely caustic," he said.
"You definitely wanted to wear gloves. Over time, the cleaning
agents that you're allowed to use have gotten progressively weaker
because of the disposal issues with them. The last solution we used
essentially didn't work at all."
Jerry Pulver, plant manager for a Minnesota Methane power plant
located in Southern California, has had similar problems. "We had a
hard time cleaning our Solar turbine fuel nozzles," he said. The
unit has 12 fuel nozzles, and each nozzle costs approximately $8,000, so
proper cleaning and maintenance is vital. "We were soaking them in
a heated solvent for a 24 to 48-hour period, and even then they
weren't really that clean. They would still plug up and give us a
poor flame pattern."
Such problems can mean poor turbine performance. "We would get
a lot of false starts when we tried starting the turbine-the unit
wouldn't start up," Pulver said. Inspection finally revealed
the reason. "We did a borescope down the fuel flow passages in
several of the fuel nozzles and saw that our method wasn't cleaning
that well. There was still a bunch of debris in there, and when you
started up the turbine, the debris would come off and block the inside
of the nozzle."
The only solution was to pull the nozzles out and clean them
again-and in some cases resort to desperate solutions such as knocking
the nozzles against wooden platforms in an effort to loosen the debris.
"It was quite a pain," Pulver said.
Of course, such performance could certainly affect utility
customers as well.
Fortunately, both Townsend and Pulver have discovered a solution to
their parts cleaning problems in the form of Omegasonics ultrasonic
cleaning tanks. The tanks utilize specialized environmentally- friendly
but effective cleaning solutions, heat, water, and ultrasonic sound
waves for cleaning. Users have not only found the method to be more
cost-effective in terms of labor and time, they've also found it to
do a more effective job of cleaning, due to cavitations within the
liquid reaching areas unable to be cleaned by human hands or other
devices.
Kim Townsend has found the tank to be a considerable blessing.
"Using this method, we were able to get all of the parts cleaned up
in a matter of 4 days, and I only devoted 1 guy to it," he said.
"This was instead of 4 men working a week of 8-hour days." He
also reports that the result was considerably better than with the older
method. "The parts were actually much cleaner coming out of the
ultrasonic cleaner than they were even after we had hand-cleaned
them."
Townsend said the ultrasonic cleaning tank was a very
cost-effective investment, and will have paid for itself within 2
planned outages without question.
Omegasonics personnel went to Minnesota Methane and performed a
demo to get the correct soap, temperature, and cleaning parameters. The
results speak for themselves.
Jerry Pulver found that instead of the ineffective 24- to 48-hour
soaking he had to give his nozzles, he can now have them thoroughly
clean within a couple hours. "It paid for itself on our first
use," he said. There are also no more operational problems-the
turbine starts right up.
For power and utility companies, reliable provision of service is
the number one priority. Smooth equipment operation is a vital
ingredient for that reliability. Ultrasonic parts cleaning
cost-effectively provides peace-of-mind that the many components that
make up intricate equipment such as turbines will be clean and will
function properly.
For more information call Frank Pedeflous at Omegasonics at
805/583-0875 or visit http://www.omegasonics.com.
COPYRIGHT 2008 Worldwide
Videotex Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.