App Developer to Facebook: We Had 'Paper' First
Join us in a city near you at Entrepreneur’s Accelerate Your Business event series kicking off Feb 23. View cities and dates »
If a competitor has its way, Facebook may have some serious rewrites to do on Paper, its much-ballyhooed new reader app.
Georg Petschnigg, co-founder and CEO of FiftyThree -- a mobile design firm that brought to market its own app entitled Paper in 2012 -- says he wants Facebook to stop using his brand name.
But the legal lines are blurry. While FiftyThree’s original trademark claim was filed for “Paper by FiftyThree,” reports TechCrunch, it applied for a “Paper” trademark on Jan. 30 -- the very day that Facebook announced its own venture.
This is most likely because “Paper by FiftyThree” would have been far easier to claim than a term as generic as “Paper,” trademark lawyer Victor Cardona explained.
“An app about stories shouldn’t start with someone else’s story,” Petschnigg wrote on FiftyThree’s blog. “What will Facebook’s story be? Will they be the corporate giant who bullies their developers? Or be agile, recognize a mistake, and fix it?”
FiftyThree’s Paper -- which can be used on iPads to draw and write with a variety of brushes, pencils and mixable color palettes -- was named Apple’s App of the Year in 2012 and is currently utilized by 100 million people, it says.
Complicating matters is FiftyThree’s numerous ties to Facebook, writes Petschnigg: “One of Facebook’s board members is an investor in FiftyThree. We’re a Facebook developer, and Paper supports sharing to Facebook where close to 500,000 original pages have been shared. Connections run deep.”
While Facebook offered an apology for not having contacted FiftyThree sooner, Petschnigg says an apology is not enough. He told TechCrunch that the company is keeping its legal options open. But even with a reported $15 million in funding, it remains to be seen whether FiftyThree would have the resources and weight to take on an opponent as massive as Facebook.