Can We Agree That the Nokia Buy Was a Total Disaster for Microsoft? After write-offs, an impairment charge, and thousands of job cuts, can Microsoft recoup any value from its $7.2 billion Nokia acquisition? Let the debate begin.

By Barb Darrow

This story originally appeared on Fortune Magazine

Given that Microsoft is about to axe another 7,800 employees, take a restructuring charge of $750 million to $850 million related to the layoffs plus a $7.6 billion impairment charge, it's hard to argue that the $7.2 billion acquisition of Nokia's phone business 18 months ago was anything but folly.

The Nokia deal was seen as Steve Ballmer's baby. The former Microsoft CEO was hell-bent on fixing Microsoft's mobile business where it was getting buried by Apple and Android devices. It could even be argued that buying its way into mobile was faster and maybe cheaper than building that business organically.

Forrester Research analyst Frank Gillett is in that camp. "Nokia got Microsoft into the hardware business where no one was betting on Windows Phone, but at a steep price. I think they couldn't afford not to get in that business and the alternative would have been to invent it from scratch which would have taken longer."

One former Microsoft manager, who still works with the company as a partner, said Nokia was a "buddy deal between Ballmer and Stephen Elop," the former Microsoft exec who left to become CEO of Nokia and returned to Microsoft as part of the acquisition. "They should have made a movie, not a deal," he said. (Elop left Microsoft two weeks ago as part of a reorg.)

Ballmer was driven to purchase Nokia by Google- and Apple-envy, which might have been fine if the company had executed well, but it didn't, said David Linthicum, an independent analyst. Last year it was clear that something was awry when the company announced plans to cut 18,000 employees, many from the phone unit.

"Now, Microsoft will likely focus on users that want enhanced management capabilities and security. That's going to be a tough course to follow considering that other phone and mobile OS providers have been working hard to provide management and security capabilities as well. So, what does Microsoft do different? Not much," Linthicum said via email.

Others think that some lemonade may be squeezed out of this lemon yet.

"If Microsoft owns the rights to the hardware and the OS they could redeem themselves in Africa and other emerging markets. Those markets have 4 to 5 billion people that have not been touched by tech. They don't need smart phones. They'll start with super-feature phones. The telcos and other infrastructure providers are going to make a fortune. Microsoft may have a chance to play here too. We shall see how they play their hand," said the former exec.

So, the question is now, as it's been for the past year: Can CEO Satya Nadella, who took the job in February, 2014, execute where his predecessor did not? So far it looks like he is willing and able to make the tough choices he telegraphed last month in an internal memo. And that's probably a good thing for Microsoft.

Wavy Line
Barb Darrow is a writer at Fortune with a focus on technology. She is based in Boston.

Editor's Pick

She's Been Coding Since Age 7 and Presented Her Life-Saving App to Tim Cook Last Year. Now 17, She's on Track to Solve Even Bigger Problems.
Lock
I Helped Grow 4 Unicorns Over 10 Years That Generated $18 Billion in Online Revenues. Here's What I've Learned.
Lock
Want to Break Bad Habits and Supercharge Your Business? Use This Technique.
Lock
Don't Have Any Clients But Need Customer Testimonials? Follow These 3 Tricks To Boost Your Rep.
Why Are Some Wines More Expensive Than Others? A Top Winemaker Gives a Full-Bodied Explanation.

Related Topics

Business News

California Woman Arrested For $60 Million Postal Service Scam

Lijuan "Angela" Chen faces two charges that each carry a maximum sentence of five years in prison.

Growing a Business

Trendspotting 101 — How to Stay Ahead of the Curve in Your Industry

Learn how to spot and capitalize on emerging trends in your industry with these practical tips.

Business News

A Wegmans Employee Allegedly Stole Over $500,000 from the Company

Alicia Torres pleaded guilty to crimes carried out over nine years while working at Wegmans in Webster, New York.

Business News

Hundreds of People Mistakenly Told They Have Cancer in Biotech Software Mishap

The biotechnology company, Grail, said a software issue caused one of its vendors to accidentally send nearly 400 letters mistakenly telling patients they have cancer.

Growing a Business

How to Harness the Power of Data Analytics for Business Growth

To thrive in the competitive landscape, entrepreneurs must understand and leverage the power of data analytics.