What the 'Murder Board' Taught Me About Leadership
Feedback comes in many forms, and may not always be constructive.
Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.
I've never been fond of tests. Not to measure how much you "learned" last semester. Certainly not to see how much "potential" you have to succeed. So when other training directors rolled out what they called a "Murder Board," I was skeptical.
My experience with "murder boards" is exclusive to the military, although I've heard of similar concepts in both the private and public sector. Candidates for a new set of responsibilities or job progression receive study material that's been categorized in some manner. For example, you're looking to promote one of your storefront associates to assistant manager. To determine which ones are ready to make the leap, you build a slideshow that describes every part of the business (e.g., operations, inventory, finance). You ask them to study it for a week, then prepare to answer questions, one or two from each category, when they come to work next week. You let them know the session is nothing more than a "datapoint," something to help indicate their proficiency as associates. But in reality, it's a filtering mechanism. If an associate misses a certain number of questions, you'll pass him over for someone else. Or if none meet your standard, you may hire from outside the team. You know the standard and the consequences of not meeting it, and keep both to yourself. This was a moment in our evolution as Air Force nuclear missile operators.
Continue reading this article — and all of our other premium content with Entrepreneur+
For just $5, get access to a ton of exclusive content and resources that will help grow your entrepreneurial mindset. You’ll find:
- Exclusive content from our network of today’s leading CEOs and business strategists
- Receive our flagship Entrepreneur Magazine - free!
- No more ads, and get access to the Entrepreneur+ homepage
- Free E-books written by our staff and other industry thought leaders