Just a year ago, the rationale behind moving tech support to the
Web was largelya matter of money: By delivering "self-service"
on the Web, software companies could save buckets of the cash they had
been spending on phone support. Today, the return on investment from Web
support is still compelling (a good online knowledgebase typically
resolves half or more of all support queries). But lately a new value
equation has emerged. More than ever, support sites have become a way to
sustain deeper interactive relationships with customers.
And it's easy to see why. Support sites are inherently
"sticky": They attract hard-core information-seekers, usually
from a company's own customer base, who come for solutions, free
software downloads, tips and tricks. Unlike e-commerce sites, which
flash relentless Buy Now buttons and banner ads in the customer's
face, support sites are helpful and non-commercial. In a world where
customer service seems more grudging than ever, good online support can
inspire remarkably intense feelings of loyalty.
Of course, inspiring loyalty is brand-new goal for most support
site designers. The first generation of Web support sites were little
more than repositories for huge collections of documents and files, and
the primary design challenge was simply to keep users from getting
lost. Now it turns out that the navigation challenge was only a
starting point. Already dozens of major companies have begun building
second-generation support sites with a focus on customer
interaction--everything from advanced personalization technologies,
virtual communities, and better e-mail management to subtle usability
enhancements and more customer-centric language.
Typically, rebuilding a support site in this way is a painfully
expensive undertaking. But the payoff (in the words of Mike Nikzad,
Iomega's director of Web support) is something few companies ever
really had: "a loyal, profitable relationship with our
customers--an ongoing virtual dialogue in which customers speak to us in
the language of audit trails, clickstream data, server logs, and
e-mail."
To be sure, some developers see little value in deeper customer
relationships, and others see interactivity largely as a marketing or
technology problem. But there are a growing number of companies that
are thinking creatively about interactive support relationships on the
Web. Ten of these companies were recently honored by the Association of
Support Professionals and Soft-letter as part of our annual Year's
Best Web Support Sites awards competition (above). These ten sites were
picked for their overall excellence, but they are especially
interesting for their approaches to personalization and customer
interaction:
HOW TO LISTEN TO CUSTOMERS
Not surprisingly, many companies (like people) are poor listeners,
and their notion of Web interaction is a one-way monolog. But there are
others who take listening seriously and use customer feedback--from
e-mail, virtual meetings, surveys, statistical tracking, and other
sources--to fine-tune online products and services:
* Iomega: Surveys and Click-Stream Analysis: When Iomega moved
into mass market channels with its Zip drive, says Mike Nikzad, the
company quickly realized that it didn't really understand its
consumer and SoHo customers. Worse, a survey of 7,000 visitors to the
Iomega support site showed that customers were equally in the dark.
Users thought Iomega's support documents were too technical and
poorly organized, "nav-bar labels and links that meant something to
us only baffled customers," and a new state-of-the-art search
engine on the site was being ignored because it didn't deliver
appropriate answers.
* As a result of this feedback, the Iomega site designers knew
they had to pay special attention to usability issues and the
"language customers use" in their site makeover, says Nikzad.
Iomega also added traffic monitoring software that "gave us
in-depth statistics on customer navigation paths, most popular
documents, and solution-delivery rates." In addition, Iomega began
watching search engine server logs closely to see what words and phrases
customers used to find information--and how often searches were
successful. "In our case, close attention paid huge dividends. By
continuously seeding the search engine with words and phrases most
commonly used by customers, 'no solution found' results
plummeted by 55%."
* Cisco Systems: Community Building: Cisco Systems already
resolves 80% of its technical support issues online, but Cisco Web
project manager Shelley Goodwin says the company is still working on
ways to help users and customers "take a more active role in the
design, customization, and development of integrated support
tools." A key part of that strategy, she adds, is a variety of
community building efforts. Cisco has set up advisory boards to
"establish personal working relationships with customers,"
conducts regular online usability tests, and demonstrates new site
features at major Cisco events to get customer feedback.
* In addition, she says, the company has begun publishing an
Internet Technical Support Newsletter that "serves as a powerful
and focused communication channel from Cisco back to the user
community." The newsletter reports on new online tools and upcoming
usability research, along with "comments and concerns" from
users.
