All about Eve's epic women.
by Sweeney, Kathleen
Afterimage • July-August, 2007 • The Rape of the Sabine Women by Eve
Sussman
THE RAPE OF THE SABINE WOMEN
BY EVE SUSSMAN AND THE RUFUS CORPORATION
80 MINUTES, 2006
With a title like The Rape of the Sabine Women, the viewer
anticipates a nasty ending. In the case of Eve Sussman's recent
filmic effort, a reference to Jacques-Louis David's painting, The
Intervention of the Sabine Women, the camera eye meanders through
several visual skeins suggesting subterranean male and female power
struggles before delivering an operatic, dust-filled climax that is more
Pina Bausch than down-and-dirty ravishment.
Sussman, who served up frisson at the 2004 Whitney Biennial with
her video 89 Seconds of Alcazar (2004), based on Diego Velasquez's
1656 royal family portrait Las Meninas, is obviously interested in
making electronic connections between epic narrative paintings and
potentially epic video art. The Intervention of the Sabine Women,
completed in 1799 after the French Revolution, brought David to the
attention of Napoleon Bonaparte who commissioned him to paint heroic
large-scale portraits. At over 12 by 17 feet, The Intervention of the
Sabine Women hangs in the Louvre Museum in Paris like a small movie
screen.
As demonstrated by the "Moving Pictures: American Art and
Early Film, 1880-1910" exhibition at New York University's
Grey Art Gallery in 2006, the links between filmic art and paintings
have been in place since the invention of photography. In this show,
framed works in oil by Winslow Homer, Frederic Remington, and John
Singer Sargent alternated with turn-of-the-century film clips by
Eadweard Muybridge, Thomas Edison, and the Lumiere Brothers, shown
digitally on flat-screen televisions. That each of the early clips is
only minutes long helped to underscore the thematic and stylistic
connections between one era's media and the next.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
At a running time of 80 minutes, Sussman's recent epic video
travels through a layered encyclopedia of art historical and cultural
references, not all of which can possibly be decoded in one sitting. My
first experience of 89 Seconds of Alcazar occurred at the unveiling of
the new Museum of Modern Art in New York in November 2004, where the
intriguing, dream-like painting-come-to-life could be seen in multiple
doses by roving through the gallery. Despite the visual allure of The
Rape of the Sabine Women, being held captive for an 80-minute theatrical
screening of interweaving, sculptural images of men and women in various
locations including the Pergamon Museum on Greece's Hydra Island,
Berlin's S-Bahn and Tempelhof Airport, Athens's Agora meat
market and Herodion Theatre, and a modern house overlooking the Aegean
Sea proved much more challenging. While well-schooled in viewing
experimental, "difficult" films by the likes of Chantal
Ackerman, Kenneth Anger, Maya Deren, Chris Marker, Alain Robbe-Grillet,
and others, I found myself in continental drift while watching
Sussman's "video-musical," waiting for a climax that
finally comes in the outdoor ancient Greek theatre scene, just a few
minutes before the end.
Despite her reference to David's hyper-charged, theatrical
painting, which is its own kind of color-based movie, and its
Romulus-founding-Rome subtextual thread, Sussman's The Rape of the
Sabine Women wanders listlessly through parties of well-groomed men and
women holding cocktails and cigarettes, without making contact. Perhaps
this is her point; it is Sussman's interpretation of a seething,
almost bored-to-the-point-of-aggression undercurrent in male/female
relationships. Arranged ostensibly as a five-part opera with an original
score by Jonathan Bepler that includes a "coughing choir,"
sounds of clanging butcher knives, and a bouzouki ensemble, the video
begins in a gallery of classic Greek statues. From there, the languid
movement proceeds to an Alfred Hitchcock deja vu in disconnected
reflections of men and women in the highly modern glass panels of
Tempelhof Airport. Conceived by Sussman and the collaborative Rufus
Corporation as a "process piece" resulting in 140 hours of
video footage and 6,000 digital stills, the five operatic parts are not
clearly delineated as such. Referential fragments repeat and return,
sometimes in once-removed versions as pixilated clips shot from
television screens. While it is tempting to let the camera rip in this
way, the value of overshooting must be questioned, particularly when the
hermetic end result is still rather long, even for the art-initiated.
Seeing this film looped in the context of a museum or gallery or
public outdoor projection/party event would have been preferable, where
the most intriguing visuals could be absorbed through repeat glances,
reentries, and access to various angles of view. The nonnarrative
quality of Sussman's work deserves appreciation in a nonnarrative
context. Undoubtedly, given her exhibition record, this work will find
its way into a museum collection as an installation.
Sitting in the movie theatre in linear time, the viewer waits for a
payoff of narrative meaning, even if it is a dreaded one suggested by
the title. That said, the film's operatic conclusion, shot in the
ancient open air Herodion Theatre with choreography by Claudia de Serpa
Soares, possesses moments of full Technicolor vividness in
1960s-nostalgic crowd patterns combined with smoky references to battle
scenes by David, Goya, and even Steven Spielberg.
KATHLEEN SWEENEY is a media artist and adjunct professor at
Marymount Manhattan College and the New School in New York City. Her
book, Maiden USA: Girl Icons Come of Age is forthcoming from Peter Lang
Publishing.
COPYRIGHT 2007 Visual Studies
Workshop Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.