Pages must preserve best features as they
evolve.
by Goudreau, Rosemary
The Masthead • Spring, 2008 • SYMPOSIUM: Saving journalism and the editorial
page
There's no place quite like the editorial page.
What other medium provides such a well-rounded forum for public
discussion?
Talk radio is about outrage, about making the lines light up, not
about helping a community connect through a common gathering spot.
Internet forums offer a quick gut-check, but their culture of anonymity
breeds an ugliness and ignorance that turns many people off. And local
television--well, it left commentary behind decades ago for fear that
half its viewers would turn the channel.
A great editorial page, on the other hand, stands up for its
values, its community, and its citizens. It helps people make sense of
things. As Michael Gartner said in his book, Outrage, Passion &
Uncommon Sense, it gives people a common yardstick for measuring a
community's evolution.
The best call out injustice, hold people accountable, and pat
people on the back. They get passionate about things, laugh at
life's hiccups, and create an experience that makes readers want to
turn there first, like eating dessert before the main course.
Editorial boards are stocked with smart, reflective people who take
the time to look a little closer and think things through. At our
most-recent national convention, Missouri Senator Claire McCaskill
lamented that the only time she expects a deep policy discussion is when
she visits an editorial board.
And for those who question the impact of editorial endorsements,
consider how Senator John Edwards' campaign soared after his 2004
endorsement by The Des Moines Register; or how former Governor Mitt
Romney's popularity fell after the Concord Monitor called him a
phony. If newspaper endorsements didn't matter, why would
presidential candidates find the time to visit those of us in early
primary states?
Yet our profession is in peril. John Oppedahl, former publisher of
the San Francisco Chronicle and The Arizona Republic, told our
membership last year that we had three years to prove our value to
publishers. Otherwise our days are numbered.
Like newsrooms everywhere, editorial boards have seen staffing
erode. In Tampa we've lost two positions. The Chicago SunTimes
recently laid off three. Tough choices lie ahead everywhere.
What keeps me awake at night is the vulnerability editorial boards
face in this digital world. Our readers are loyal, but aging. To remain
relevant, we must increase our appeal and meet the demands of an
ever-changing audience.
Let's be honest. While newsrooms have been awash in change
efforts for decades, editorial boards have been slow to evolve.
Until now.
Consider the opening-day "boot camp" at our October
convention in Kansas City. The topic: video editorials.
At the same convention, we announced a national initiative to
engineer a muscular future for opinion journalism. We are exploring
ideas for online features and new tools of engagement.
Remember, it means something for readers to have a letter published
in the paper. People keep those letters for years--on their
refrigerators or in their scrapbooks. Properly stoked and creatively
developed, this relationship will transcend print on paper.
It discourages me to hear editorialists say they simply hope their
jobs survive until they retire. As a profession, we must grab hold and
make our future together. We owe this debt to the generations behind us,
to our communities, and to our democracy.
The man who won the Tribune's Letter of the Year two years
ago, an airman at Tampa's MacDill Air Force Base, expressed the
public value of the editorial page while accepting his award. He told
the story of going through the drive-thru at Chick-fil-A and having some
anonymous customer inside buy his dinner. He wanted to thank the
community for supporting the troops. So he wrote a letter to the editor.
There's no place like our pages. We are the place to be seen
and heard on issues affecting our community.
We are a public trust that needs to be protected and preserved.
Rosemary Goudreau is the editorial page editor at The Tampa Tribune
in Florida. Email: rgoudreau@tampatrib.com
COPYRIGHT 2008 National Conference of Editorial
Writers Reproduced with permission of the copyright holder. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights
reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
NOTE: All illustrations and photos have been removed from this article.