Defining Moment

A new franchise definition?
Magazine Contributor
2 min read

This story appears in the May 1998 issue of Entrepreneur. Subscribe »

A recent decision by a California Court of Appeal has many companies shaking their fists and shaking in their boots. Choosing to uphold a lower-court decision, the Court of Appeal found that independent sales agents for Dallas-based Safeguard Business Systems Inc. are protected under the California Franchise Investment Law.

In 1992, 10 distributors brought a class-action suit with 17 claims against office products manufacturer Safeguard. The court tried only one issue: whether the distributor/Safeguard business relationship constituted a franchise agreement. A California judge ruled for the plaintiffs, granting each of them a $6,000 settlement. Safeguard then took the case to the Court of Appeal, but it upheld the prior decision--and Safeguard filed a new petition with the California Supreme Court in March.

According to Safeguard, if this case stands as it is, it could set a precedent in jurisdictions nationwide, opening up businesses with distribution forces or independent sales agents to retroactive criminal penalties, civil suits and recision suits. David J. Kaufmann, a senior partner with New York City law firm Kaufmann, Feiner, Yamin, Gildin & Robbins LLP, says, "This type of relationship, an independent contractor sales force, is common but has never before been held to constitute a franchise relationship. The California court pushed the envelope on this further than anyone had ever thought possible."

The plaintiffs, however, maintain that Safeguard operated as a franchisor without registering as such and that the decision protects distributors and franchisees. "There is nothing startling about this decision," says Bruce C. Fishelman, the plaintiffs' attorney and a partner with Los Angeles law firm Stanbury & Fishelman Inc. "I think it has virtually no effect on any business that uses true manufacturer's representatives."

Contact Sources

Kaufmann, Feiner, Yamin, Gildin & Robbins LLP, 777 Third Ave., 24th Fl., New York, NY 10017, (212) 755-3100

The Pizza Maker Inc., (248) 698-1414,

RFC Inc., 1013 Obispo Ave., Coral Gables, FL 33134,

Stanbury & Fishelman Inc., (310) 278-1800, fax: (310) 278-1802.

More from Entrepreneur

Grow Your Business at Entrepreneur LIVE! Join us on Nov. 16 in Brooklyn, NY, to learn from legends like Danica Patrick and Maria Sharapova, pitch our editors, meet with investors, and potentially walk away with funding!
Register here

One-on-one online sessions with our experts can help you start a business, grow your business, build your brand, fundraise and more.
Book Your Session

Whether you are launching or growing a business, we have all the business tools you need to take your business to the next level, in one place.
Enroll Now

Latest on Entrepreneur

My Queue

There are no Videos in your queue.

Click on the Add to next to any video to save to your queue.

There are no Articles in your queue.

Click on the Add to next to any article to save to your queue.

There are no Podcasts in your queue.

Click on the Add to next to any podcast episode to save to your queue.

You're not following any authors.

Click the Follow button on any author page to keep up with the latest content from your favorite authors.