* The community approach is especially valuable, Goodwin notes,
because Cisco's community members tend to offer
"holistic" views of how the site performs, rather than
piecemeal evaluations of individual tools. "Merely dropping
applications one-by-one on a support site doesn't utilize the power
of the Internet," she says.
HOW TO CREATE "MY" SUPPORT SITE
The Web usually gives customers access to the same knowledgebase
documents that technicians read over the phone, but Web knowledgebases
also contain a vast amount of irrelevant material that a live technician
would otherwise filter out. The challenge of "mass
customization" is to carve out just the information that the
customer wants to see:
* Sybase: Personalized Pages: "We had massive amounts of
information at our support site--technical documents, FAQs, white
papers, software downloads, solved cases, case management tools--you
name it, we had it," says Sybase services marketing manager Beth
Swilling. "And we had it for hundreds of software products and
versions on multiple platforms and operating systems."
* The solution: Let users create personalized profiles that
reflect product ownership, areas of interest (such as Y2K issues or
database administration), operating systems, and other items. Whenever
users log in, a database engine uses this profile information
dynamically to assemble a personalized Sybase support site for each
user. The profile is also used to send out customized e- mail alerts
about new tech notes and other user-specific information. (Collecting
information for e-mail alerts is a delicate issue because of privacy
concerns, Swilling notes. "It's important that your customers
trust you and are encouraged to enhance their profile without the threat
of being spammed or phoned by telemarketers.") So far, she says,
38% of Sybase users have provided profile information, and the number is
growing.
* Microsoft: Customer Segmentation: As part of a new
company-wide segmentation strategy, Microsoft's Product Support
Services (PSS) division recently dropped what Steve Blair calls "a
one-size-fits-all site" model. Instead, Microsoft now offers 16
different support URLs for such groups as resellers and consultants,
home and small business users, OEMs, technical professionals, and
developers.
* This new segmentation approach, says Blair, lets PSS Web site
developers "give specific customer segments the information they
need, in a format and a language they can understand." For example,
Microsoft's site for third-party developers emphasizes early access
to new technologies, live chats, and "Critical Problem
Alerts," while a separate site for resellers and consultants
provides a richer selection of diagnostic tools and is optimized for
fast (two hour) turnaround on escalated problems.
* Intuit: Extending the Desktop: How does a company create
online interactivity for customers who are reluctant to visit the Web in
the first place? This was one of the challenges Intuit faced with tax
professionals, one of its most valuable customer segments. "Since
we know people don't always have time to use the Web," says
senior project manager Donna Harring, "we added features to the
software that automatically bring important information from the Web to
their desktop."
* For example, says Harring, Intuit's professional products
have been redesigned to automatically check the Web and download updates
and patches, along with technical documents that become part of the
user's own desktop Help files. In addition, the ProSeries Web site
"provides users with links to State and Federal tax resources,
recent tax news, and accounting associations." The goal, Harring
adds, is to gradually expose users to a rich world of Web resources and
"fulfill a need that can't be satisfied through traditional
support outlets."
HOW TO START A CONVERSATION
Usually, first-generation Web sites were heavily document-centric,
but many site managers are now looking for ways to encourage more
personal conversations, especially through online forums and bulletin
boards:
* Intel: Moderated Forums: Intel has one of the Web's
largest collections of product-specific discussion forums--40 public
groups plus another 20 private forums. These forums create
mini-communities of users who ask and answer questions for each other,
often without much input from Intel itself. However, one reason these
forums are successful, says Internet technology manager Ellen Recko, is
that Intel appoints moderators for each group. Intel moderators make
sure questions get answered in a reasonable amount of time (Intel
intervenes after 48 hours), and they occasionally correct peer-to-peer
answers that are incorrect.
* Recko also notes that Intel now places links from each forum to
"top technical issues" documents elsewhere on its support
site. These links help eliminate repetitious postings that make a
forum's content less interesting to advanced participants; on some
forums, she says, the links have reduced the volume of postings by
50%-75%.
* Symantec: Live Chat: What about users who insist on dealing
with a live support technician? Symantec has been experimenting with a
fee-based service that combines live, real-time support with Web-based
document delivery. According to senior supervisor of online services
Steve Cheeseman, "this is the first (and only) fee-based service in
the history of Symantec's online support, and it is one we are
strongly committed to improving as technology continues to evolve."
