⚡ Get All Content for 20% Off ⚡

3 Big Patent Moves That Won't Generate Real Value These missteps will waste your company's time, money and resources.

entrepreneur daily

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Sophisticated companies understand that intellectual property is important and, frequently, can account for 85 percent or more of a company's value. Without patent protection, competitors could (and would) freely copy their innovations. To competitors, such copying is simply good business. To the innovating company, however, unhindered copying can quickly wipe away corporate value.

But not all patents are created equal. Those that fail to block competitor access to a company's innovations can be valueless. On the other hand, patents that protect key technologies can generate sensational value, priming the company for an acquisition, an IPO, or simply success in the market.

Related: Protect Your Most Valuable Business Assets

Several common missteps prevent companies from harnessing the potential value of patents.

1. Putting technology before business.

The innovations that engineers produce are critical to technology companies. But obtaining patents based on what is interesting to a company's engineers, without consideration of its business goals, often results in patents that do not generate company value.

This situation may arise when a company's executives provide the direction, "We need patents" or an investor wants to "check the patent box." Whatever the cause, letting the technology dictate the patent strategy often results in patents that do not:

  • Protect the company's revenue streams
  • Cover key features most likely to be copied by competitors
  • Have broad enough coverage to prevent "design arounds" from competitors

2. Patenting invisible features.

Patents directed to "invisible" features may have little value. These patents are aimed at specific algorithms or technologies buried in the depths of source code, rather than features that end-users directly interact with and perceive.

Related: Have a Brilliant Idea? How to Keep it Safe. (Infographic)

Why does feature visibility matter? Infringement is easier to detect and prove for patents covering visible features. Identifying infringement of "invisible" features, however, can be difficult or impossible, which can render a patent valueless.

Meanwhile, monetary damages and royalties are more readily available for patents covering popular, outward-facing features than those that cover features unknown to customers. As the recent smartphone wars illustrate, patents covering visible features of a user interface may be significantly more valuable than patents directed to behind-the-scenes algorithms for driving the features.

3. Choosing quantity over quality.

Prioritizing the quantity of patents over the quality of patent-blocking positions is usually ineffective, and the cost of such a strategy is often prohibitive. Yet many companies wield a shotgun approach to patents, hoping to have so many that a competitor must infringe at least one.

Smart companies and investors know, however, that a patent is only as good as the strength of the blocking positions it provides. Even one patent that effectively prevents a competitor from practicing a key technology generates immeasurably more value than a mountain of patents covering trivial or easily avoidable features.

A strategy that is laser-focused on locking up features that others will need to compete is both more effective in boosting the bottom line, and less costly, than a scattershot approach to patenting.

Elliot Cook and Darren Jiron

Patent Attorneys at attorneys at Finnegan

Elliot Cook and Darren Jiron are attorneys at global IP law firm Finnegan.

Cook maintains a diverse intellectual property practice, encompassing patent litigation, post-grant patent challenges, patent prosecution, and patent monetization. Through his involvement in 18 U.S. district court cases, Cook has acquired significant experience with various facets of patent litigation.

Jiron focuses on patent litigation and strategic development of patent portfolios. He has represented clients in all phases of patent litigation before numerous U.S. district courts and the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC).

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Side Hustle

The Remote Side Hustle a 43-Year-Old Musician Works on for 1 Hour a Day Earns Nearly $3,000 a Month: 'All From the Comfort of Home'

Sam Ziegler wanted to supplement his income as a professional drummer — then his tech skills and desire to help people came together.

Business News

Costco CFO Reveals Uncertain Fate of $1.50 Hot Dog and Soda Combo

CFO Richard Galanti reveals that the price will stay the same — but only "for a while."

Business News

The Most Unexpectedly Popular Side Hustle of the Decade Has Low Startup Costs and High Markups

A new report shows that vending machines are a popular investment — and the industry is set to grow up to $3 billion by 2031.

Marketing

Ever Wonder Why Certain Websites Rank Higher Than Yours? This SEO Expert Reveals The Secret to Dominating Search Results

It's often the smart use of SEO, now supercharged with AI, particularly in keyword optimization.

Business News

AI Is Impacting Jobs. Here Are the Gigs Affected the Most, According to an Analysis of 5 Million Upwork Postings

The researcher said in the report that freelance jobs were analyzed first because that market will likely see AI's immediate impact.

Leadership

Former Interrogator Shares 5 Behaviors Liars Exhibit and How to Handle Them

Five deceptive behaviors to look for and how to respond to those behaviors when you encounter them.