4 Considerations When Determining the Best Leadership Structure for Your Business Should you have one leader at the top, or spread decision-making among employees.

By Andre Lavoie

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

How owners organize the management of a small business has a huge effect on internal and external growth. The question is, which leadership structure works best?

By nature, startups tend to start off with a horizontal structure, which follows an employee-centered approach -- fewer management layers with a wide span of authority. On the other hand, as small businesses grow, many adopt the traditional vertical structure, defined by an organizational hierarchy with strong management and subordinate employees.

At ClearCompany, we maintain a fairly horizontal structure and strive to empower employees at every level to be independent and entrepreneurial. We strongly believe in the power of transparency. We've found that sharing more information with our team allows them to make strategically-driven decisions that, in turn, enhance performance.

Related: How to Develop Your Management Style and Assemble the Best Team

There's no right or wrong way to structure a company's leadership. Whether to go with a horizontal or vertical leadership model depends on a number of things, from company vision to size to the overall culture. Here are some pros and cons of each structure to consider, when determining which management style will drive business success:

1. Top-down vs. side by side

Vertical and horizontal leadership structures take very different approaches to decision-making. Because vertically structured organizations have a chain of management, decisions usually take a top-down approach, with major decisions occurring at the top of the chain. For larger organizations, taking a top-down approach when making important decisions can sometimes be easier than waiting for everyone to give their two cents.

The comprehensive nature of the horizontal structure lends itself to teamwork. Rather than following a hierarchy, this side-by-side model of leadership takes down the structural walls to include everyone in the decision-making process. Since the chain of command in a horizontal organization is small -- or even only one layer -- decision-making is often faster and more effective. This is especially true for smaller businesses or companies just starting out.

2. Defined vs. shared

The vertical leadership structure implements an organizational hierarchy based on clearly defined roles. Employees can easily recognize the chain of command and reporting relationships within the company. The CEO sits at the top of the organizational ladder and delegates authority to lower-level managers who then manage employees through clear lines of authority. In short, there's no room for confusion when determining who to report to.

A common frustration with the horizontal leadership structure is that employees don't always know who to report to because so much responsibility is shared across the organization. A flat organization makes it easier for employees to see how their work efforts contribute to the bigger picture, but employees may be less sure about their roles within the company, and project leads can become frustrated by their lack of authority.

Related: How Poor Management Creates Zombie Employees (Infographic)

3. Need-to-know vs. transparent

One of the biggest differences between vertical and horizontal leadership structures is the level of transparency within the organization. Companies that are vertically structured are more likely to share information on a need-to-know basis. Additionally, because vertical companies have so many layers of management, it's easy for information to get muddled as it's passed down the corporate ladder.

Horizontal leadership structures, on the other hand, encourage transparency across all aspects of business. Taking down the structural walls helps streamline communication and collaboration within the workplace -- and boosts employee morale in the process.

Transparency is a natural characteristic of employee-centered organizational structures. For structures based on established hierarchies, a company is as transparent as management makes it.

4. Us vs. them

How do employees feel about each of these organizational structures? The traditional vertical leadership model, commonly seen in larger organizations, can create an "us versus them" feeling in a company, as managers and employees are on very different levels.

The horizontal leadership structure eliminates that feeling by placing more importance on skill proficiency than management hierarchy, so less division exists between upper management and employees.

However, vertically structured companies promote more individual growth, as employees have an opportunity to climb the corporate ladder. Flat organizations don't always have much room for upward mobility, although employees can develop professionally through training and experience.

What do you think? How does your company structure its leadership? Share in the comments section below!

Related: For More Results, Make the Switch to a Minimalist Managerial Style

Wavy Line
Andre Lavoie

Entrepreneur; CEO and Co-Founder, ClearCompany

Andre Lavoie is the CEO of ClearCompany, the talent-management solution that helps companies identify, hire and retain more A players. You can connect with him and the ClearCompany team on Facebook LinkedIn and Twitter.


Editor's Pick

A Father Decided to Change When He Was in Prison on His Son's Birthday. Now His Nonprofit Helps Formerly Incarcerated Applicants Land 6-Figure Jobs.
A Teen Turned His Roblox Side Hustle Into a Multimillion-Dollar Company — Now He's Working With Karlie Kloss and Elton John
3 Mundane Tasks You Should Automate to Save Your Brain for the Big Stuff
The Next Time Someone Intimidates You, Here's What You Should Do
5 Ways to Manage Your Mental Health and Regulate Your Nervous System for Sustainable Success

Related Topics

Business News

After Being Told They Could Work From Home Forever, Employees Made Major Life Changes. Then, a New CEO Ordered Them Back to the Office.

Farmers Group CEO Raul Vargas is facing backlash for the change, but he says being in the office brings more "collaboration" and "innovation."

Business Ideas

The 13 Best Jobs for People With ADHD

Want to find the perfect profession as a person with ADHD? Check out this review of the best jobs for people with ADHD if you need ideas.

Money & Finance

The Spring Cleaning Tips You Need to Keep Your Business Finances Neat All Year Long

Use the five S approach to clean up your business financials this spring and spend the rest of the year totally in charge.

Business News

Hedge Fund Pays NYC Interns $20,000 a Month on Average, Sent to Lavish Palm Beach Kickoff

Citadel is known for its over-the-top parties and company retreats.

Business News

Pete Davidson Says He's 'Figuring It Out' After Buying a $280,000 Boat While 'Very Stoned'

The former "Saturday Night Live" star purchased a used Staten Island Ferry with Colin Jost in January 2022.