Get All Access for $5/mo

The Sleeper Campaign Issue: Net Neutrality It's a battle between carriers and internet companies with important economic implications. And the presidential candidates see it very differently.

By Riva Richmond

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

The Sleeper Campaign Issue Net Neutrality

Editor's Note: This 10-part series looks at issues critical to entrepreneurs this election season. Read installments on the economy, taxes, healthcare, capital and contracting.

You've barely heard about it during the 2012 campaign, but net neutrality is another issue important to businesses where the presidential candidates disagree.

Under net neutrality rules imposed by the Federal Communication Commission, companies that provide wired internet service are required to treat all online content equally, much as phone companies must put through all calls without regard to who is calling. ISPs may not give preferential treatment, or "fast lanes," to their own content or content from parties that will pay more. Nor may they block or impede content that's controversial or competes with their own offerings.

Net neutrality has been championed by Democrats, who say that the rules are needed to safeguard the open lanes that have allowed online commerce to flourish and powered tech entrepreneurship, economic growth and good high-tech jobs.

See Where the Candidates Stand on Small-Business IssuesBut carriers have fought back, arguing they should be able to manage traffic and profit as they see fit from private networks that they built at great expense. They have found friends among Republicans, who decry regulation as a drag on economic growth and want to encourage carriers to invest in expanding broadband service. They also argue there's sufficient competition in broadband to keep carriers from discriminatory activities.

Related: Obama vs. Romney on Government Contracting and Federal Spending

A bit of background: The net neutrality debate was born amid hints that ISPs were gearing up to create a tiered-pricing system and to discriminate against some traffic. An early salvo came in February 2006, when a Verizon executive complained that a booming Google was "enjoying a free lunch" at the expense of carriers like Verizon that spent billions of dollars building the network.

But the key test began in October 2007, when Comcast came under fire for interfering in its customers' use of popular -- albeit bandwidth-hogging and sometimes unsavory -- file-sharing services. The FCC ordered Comcast to stop, citing its "ancillary authority" to regulate ISPs. Comcast sued.

The court ruled against the FCC, saying it overstepped its statutory authority. In response, it established new rules for regulating the internet, which went into effect in November 2011. But its legal grounds were somewhat similar to those of the failed court case, leading many legal experts to question whether the rules will survive a court challenge that's underway.

When it comes to net neutrality, the candidates have strikingly different positions. Here's a look:

Related: The Forgotten Issue? Romney, Obama Stay Mum on Capital

President Barack Obama
Obama has strongly supported net neutrality as grease for an "innovation economy" that can provide high-paying jobs and breakthroughs in health care, education and energy. He advocated it in his first run for the presidency and backed the FCC's rulemaking efforts as president.

"We don't want to create a bunch of gateways that prevent somebody who doesn't have a lot of money but has a good idea from being able to start their next YouTube or their next Google on the internet," President Obama said in a February 2010 interview.

But his commitment could soon be tested. "If the FCC decision gets overturned, there's a difficult choice facing the Obama administration," says Michael A. Livermore, executive director of the Institute for Policy Integrity at the New York University School of Law, a nonpartisan think tank.

The administration could up the ante and seek an explicit mandate to regulate broadband providers as "common carriers," the authority that allows it to regulate telecommunication companies, Livermore says, which would be a brutal fight. Or it could try to negotiate a compromise with industry.

Former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney
Romney opposes net-neutrality rules. Asked at a town hall meeting what role the government should have in regulating the internet, Romney said: "Almost none." And in his economic agenda he says: "We should build upon our strengths, not burden them with bureaucracy, excessive regulation, and intrusive government."

The outcome if Romney becomes president is easier to envision. His FCC would likely let net neutrality die by simply not enforcing the Obama-era rules and drop the lawsuit.

Michael Jude, a senior analyst at Frost & Sullivan, a research and consulting firm, sums it up: "I don't think there would be any appetite in a Republican-controlled FCC to continue to pursue a regulatory framework for the internet."

Related: Where the Candidates Stand on 'Obamacare'

Is net neutrality a concern for your business? Will the issue affect your vote? Leave a comment and let us know.

Riva Richmond is a freelance journalist who has covered technology for more than a decade. She focuses on computer security, privacy, social networking and online business and has written for The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal and other national publications. Previously, Riva was a technology reporter at Dow Jones Newswires and regular contributor to The Journal's "Enterprise" small business column.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Editor's Pick


ChatGPT is Becoming More Human-Like. Here's How The Tool is Getting Smarter at Replicating Your Voice, Brand and Personality.

AI can be instrumental in building your brand and boosting awareness, but the right approach is critical. A custom GPT delivers tailored collateral based on your ethos, personality and unique positioning factors.

Business News

Apple Reportedly Isn't Paying OpenAI to Use ChatGPT in iPhones

The next big iPhone update brings ChatGPT directly to Apple devices.

Business News

Is the AI Industry Consolidating? Hugging Face CEO Says More AI Entrepreneurs Are Looking to Be Acquired

Clément Delangue, the CEO of Hugging Face, a $4.5 billion startup, says he gets at least 10 acquisition requests a week and it's "increased quite a lot."

Business Ideas

63 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2024

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2024.

Business News

Sony Pictures Entertainment Purchases Struggling, Cult-Favorite Movie Theater Chain

Alamo Drafthouse originally emerged from bankruptcy in June 2021.

Business News

You Can Now Apply to Renew Your U.S. Passport Online — But There's a Catch

The U.S. State Department officially launched the beta program this week.