* In its current form, the top half of the customer's
browser screen provides a chat window for back-and-forth dialog, and the
bottom half displays documents that the support rep "pushes"
to the customer. At the end of the session, Symantec e-mails the
customer a transcript of the session. "Those who use the service
find great value in it," says Cheeseman.
HOW TO MAKE CUSTOMERS FEEL COMFORTABLE
In the end, people who visit Web sites are still interacting with
(or through) a machine. But some machine interactions feel hostile and
unforgiving, while others create an illusion of intimacy and
friendliness. Some of the most inspired personalization efforts
we've seen simply enhance the user's comfort level, usually
with a minimum of technology:
* CambridgeSoft: Rapid Response: CambridgeSoft, a $7.5-million
developer of software for chemists, is a classic example of a niche
developer whose Web site is like a private club where users can feel at
home. Since the company's customers are chiefly academics and
scientists, the site has a deliberate no- frills quality; its contents
are mostly functional collections of documents and tools, full of charts
and tables and equations.
* But small companies often have problems keeping their content
up to date, which sends the same message as a boarded-up storefront: No
one is here, and don't expect much interaction. For that reason,
CambridgeSoft tech support manager Rich Talbot decided that his most
urgent priority was simply to make the site more responsive, faster on
the draw with the latest word on CambridgeSoft products. And that meant
eliminating production bottlenecks for HTML document authoring and
editing. Instead, Talbot created a simple form-based document management
system with Cold Fusion query forms and Microsoft Access data tables.
The result: Web visitors can learn about new tech notes and updates
almost as fast as CambridgeSoft's own phone support reps.
* Dell Computer: "Ask Dudley": When Dell Computer
polled its customers about support, 77% said their first choice would be
to talk with a live technician. Once users learn to use knowledgebases
and online tools, that preference often changes--but many of Dell's
customers never take the first step toward using the Web for support.
And because Dell relies heavily on the Web for direct sales as well as
support, Web-phobia is a problem that can affect the company's
long-term customer retention rate.
* Dell's answer is to put a friendly human face on its Web
support by creating a top-level option called "Just Ask
Dudley." Dudley is a cartoon character who is integrated with a
natural language query tool. Dudley can answer a broad range of simple
questions, and he even encourages users to "peek" at questions
other Dell customers are currently asking (an effective way to show
neophytes that people just like themselves are using the Dudley
interface).
* Macromedia: Anticipated Answers: Just as a good tool fits
comfortably in the hand, a good support site should provide answers that
feel pre-selected for an individual user. "Talking to an agent on
the phone allows the customer to customize a query and to receive very
specific details in return," says Macromedia Web support systems
manager Craig Goodman. "Our support site gives customers the same
specific information by anticipating their needs."
* Goodman says the Macromedia site has been carefully structured
to deliver "anticipated" answers by putting "the most
frequently asked questions at the top of each product support home page
and assigning others to be found by search only." In addition,
navigation paths are kept as short as possible; as a rule, says Goodman,
users almost never have to click more than three times to get from the
Macromedia home page to a document that answers their question.
Related Article: The Ten Best Web Support Sites of 1999
CambridgeSoft Corp. www.camsoft.com/support
Cisco Systems www.cisco.com
Dell Computer Corp. support.dell.com
Intel Corp. support.intel.com
Intuit www.proseries.com www.intuit.com/support
Iomega Corp. www.iomega.com/support
Macromedia www.macromedia.com
Microsoft Corp. www.microsoft.com/directaccess msdn.microsoft.com
Sybase mysupport.sybase.com
Symantec Corp. www.symantec.com/techsupp
The Year's Ten Best Web Support Sites is an annual awards
competition conducted by The Association of Support Professionals (ASP)
and Soft[yen]letter. A panel of judges has selected these sites based
on site performance, usability, graphical appearance, appropriateness
to the customer base, use of metrics, and challenges that the
developers overcame. For additional information on the awards, see
www.asponline.com/awards.html.
COPYRIGHT 1999 Soft-letter Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 1999, Gale Group. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.