Join our Waitlist for Expert Advice!

You Won't Guess Which Pizza Toppings Could Boost Sales the Most Hello, lobster and prosciutto. A new report finds that bold flavor mashups can help pizzerias boost sales.

By Kate Taylor

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Shutterstock
Pizza

What's your pizza order? Plain cheese? Pepperoni? How about lobster, hot Italian sausage and prosciutto with ricotta cheese?

A new study by global marketing company Affinnova sheds light on the toppings that could help pizza chains boost sales. The conclusion: bold flavor combinations will grab customers' attention without cannibalizing sales of more classic toppings.

Affinnova surveyed customers' preferences for dozens of cheeses, sauces, crusts and topping possibilities, producing more than 2.5 billion potential pizza concept combinations. The optimized pies were then tested against in-market specialty pizzas.

The three top-performing pizzas demonstrate that customers are craving some weird flavor mashups. Customers loved the lobster, hot Italian sausage and prosciutto pizza, the BBQ chicken pizza with cilantro and the three-meat pizza with the unexpected trio of sweet Italian sausage, meatballs and buffalo chicken.

Related: Canadian Pizzeria Generates Buzz With $450 Pie

"Marketers invest millions of dollars and months of development creating great tasting food products, but taste really doesn't matter if you can't drive trial purchases," Waleed Al-Atraqchi, CEO of Affinnova, said in a statement. "To drive trial purchases a new product must first create an expectation of a great tasting flavor – or an anticipated taste – with the consumer."

The combination of bold flavors is one way to heighten consumer expectations. For example, when measured individually, customers ranked the ingredients in the lobster, prosciutto and sweet Italian sausage pizza in the middle-of-the-pack. However, the combination of the three piqued consumer interest, with the pizza surging to the top of pack.

Even better for pizzerias, Affinnova reports that intense flavor mashups help boost incremental sales without taking sales away from existing products. The study suggests adding a lobster, prosciutto and spicy Italian sausage pizza to Papa John's menu would deliver a 70 percent incremental boost to the pizzas included in the report.

Zany favors and culinary mashups have been dominating the food landscape in recent months. Taco Bell's Waffle Taco and KFC's Chicken Corsage are blowing up social media. Meanwhile, Boston Pizza made waves with the Pizza Cake and Steveston Pizza set records with its $450 lobster and cod pie. Perhaps it is time for the major pizza chains to notice the trend and start mixing up their toppings.

Related: Like It or Not, 'Pizza Cake' Could Soon Be a Thing

Kate Taylor

Reporter

Kate Taylor is a reporter at Business Insider. She was previously a reporter at Entrepreneur. Get in touch with tips and feedback on Twitter at @Kate_H_Taylor. 

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Business Solutions

Cut Costs, Not Features with This Microsoft Bundle Deal

You get Office, Windows, Project, and Visio for $72.

Business News

You Have One Month Left to Buy a House, According to Barbara Corcoran. Here's Why.

"If you are planning on waiting a year and seeing where interest rates go, you are out of your mind," Corcoran said.

Business Ideas

63 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2024

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2024.

Franchise

The McRib Is Back, But Only at Select McDonald's — Here's Where to Find It

This scarcity is nothing new. In 2022, McDonald's announced a "Farewell Tour" for the McRib, suggesting that it might be the last time customers could get their hands on it.

Data & Recovery

Protect Your Business Data Without Sacrificing Privacy With Koofr Cloud Storage on Sale

Get 1TB of lifetime storage for your business with no recurring fees or data tracking.

Business News

Meta Fires Employee Making $400,000 Per Year Over a $25 Meal Voucher Issue

Other staff members were fired for the same reason, per a new report.