Report: Australia sliding into
secrecy.
by Swartz, Nikki
According to a major report, there is a growing culture of secrecy
in Australia that is chipping away at press freedom and denying public
access to critical information.
The "Right to Know" report--produced by Irene Moss,
former chair of the NSW Independent Commission against Corruption, and a
coalition of leading Australian media outlets--identified at least 1,000
court suppression orders in force, restricting media reporting or the
release of information to the public.
According to The Australian, the report condemns governments across
Australia for imposing unprecedented levels of secrecy on the flow of
public information. It describes commonwealth laws protecting public
service whistleblowers as "glaringly inadequate" and says
federal shield laws to protect journalists from being prosecuted for
refusing to reveal sources are "a sham."
The report also assesses the impact of all restrictions on the the
free flow of information around the nation, warning that free speech and
media freedom are being whittled away by gradual, sometimes almost
imperceptible changes.
"I believe there are indeed grounds for concern," Moss
said. "I do not see a crisis. Rather, I see a subtle shift, which
means we need to be vigilant."
According to the report, there are at least 500 pieces of
legislation in Australia that restrict the media, and 335 acts of
parliament containing secrecy provisions. It also reveals that
governments sometimes refused to provide documents and other information
to their parliaments so as not to subject themselves to scrutiny.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Moss' report identified Victoria as the state where open
justice is most imperiled. The state's judges currently have 700
suppression orders in force--seven times the number in New South Wales,
for instance.
Australia's federal Opposition had promised to overhaul the
country's freedom of information laws, pass better whistleblower
laws, and improve shield laws for journalists. Attorney-General Philip
Ruddock said the government already has systems in place to protect
whistleblowers and added that it is "more than happy to pursue
recommendations in line with" the report from an independent
research project that is considering the impact of whistleblower laws.
Ruddock also offered to establish a national register for
suppression orders and suggested that the government's current
inquiry into the FOI system would consider costs and delays.
"The Government has attached a great deal of importance to the
FOI Act," he said. "We would consider it appropriate that
issues such as delay and cost be examined as part of the Australian Law
Reform Commission review."
Moss said current FOI laws are not serving the public well.
"Sometimes the FOI provisions, which were intended to help people
get information, are used as an excuse to deny it," Moss said.
John Hartigan, chairman and chief executive of News Limited, told
The Australian: "Australian democracy is not as free, not as open
and not as transparent as it should be. Some of the rights and freedoms
we cherish are threatened. The Moss report shows that the slide into
secrecy and censorship is evident at all levels of government and among
political parties."
COPYRIGHT 2008 Association of Records Managers &
Administrators (ARMA) Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.