Lucky Cheng's, Manhattan's "original drag queen
restaurant," is suing the Zagat Survey for giving it a food rating
of 9 out of a possible 30.
The guide publishes restaurant reviews based almost entirely on
ratings by patrons, with scores reflecting the quality of the food,
decor and service.
In its lawsuit filed in Manhattan Supreme Court, a trial-level
court, the restaurant said Zagat's 2004 edition, printed last
October, did not reflect improvements since new owners took over in
April 2002.
"God knows 'you don't go for the food',"
says Zagat's entry on Lucky Cheng's; "rather you go to
'gawk' at the 'hilarious,' 'cross
dressing' staff. Well-wishers suggest they 'freshen up the
menu - and their makeup.' "
The restaurant claimed the reviews "falsely state the quality
of food and beverage, service, wait staff, sanitation and cleanliness
are substandard and unworthy of patronage."
It seeks $10 million for libel and negligence, an estimated $30,000
a week in lost income since the review's publication, reimbursement
of $250,000 in advertising costs and an injunction against more copies
being printed.
The establishment's own website makes scant mention of
cuisine, which it describes as "Asian fusion and Polynesian."
"For a special night out in New York, whether to shock your
'wild' friends from Des Moines, or to host a birthday party, a
bachelorette party, even an office party, try Lucky Cheng's, the
original drag queen restaurant," the website says, going on to
extol the quality of the entertainment and cocktails.
Alexa Rudin, director of communications for the Zagat Survey, said
the organization is confident of its review and stands by it. "This
is not one person's opinion," she said. "This is the
collective opinions of the contributors."
COPYRIGHT 2004 JR Publishing,
Inc. Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2004, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.