Get All Access for $5/mo

This Is Why You Should (Almost) Always Go for It on Fourth Down But Seldom Do Loss aversion makes football coaches and business leaders timid when the data says they should be bold.

By Gene Marks

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Focus on Sport | Getty Images

Back in 2009, the football coach at a little known but prestigious high school in Arkansas had an unorthodox strategy. The coach, Kevin Kelley, always went for it on fourth down. Why? Because it made sense to him - and he couldn't understand why more coaches didn't do the same.

"You can have an extra down if you want it," he told the authors of the great book Scorecasting: The Hidden Influences Behind How Sports Are Played and Games are Won. "(But some coaches just say) no, I'll be nice and just use three."

Turns out Kelley was right. His winning percentage was 82 percent. His team won championships. His players loved the risks he took. The fans ate it up. But Kelley wasn't taking such a big risk. To him, it was crazy not to go for it on fourth down -- and the numbers, according to the book, certainly back him up.

Related: How to Take the Right Risks

The book's authors interviewed David Romer, a Cal-Berkeley economist. His paper, entitled "Do Firms Maximize? Evidence from Pro Football," analyzed 1,068 fourth down situations in more than 700 NFL games. He found that almost 90 percent of the time - 959 times to be exact - the coaches did not go for it on fourth down even though the right call would've been to do that.

How do you know it would've been the right call? You just have to look at the data. In the case of a football game it would be field position lost and the chances that the opposing team would, or did, score. Romer's analysis concluded that inside the opponent's 45-yard line, facing anything less than fourth and eight, teams are better off going for it than punting. He also found the same for when a team is inside the opponent's 33-yard line and it's anything less than fourth and 11. Regardless of field position, Romer concluded, a football team is always "better off" going for it when it's anything less than fourth and five.

So why don't more NFL coaches do this? The Scorecasting authors said it was due to "loss aversion." It's a fear that most of us, as business owners and leaders, also have.

Related: There Is No Success Without Risk

"Time and time again we let the fear of loss overpower rational decision-making and often make ourselves worse off just to avoid a potential loss," they wrote. "This loss aversion means we tend to prefer avoiding losses at the expense of acquiring gains." Because of loss aversion we don't make that key hire, avoid buying that piece of equipment, hold back from investing in a new venture. We're afraid to lose what we have.

Successful coaches like Kelley and even the Patriot's Bill Belichick (who was also cited in the book as a coach that tends to go for it on fourth down more often than not) know the data. In Philly, we Eagles fans see our coach Doug Pederson doing this too. Many credit his "aggressive tactics" for bringing the city its first ever Super Bowl championship last year.

But is this so "aggressive?" Not really. It's just about knowing when to take a risk. Smart leaders who do the analysis, know the data and have the right information at hand aren't afraid to do this. They don't suffer from loss aversion.

Related: Why 'Big Risk, Big Reward' Is a Myth

In football as in business, nothing is guaranteed. You could fail. Your decision may be wrong. You could incur a loss. But why aren't you going for it when the data -- your return on investment analysis, market research, feedback from customers, experience with similar investments, a person's track record, a potential customer's orders -- is telling you that the odds are well in your favor of succeeding?

Gene Marks

Entrepreneur Leadership Network® VIP

President of The Marks Group

Gene Marks is a CPA and owner of The Marks Group PC, a ten-person technology and financial consulting firm located near Philadelphia founded in 1994.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Side Hustle

The Side Hustle He Started in His College Apartment Turned Into a $70,000-a-Month Income Stream — Then Earned Nearly $2 Million Last Year

Kyle Morrand and his college roommates loved playing retro video games — and the pastime would help launch his career.

Marketing

5 SEO Hacks to Help You Rank Fast

Discover the best SEO hacks you can use to rank fast and avoid waiting for months to see results.

Starting a Business

Inside the Exclusive Private Club Devoted to Food, Wine and the Arts

Barrett Wissman breaks down the passions and partnerships behind his latest venture Domus Artium Reserve.

Business News

Elon Musk Threatens to Ban Employees from Using Apple Products, Says Will Lock Devices in 'Cages'

The Tesla founder sounded off on X following Apple's 2024 Worldwide Developer Conference on Monday.

Collaboration

Watch Out for These 5 Consequences of Too Much Collaboration

Beware of the collaboration trap! Too much collaboration causes overload, and well-intentioned efforts to have broad collaboration can backfire.

Science & Technology

Why We Shouldn't Fear AI in Education (and How to Use It Effectively)

Facing resistance to new technologies in the educational process is nothing new, and AI is no exception. Yet, this powerful tool is set to overcome these challenges and revolutionize education, preparing students and professionals for a future of unparalleled efficiency and personalized learning.