For Subscribers

Border Patrol Congress goes to bat for in-state expansion tax incentives.

By Stephen Barlas

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Members of both parties in Congress are trying to reverse anunappealing decision handed down last September by the 6th U.S.Circuit Court of Appeals, whose rulings cover the states ofKentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee. The decision said it wasunconstitutional for Ohio to offer tax incentives to statecompanies to convince them to expand inside the state'sborders.

Sometimes tax incentives, such as Ohio's manufacturingmachinery and equipment tax credit, are used to lure entrepreneursto high-priority economic development zones. Ohio had offered theincentives to DaimlerChrysler AG for expansion of a Jeep plant inToledo, an expansion which has gone forward anyway as the companyappeals the court decision. That growth has meant considerable newbusiness for numerous small Jeep suppliers in Toledo. In itsSeptember decision, the appeals court struck down the tax creditbecause Ohio companies could not get the tax credit if theyexpanded outside the state; the court ruled that the tax credittherefore discriminated against interstate commerce.

Bills have already been introduced in both the Senate and theHouse (S.1066/H.R. 2471) that would legalize the Ohio tax creditand others like it. Reversing the appeals court decision is apressing issue because similar challenges to state tax incentivesare pending in Minnesota, Nebraska and Wisconsin, and a suit isexpected to be filed soon in North Carolina.

"This [new] legislation is carefully crafted to protect themost common and benign forms of tax incentives, but not toauthorize those tax incentives that truly discriminate againstinterstate commerce," says Sen. George Voinovich (R-Ohio), whowas governor of Ohio when the tax credit became law and isco-sponsoring the new bill. "This legislation does notinvalidate any tax incentives. It only authorizes taxincentives."


Stephen Barlas is a freelance business reporter who coversthe Washington beat for 15 magazines.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Side Hustle

After a 12-Year-Old's Side Hustle Made Over $4,000 in 1 Day, He and His Dad Grew the Business to Nearly $50,000 a Month: 'It Takes Commitment'

Madden Forrest and his father, Steven, turned their passion for football into a lucrative business.

Business Ideas

70 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2025

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2025.

Business News

Mattel Signs First-of-Its-Kind Deal With OpenAI to Bring ChatGPT to 'Iconic' Toys

Mattel is also allowing its employees to use ChatGPT Enterprise to help design new products.

Business News

Google, Spotify Down in a Massive Outage Affecting Tens of Thousands. Here's What We Know.

Both Google and Spotify appear to be down for thousands of users.

Business News

Meta Is Reportedly Offering Up to Nine-Figure Pay for Researchers on Its New Superintelligence AI Team

Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg, 41, is overseeing the hiring of staff for the new 50-person team.

Business News

This 'Sweet' Role Is the Highest Paid Position at Walmart After Managers

If you're creative and have a sweet tooth, the coveted (and lucrative) cake decorator position at Walmart may be for you.