⚡ Get All Content for 20% Off ⚡

Clicks Are Not the Only Online Marketing Metric and They May Not Even Be the Best For decades the billboard and TV industries have tested markets in a way ecommerce entrepreneurs will find tells them a whole lot more.

By Claude Denton

entrepreneur daily

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Dmitry Ageev | Getty Images

Ever since the world's first banner ad in 1994 asked users to click "right here," clicks have been the default measure of success online.

But clicks, it turns out, are a poor indicator of how successful one's marketing really is. Consider the consumer who may have seen 10 digital ads before purchasing -- by measuring clicks, you can't definitively attribute 100 percent of credit to any one of those individual ads. Because of that, it's difficult to determine which ad to mirror in the future.

Multi-touch attribution -- an alternative to "last click" that awards value to each digital ad a consumer sees -- is an advertiser's dream. But collecting the depth of data to measure every factor affecting a buyer's decision is not possible in reality.

However, lift measurement -- a staple of TV and billboard ad measurement for decades -- is a much better gauge of online ad performance than any click-based attribution. While digital advertising may be a quantum leap over traditional mediums (because marketers can target with precision whom they want to see their campaigns) lift measurements are one case in which TV and billboard advertising had it right.

How lift studies for TV and billboards work.

Whether examining a drug treatment or an ad campaign, the best way to measure success is via a randomized control trial (RCT). When applied to traditional offline advertising, the preferred RCT is a geographic lift measurement, in which one regional area is put in a treatment group and shown TV commercials or billboard ads. Meanwhile, a similar regional area acts as a holdout or control group and isn't shown any advertising.

If sales jump for the treatment group compared to the baseline of the other one, then the campaigns were successful. The amount of the rise in sales, commonly known as lift, tells you if the advertising spend was worth it.

Related: 3 Crucial Metrics to Measure When You Advertise In 2018

For example, imagine if McDonald's ran TV commercials in Cincinnati for its McRib sandwich but didn't run them in Cleveland (assuming customers in those cities show similar purchasing behavior). If McDonald's found that sales were up 20 percent in Cincinnati versus Cleveland, then they can surmise that the commercials prompted that 20 percent increase.

Digital gave birth to flawed attribution approach.

Lift measurements aren't perfect. Other factors could have increased McRib sales in Cincinnati. Maybe an influential radio DJ talked up the McRib during the morning commute. Also, separating by geography means the groups may not be exactly comparable, due to regional differences in personal preferences, culture, weather, etc.

Regardless, lift studies are far more accurate than click-through rates. Clicks don't tell you much about whether an ad drove incremental revenue. So why are marketers so focused on them?

One reason is that search pioneers decided that pay-per-click was the best model for sales. It makes sense: clicks provide solid proof that a user responded to an ad. This model underscored the advantage search advertising had over display advertising in identifying short-term intent. Even better, marketers could analyze the on-site behavior of said users.

Related: 10 Ways Technology Hijacks Your Behavior

In the ideal scenario for this model, a consumer sees an ad for a sweater, clicks on it, and buys the sweater online. While that certainly happens, a consumer can also view the sweater ad, think about it for a week, look at other sweater ads, forget about the sweater altogether, and then visit the site and buy the sweater. Or maybe it was the combination of online ads and a billboard that sent the consumer down the purchase funnel. The picture isn't a clear one for marketers.

TV and billboards have always had one glaring problem: The marketer can't tell who saw the ads. After all, you can't click on a billboard or TV commercial. With digital ads, the advertiser does know (at least on an anonymized basis), which creates an opportunity for much better measurement.

But many advertisers falsely assume that because a consumer clicked on an ad, that ad led to whatever behavior followed. Confusing correlation with causation is what's holding most marketers back from truly understanding the data behind their campaigns and which ones are proving successful. Those who wish to overcome this challenge should take a hard look at their current measurement practices. Then they should begin experimenting with lift tests.

Lift in a digital world.

The advantage of doing lift measurements in the digital realm is that audiences can be truly randomized and used as part of continuous testing and measurement. Analysts need not find a new city to use as a control group for billboards and TV commercials. This is particularly true for some of the largest online retail brands. It's no real headache for L.L. Bean or Adidas to withhold digital ads from 10 perfect of their online audiences.

Taking a continuous approach to lift tests is the key takeaway. It's critical to create these holdouts or control groups more than once every six months, or once a quarter, because the revenue from your holdout group provides your baseline (it represents revenue you'd make without advertising). That baseline will vary over time due to seasonality, competition and changes to your products. Continuous digital lift measurements provide the most accurate baseline. From that you can calculate the true incremental return on your advertising.

Related: How Bots Steal Your Online Advertising Budget

Unfortunately, many marketers are still focused on the wrong metrics, with no ability to show the effectiveness of their campaigns when it comes to the bottom line. But measuring and optimizing your budgets based on lift measurement finally closes this loop. It directly ties the performance of individual campaigns to the revenue they provide. For CMOs, this is the holy grail of measurement insight.

While this approach isn't new, it is hiding in plain sight for digital advertisers. Billboard, print and traditional TV advertising budgets may be in decline, but the tried-and-true method of lift testing to measure ad performance is timeless. So, marketers, look to the past to update your measurement strategy today. Stop prioritizing clicks, and you'll gain tremendous insight into the performance of your campaigns.
Claude Denton

Co-Founder and CTO of Nanigans

Claude Denton is Nanigans’ co-founder and CTO. Prior to Nanigans, he co-founded and served as CTO of CourseAdvisor. Denton holds 16 patents and four applications in communications and video processing architecture. He has BS and MS degrees in electrical engineering and computer science from MIT.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Side Hustle

The Remote Side Hustle a 43-Year-Old Musician Works on for 1 Hour a Day Earns Nearly $3,000 a Month: 'All From the Comfort of Home'

Sam Ziegler wanted to supplement his income as a professional drummer — then his tech skills and desire to help people came together.

Business News

Costco CFO Reveals Uncertain Fate of $1.50 Hot Dog and Soda Combo

CFO Richard Galanti reveals that the price will stay the same — but only "for a while."

Business News

The Most Unexpectedly Popular Side Hustle of the Decade Has Low Startup Costs and High Markups

A new report shows that vending machines are a popular investment — and the industry is set to grow up to $3 billion by 2031.

Marketing

Ever Wonder Why Certain Websites Rank Higher Than Yours? This SEO Expert Reveals The Secret to Dominating Search Results

It's often the smart use of SEO, now supercharged with AI, particularly in keyword optimization.

Business News

AI Is Impacting Jobs. Here Are the Gigs Affected the Most, According to an Analysis of 5 Million Upwork Postings

The researcher said in the report that freelance jobs were analyzed first because that market will likely see AI's immediate impact.

Leadership

Former Interrogator Shares 5 Behaviors Liars Exhibit and How to Handle Them

Five deceptive behaviors to look for and how to respond to those behaviors when you encounter them.