Property Rights
Congress battles over bills to protect inventors.
Two republican congressmen with competing bills on patents are
both claiming small-business support. However, only one of them
would pass a lie detector test with flying colors.
Reps. Dana Rohrabacher (R-CA) and Carlos Moorhead (R-CA) brought
their yearlong slugfest to the House Judiciary Subcommittee on
Courts and Intellectual Property (which Moorhead chairs) on
November 1. The bone of contention? Rohrabacher wants to change
U.S. patent law, which was altered recently in compliance with the
GATT world trade agreement signed by the United States in
1994.
Before GATT, American patents were protected for 17 years from the
time they were granted by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office
(PTO). The GATT agreement says a patent will be protected for a
minimum of 20 years after an application is filed. The United
States set the patent protection floor and ceiling at 20 years from
the time of filing-no more, no less.
Rohrabacher's bill (H.R. 359) would amend that so patents would
have either 17 years from the date of issuance or 20 years from the
date of application, whichever is longer. He points out that the
PTO often drags its feet on patents related to breakthrough
technologies. As a result, under post-GATT law those inventions
will get considerably less than the 17 years of protection they
would have enjoyed before GATT.
"The polypropylene patent, which the Patent Office issued
after 27 years of delay, would have gotten zero protection,"
Rohrabacher said at the hearing, as an aide displayed a poster
board detailing patent delays for key inventions.
Moorhead's bill (H.R. 1733) does not address the term of
patents. Its most controversial provision requires the PTO to
publish a pending patent after 18 months. After that date,
inventors could claim royalties, even if no patent had been issued.
Moorhead also attempted to get the support of inventors by adding a
fourth reason (there are three in current law) why patents can be
extended beyond 20 years: if the PTO unreasonably delays its
examination of a patent. Up to 10 years (the current limit is five
years) could be granted because of any of the four administrative
delays.
At the hearing, Moorhead and Rohrabacher argued that their
respective bills each had the support of small business. Moorhead
had a tougher time proving that, however, since National Small
Business United, the National Association for the Self-Employed and
many inventors' groups back Rohrabacher. Perhaps more
important, last year the White House Conference on Small Business
passed a resolution supporting Rohrabacher's bill.
Backing Moorhead is The Coalition to Save Patent Term Reform. Its
members: the likes of Xerox, 3M, Apple, Rockwell, Polaroid,
Phillips Petroleum and other giants.
Hoping to prove he had some small-business support, Moorhead
brought in William Budinger, chairman and CEO of Rodel Inc. in
Newark, Delaware. However, Budinger's company, which is 26
years old and grew from his invention of a "hickey
picker," a tool that picks blemishes off lithographic presses,
has at least 500 employees at two facilities in Delaware and
Arizona; another
75 are employed at a plant in Japan.
Ed Stead, vice president of Apple Computer, was also there to back
Moorhead. Paul Heckel was not. Heckel owns HyperRacks Inc., a Los
Altos, California, company he formed in 1982. He filed a patent
infringement suit against Apple in 1989, claiming Apple infringed
on his patent for its HyperCard product. After filing its own
noninfringement suit, Apple subsequently paid a sum to Heckel and
obtained a license to produce the product.
Heckel, who formed an organization called Intellectual Property
Creaters in 1994, backs Rohrabacher and says Moorhead's call
for publishing patents after 18 months is "a sucker's
contract."
Budinger admitted publishing a patent after 18 months could prevent
an inventor from keeping the product secret if it doesn't prove
patentable. But he claimed that won't happen under the Moorhead
bill. After 18 months, 75 percent to 90 percent of all U.S. patent
applications are already published overseas, where American and
foreign companies can view them. That's because 45 percent of
those patents are filed by foreign companies and another 30 percent
by multinational corporations.
But what about inventors whose patents aren't filed abroad and
subsequently aren't granted by the PTO? Budinger admitted
18-month publication would cause a problem for these people, but he
claimed the Moorhead bill ameliorates that problem. "For small
inventors who do not file abroad, H.R. 1733 delays publication
until three months after the PTO has taken the first office action
[on the product]. If granting looks unlikely, the applicant has
time to withdraw the application before publication. Thus the
secret is safe."
John Morgan, an aide to Rohrabacher, says there might be room for
compromise if Moorhead agreed to delay publication until three
months after the second PTO action. He explains, "It is
extremely uncommon to win a patent after the first office
action."
In terms of congressional support, Rohrabacher has the bigger
cheering section, with 189 co-sponsors; Moorhead has about 40. But
Moorhead is also chairman of the subcommittee with authority over
patents. So it may not matter that inventors and entrepreneurs
solidly support Rohrabacher.
Heckel worries that Rohrabacher may have to make a compromise
inventors oppose. "He may not want to," Heckel says,
"but he may not have a choice."
Stephen Barlas is a freelance business reporter who writes monthly Washington columns for 15 magazines.
Continue reading this article - and everything on Entrepreneur!
Become a member to get unlimited access and support the voices you want to hear more from. Get full access to Entrepreneur for just $5.
Entrepreneur Editors' Picks
-
These Co-Founders Are Using 'Quiet Confidence' to Flip the Script on Cutthroat Startup Culture and Make Their Mark on a $46 Billion Industry
-
My 7-Year-Old Daughter Started Selling Eggs. Here's What She Taught Me About Running a Startup.
-
Why You Need to Become an Inclusive Leader (and How to Do It)
-
Career Transitions You Can Make in Your 40s and 50s
-
Billionaire Naveen Jain Is an Expert at Disrupting Fields He Has No Experience In. His Secret Sauce for Building Multi-Million Dollar Companies? 'You Have to Come as Naive.'
-
4 Principles to Develop Next-Level Leadership at Your Company
-
This Filipino American Founder Is Disrupting the Beverage Aisle by Introducing New Flavors to the Crowded Bubbly Water Market