Pro-suicide web sites can spell danger for suicidal
patients.
by Wachter, Kerri
WASHINGTON -- Physicians might be surprised by just how easy it is
for their patients to access very detailed information about suicide
methods on the Internet, a study using five Internet search engines
shows.
"A determined suicidal person can easily and quickly find a
way to commit suicide and even find a suicide support group ... if they
go online," Dr. Patricia Recupero of Brown University, Providence,
R.I., said at the annual meeting of the American Psychiatric
Association.
"The time has come in which part of the routine evaluation of
anyone has to include [the questions] 'Do you use the Internet and
what do you use it for?' " said Dr. Recupero, who also is a
lawyer.
The good news is that suicide prevention and crisis information
might be even easier to access. "Conversely, a desperate person who
is open to getting help might easily find support," Dr. Recupero
added.
For the study, Dr. Recupero and her colleagues entered four
suicide-related search terms into five popular Internet search
engines--Google, Yahoo, Ask, Lycos, and Dogpile. The terms included
"suicide," "how to commit suicide," "suicide
methods," and "how to kill yourself."
They included the first 30 hits for each term using each search
engine, along with any sponsored link. "We figured that people
generally look at about 30 [hits] before they get tired and move on to
the next search," Dr. Recupero said.
The Web site hits were coded by three different raters, with
disagreements settled by consensus. Web sites were coded as pro-suicide,
anti-suicide, suicide-neutral, not a suicide site (a Web site featuring
a song about suicide for example), or error (the link did not work). The
Wikipedia entry on suicide was classified as suicide-neutral, for
example.
They identified 373 Web sites. Of these, most were suicide-neutral
(31%), followed by anti-suicide (29%), not suicide Web sites (20%),
pro-suicide (11%), and error (9%). They also looked at whether a Web
site linked to a crisis intervention program and if it included detailed
suicide methods.
In all, almost a third (29%) linked to suicide prevention
resources. However, 14% of the Web sites provided detailed methods or
instructions for suicide. "You can see that it's quite easily
obtained and quite common," Dr. Recupero said.
Most of the pro-and how-to resources were associated in some way
with the Church of Euthanasia, whose Web site offers a lengthy
pro-suicide guide, including detailed instructions. That site also
describes several unusual and highly lethal suicide methods. Another
Internet resource is alt.suicide.holiday, a nonmoderated news group,
which includes an archive of suicide methods.
"The Internet is also a source of help and support. We would
definitely want to encourage our patients to be familiar with
this," Dr. Recupero said. The National Institute of Mental
Health's Web page on suicide prevention is one of the more popular
hits when using the search term "suicide."
Of the 74 Web sites that were coded as not a suicide Web site, 8
linked to Internet pharmacies. The advent of Internet pharmacies has
made suicide even easier. "It's very easy for patients to go
online, answer a few brief questions, and obtain drugs--licit and
perhaps illicit as well," said Dr. Recupero, president and CEO of
Butler Hospital, also in Providence, R.I.
In all, 18 of the 20 searches yielded at least one pro-suicide Web
site. Two searches for suicide methods each yielded 16 pro-suicide hits
out of 30. In four searches, pro-suicide sites ranked as the No. 1 hit.
The researchers also asked patients about Internet use. Most did
not have Internet access. However, of those who did have access and had
gone online looking for suicide information, none had told their
clinicians nor had they been asked by their clinicians about online
suicide information.
"It's really important that we take advantage of the good
things on the Internet ... giving patients the right URLs that lead them
to NIMH- or APA-type Web sites, and [having] a candid discussion with
them about what they're doing online."
Dr. Recupero cautioned that the Internet is always changing and
repeating the study might produce different results. The investigators
conducted the study twice, about a year apart, with the same results.
BY KERRI WACHTER
Senior Writer
COPYRIGHT 2008 International Medical News
Group Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.