Man Wins $450,000 Lawsuit After Office Birthday Party Triggered Panic Attack A Kentucky court's judgment creates new precedent in conversations around workplace wellbeing.

By Entrepreneur Staff

entrepreneur daily

In 2019, Kentucky resident Kevin Berling, who suffers from an anxiety disorder, requested that his employer, Gravity Diagnostics, not throw him an office birthday party due to the stress it would trigger.

According to a lawsuit filed by his attorneys, that request was ignored and the company threw him a surprise party on Aug. 7, 2019 anyway.

Related: 4 Expert-Backed Strategies for Managing Anxiety

As Berling predicted, the event caused a panic attack. He left the lunch party to go to his car, where he texted his manager about how upset he was that his request wasn't taken seriously.

The lawsuit states that Berling "was confronted and criticized" in a meeting the next day by his superiors, which triggered another panic attack and resulted in him being sent home.

On Aug. 11, four days after the birthday party, he received a letter in the mail explaining that he was fired "because of the events of the previous week."

Berling's employers told Kentucky news website Link NKY that Berling was fired for violating a "workplace violence policy" and that they stood by the termination, concerned that he would return to work angry and possibly dangerous to coworkers.

Related: How this Entrepreneur Learned to Cope With Anxiety

Berling's lawyer, Tony Bucher, told WKRC that their concerns about violence were unwarranted, as Berling uses coping techniques to calm his emotions, and the termination was more likely an excuse to get rid of someone perceived as not being a team player. "They started giving him a pretty hard time for his response to the birthday celebration, actually accusing him of stealing his co-workers' joy," Bucher said.

A jury sided with Berling, awarding him $450,000 in damages, including $300,000 for mental anguish.

In a statement after the ruling, Bucher explained, "I think the significance for employers is that they need to understand that they shouldn't make assumptions about individuals with mental-health issues. Kevin was an exceptional employee that went above and beyond for his employer, and if they would have taken a step back it would have been clear that he did not present any danger at all."
Entrepreneur Staff

Entrepreneur Staff


Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Editor's Pick

Related Topics

Side Hustle

Getting Laid Off Allowed Him to Focus on His Sentimental Side Hustle. Now He's on Track to Earn Over $700,000 in 2024.

Alaa El Ghatit wasn't fulfilled at his day job. So he started LifeOnRecord to help people record memories and well wishes.

Business News

Should CEOs Take a Pay Cut to Avoid Layoffs and Cutting Jobs? It's Complicated, Experts Say

Former Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata famously took a 50% pay cut in 2013 to avoid layoffs and pay employee salaries.

Business News

Kellogg's CEO Suggests Americans Should 'Eat Cereal For Dinner' During Tough Economic Times

Cereal prices in the U.S. have increased roughly 28% since the beginning of 2020.

Starting a Business

4 Hard Truths You Must Accept to Become Successful

As you buckle up for entrepreneurship, remember – it's not just a journey but an epic adventure towards enduring achievement in the dynamic business world.

Business Ideas

55 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2024

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2024.